3 ms·
They make predictions, but they tend to be more qualitative and less useful for central control than Keynesian policies. The main reason for that is Keynesian
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
They make predictions, but they tend to be more qualitative and less useful for central control than Keynesian policies.
The main reason for that is Keynesian economics reduces the many sectors of our economy to a few simple aggregate quantities - e.g., rather than having demand for housing, demand for pizza, demand for computers, we simply have "aggregate demand". An uncharitable person would say that this is simply because Keynes was not very good at math.
If you simply do this calculus, we should never have a recession. Therefore, Keynesian economics assumes these curves behave in certain tricky ways - this imposes recessions and stimulus comes out as the remedy.
Austrian economics, or at least their more modern variants, does not accept the reduction of a complex economy to simple calculus. It views recessions as being caused by misallocation of resources between sectors (i.e., too much housing, too little something else) and recessions as being caused by a lag [1] in re-adjustment. Fine tuning such a complex system is tricky (not to mention many parameters are unknown), and most predictions would simply be qualitative. Such a system is also not amenable to simple calculus (you need big ODE/graph models), which makes it somewhat unpopular.
[1] An unemployed construction worker may be unwilling to accept a non-construction job or to leave his hometown. Or he may be willing to make such a move, but not know where to move to. Until his attitudes change or he becomes more knowledgeable, he remains unemployed.
- jhpriestley 16y agoAggregate demand is a money quantity, so it is perfectly well-defined. Keynes never tries to add 1 slice of pizza to 1 computer, and in fact goes into great detail about units and definitions in book 2 ("definitions and ideas") of The General Theory. An uncharitable person would say you've probably never even read it.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI did not claim Keynes ignored units. I claimed he reduced the economy to a few aggregate quantities and claimed they are sufficient to make predictions. Statistical physics does much the same thing - they reduce a complex newtonian system of 10^23 particles to a few aggregate quantities: temperature, pressure, etc, and makes predictions based on the aggregates. Keynes tries to do the same thing, reducing a bunch of sectorial demand curves into a single aggregate demand curve. Austrians/Chicagoans believe this reduction is unjustified. I freely admit I've only read a small portion of General Theory, though I've read a bit more by newer Keynesians (Krugman and Thoma are two names that spring to mind).
- jhpriestley 16y agoOkay, I assumed you were talking about the 'aggregation problem' (the aggregation of unlike quantities, rather a common pitfall in economics). If you agree that aggregate demand is a well-defined quantity, then I'm not sure what you're objecting to. You can disagree with a theory based on this curve, but the curve itself requires no justification beyond a proof that it is well-defined.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoAn aggregate theory of any sort has two separate pieces. The first is the definition of the aggregate. The second is a a reduction of the more complicated system to a simplified one based on the aggregate, i.e. showing that theories based on the aggregate quantity are sufficient to predict the world. I'll make the analogy to statistical physics again. You can always define the average temperature and pressure in a vessel. One can come up with simple calculus laws, such as PV=nT and make predictions(remember high school chem?). Sometimes that's an oversimplification, since temperature and pressure vary from place to place within the vessel. Sometimes you can't even use simple gas laws and need to revert to newtonian or quantum mechanics. The belief of Austrians (and myself) is that for the most part, the simple calculus of aggregates is an oversimplification and hides important details necessary to explain the world. One example: you can make a two-sector model of the economy, say [housing, everything else]. In this case, demand is a vector, say [housing demand, other demand]. The demand shock is in housing, and that's where a lot of the unemployment lives (there is some unemployment in "everything else" due to knock-on effects). It's fairly clear to see that stimulus will have different effects depending on whether it is a housing stimulus or an "everything else" stimulus, and that stimulus can mostly only help with the knock-on effects. A theory based solely on aggregate demand is completely incapable of recognizing this, since it doesn't even have the variables to describe it. The AD theory simply studies AD=housing demand + everything else demand, and tries to go from there. If, for example, housing demand = alpha x AD, and everything else demand = beta x AD, an AD-based theory would be very useful since it would just hide unnecessary complexity. If that isn't the case, then an AD-based theory hides necessary complexity and gives the wrong answers.