3 ms·
> It’s better to have no management than unqualified management. If you’ve ever been on a project with more than 1 or 2 people without a manager—or where the m
by mcphage 9y ago
> It’s better to have no management than unqualified management.
If you’ve ever been on a project with more than 1 or 2 people without a manager—or where the manager doesn’t do their job—you would know how insane this sounds. It does not work. Once you’re coordinating groups of people you need a manager to keep them working together towards a common goal.
- TomMarius 9y agoThat's not true in general, I've been in environments where a team of 10+ very motivated individuals worked together without a manager. It's not common though.
- the-pigeon 9y agoBut you still have people doing the job of a manager. Someone has to set meetings, someone has to call out issues, someone has to communicate with upper management and other teams. No-manager really means distributed management or an informal manager. Because the essential work a manager does has to be done by someone.
- mjw1007 9y agoSure, that work still has to be done. But if you start off by thinking of it as "the job of a manager" then you're assuming your conclusion.
- sheepmullet 9y ago> Once you’re coordinating groups of people you need a manager to keep them working together towards a common goal. What is a manager? I've worked on many successful teams (including projects with 100+ devs) without formal managers in the typical hierarchy sense. You just need a combination of program managers, project managers, product managers, and architects.
- mcphage 9y agoSo you’ve worked on successful teams without managers—they just had... managers, managers, managers, and architects?
- sheepmullet 9y agoThe individual tasks a manager does are important - my point is they can be handled under many different roles. All of those roles are quite different from the traditional manager - for example none of those "managers" had strong authority over the developers day to day work the way a manager typically would. Nor did they speak on behalf of the developers.
- marcinzm 9y ago>Once you’re coordinating groups of people you need a manager to keep them working together towards a common goal. No, you need someone to coordinate them. It does not need to be your manager. Plenty of matrix and matrix like organizations which have split the two. Managers just need to enforce who that person is and resolve people (not product or business) disputes.
- kabdib 9y agoThe best teams I've been on have done well without much management at all. Mostly the managers were there to shield the team, the rest of the time the managers just got out of the way. On the very best projects, individuals will step up and lead for a while, then decide to do other things and let someone else run the show a little. Maybe it will be feature ownership, or to handle a different phase of a product in its ship cycle. (Meanwhile there will be managers behind the scenes, hopefully not many, making sure that forms are getting filled out, HR duties are attended to, and nonsense meetings are canceled and kept canceled). Most of the places I've worked could have used less management. A lot less.