3 ms·
In a democracy there is at least a well defined process for removing leaders which is outside those leader’s control. Even then, I think the US system of term l
by simonh 9y ago
In a democracy there is at least a well defined process for removing leaders which is outside those leader’s control. Even then, I think the US system of term limits has its benefits and think it might be advantageous here in the UK. After all both Margaret Thatcher and Tony Blair, who at least in their early terms seemed to be effective leaders, became clearly out of touch towards the ends end even in the eyes of many of their own supporters.
However in an autocracy with no other clearly defined mechanism to constrain the power of a leader, term limits at least fulfil that function. The danger is that with no fixed constraints or limits on power in such a system, if a monster gains power or if power creates a monster, there’s nothing anyone can do. The question is, does the risk of that happening outweigh the risk of ejecting a capable leader from power earlier than necessary.
So even if you think Hu a Jintao is the best leader for China now and after 2 terms, the precedent could lead to someone you think is a terrible leader gaining perpetual power later.
- stupidcar 9y agoI think term limits are a weak defence against autocratic leaders, because in such situations the separation of powers necessary to maintain the constitutional check usually doesn't exist. I.e. there's no independent judiciary or opposition bloc in the legislature. In a system like China, these institutions are politically inert facades, designed to outwardly resemble their democratic counterparts, but with actual power remaining wholly invested in the executive, which is wholly controlled by the ruling party. The real checks on an autocratic leader are rivalries within the ruling party's elite, and once a leader like Xi has achieved dominance there, then amending the constitution to remove the term limit clause is trivial.
- simonh 9y agoCompletely agree, term limits are a weak check but better than nothing. It reserves power to a political elite that control the succession process, but at least that’s better than a single individual.