4 ms·
I'm always a little skeptical of these sorts of surveys because it's hard to tease out what people believe about themselves because it's true vs. what people be
by nostrademons 9y ago
I'm always a little skeptical of these sorts of surveys because it's hard to tease out what people believe about themselves because it's true vs. what people believe about themselves because it's useful.
I remember that when I was a new grad, there was a very large part of myself that held a realistic appraisal of my abilities and was therefore scared shitless about my ability to make it in the working world. I was very careful to never let that part of me out in interviews - or, for that matter, to anyone. Confidence only works if you keep up the illusion so thoroughly that it ceases to be an illusion.
And it worked. I got a job at a financial software startup, and then was put in charge of projects that no new grad should ever have been put in charge of. I grew into the role. I left to go found a startup, which is also something that someone with 2 years of work experience had no business doing. That worked too - I may not have been qualified to found a startup, but when I folded it up, I was a lot more qualified as an engineer than most of my other peers with 4 years of work experience. So Google hired me to work on the front page of the search engine, and I grew into that role too.
The majority of my classmates let their accurate perceptions of what they were actually qualified to do govern what they applied to do, and as a result, many were still struggling to get into a career 10 years later. By that point, your self-perception has become reality, and it's much harder to convince potential employers to take the risk that you'll grow into the position. Then they wake up and realize that everybody's faking it and their new manager isn't actually all that much more skilled than them, but (barring a career reset like going to grad school) it's difficult to reset people's perceptions.
- Zanni 9y agoRelated: these aren't even the competencies that employers have selected as most important, only the ones that the firm doing the survey selected. So how important are they really? Where do, for instance, "Career Management" and "Global/Intercultural Fluency" stack up against "Can actually do the job we're hiring them to do, e.g. program a computer"?
- sandworm101 9y agoIntercultural fluency is code for people that are less likely to say the stupid things, either to customers or coworkers, that result in lawsuits. Career managment is code for people who can maintain professional qualifications without supervision, who book the course for themselves before something expires.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoCode words for sussing out leaders vs those who need direction. Know how to grow, know when to bite your tongue.
- kartan 9y ago> Confidence only works if you keep up the illusion so thoroughly that it ceases to be an illusion. This was the same for me as new manager. I was less confident that I let interviewers see. But in the end I got that confidence for real. "Fake it till you make it"
- JCSato 9y agoHad the exact same thought coming here, couldn't have said it better.
- ericmcer 9y ago"What is your greatest weakness?". Everyone is expected to lie or warp reality a bit on this question. Interviewing is just a game and people learn pretty quickly to give the answers interviewers want to hear. The alternative to overconfidence is not great.
- bpchaps 9y agoI answered this in one of my first interviews with, "My greatest weakness is my inability to focus on things for an extended period of time." The interviewer told me never to do that, but appreciated my candor and extended an offer, though I didn't take the job. Sometimes it actually works to be honest instead of treating it as a game. :)
- dvtv75 9y agoThis leaves me conflicted. I've noted here (quite) a number of times that I have a disability that impacts my ability to absorb chunks of written material. I've had an occupational therapist tell me that I shouldn't work in CS or IT (I have a CS degree in spite of that), and several doctors have told me I should stay away from the field, while others have told me that just go with whatever works and don't tell employers I have this disability. I prefer to be honest, but at the same time I also like to eat most days. I have an interview for a job in a few days, and no clue what I should do. If they don't ask, do I bring it up? What do I tell them? Most employers in the city are highly discriminatory against people with a disability, even if it means they're not hiring the most qualified one. (I'm not actually seeking advice here, just musing online.)
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoIf they don't ask, do I bring it up? Most people without a disability would focus on their positive attributes, I can't see why you should be any different.
- bpchaps 9y agoIf the companies that you're interviewing for aren't accepting of the way you are, then it might be useful to question whether those companies are for you. Yes, it's difficult to think this way when the specifics of your circumstances are difficult, but it still might be a lifestyle worth pursuing. Lentils/rice/chick peas are a super cheap way of living on a budget ;). It's exceptionally difficult having disabilities, especially when trying to relate it in a professional environment. Though, I've found my own disabilities have been very useful in figuring out what it is that I really want out of a career and life. Cheers and good luck.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoHave you considered that perhaps your self-appraisal was unrealistically negative? Your post suggests that either most people are capable of far more than work situations demand of them, or that you were more capable in practice than you appreciated at the time. It's either that, or you were very, very lucky - which is possible, but not necessarily probable.