5 ms·
Bering Sea loses half its sea ice over two weeks
- sintaxi 9y agoWhat we are seeing here is the next climate scam. Arctic sea ice thickness has grown substantially in recent years and not even ice-breakers can get through the arctic reliably these days yet submarines were surfacing at the North pole in the 50's which would be completely impossible today. Never forget that Al Gore insisted the ice would be completely gone by 2013 in an effort to gain political power.
- Gustomaximus 9y ago2018 now has the second lowest sea ice volume on record: http://neven1.typepad.com/blog/volume-and-concentration/ http://neven1.typepad.com/blog/volume-and-concentration/ Also because Al Gore was wrong on one statement, or has incorrect timing, doesn't mean Climate change is not real. Nor does it mean he announced his concern sfor political power. I provided some information showing artic ice is on the decrease. And I haven't down-voted you yet as I dont like this internet thing where people down vote opinions against their view. Why dont you provide some real data/facts to support this view that climate change is a scam?
- sintaxi 9y agoThanks for the benefit of doubt. If you have 7 minutes this explains it better than I can. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFwie-kC8uc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFwie-kC8uc Not sure how those volume records are measured when you look at a view of satellite data you can clearly see the ice is thicker overall especially near the North Pole and Russian coast.
- Gustomaximus 9y agoI had a look at his. The problem with this (and similar seen) is they pick very specific things, and attempt to make this as an argument against the whole. In this video for example, they mention a few times the 'missing satellite data' conspiracy from the 70's. You know we only put a man on the moon in '69 right? And they were using slider rulers still then. While I acknowledge this be wrong it seems entirely realistic to decide systems before then were inaccurate and focus on reliable data from '79. And if you look at longer sea ice data below, you can see this increase during the 70's is still part of a long term decline. So this video is selecting a small upward increase and making it out NASA avoided this period when the video creators could seem they are doing the exact same thing, avoiding previous period data to make theirs agree with a point. See below longer data. Arctic sea ice data: https://www.carbonbrief.org/guest-post-piecing-together-arctic-sea-ice-history-1850 https://www.carbonbrief.org/guest-post-piecing-together-arct... I find the more interesting skeptics look at holistic weather patterns at geological time frames. Something like this article which seems to have some merit to my limited knowledge. Thought the weakness (flaw?) seems they merge geological time frame to the current short term as though changes were this rapid. So sure a 4C temp swing doesn't seem much against millions of years of fluctuation, but our change in happening in 100 years and we dont have a clue where it will go in 10,000 years type thing. Very different. Example article here: http://joannenova.com.au/2010/02/the-big-picture-65-million-years-of-temperature-swings/ http://joannenova.com.au/2010/02/the-big-picture-65-million-... Overall I've considered this a bit. So many people write climate change deniers off as a bit stupid or religions fanatics. I've found many climate change deniers to be intelligent people but they have a tenancy to focus on the specific, not the broad. If you are going to push climate change denial first ask yourself why have sea levels gone up 8mm in 35 years. Why are we getting record warm years again and again. Why are glaciers that have always been know to exist disappearing across the globe. Why is ocean acidy up 30% and what happens when this reaches saturation. And if there is a scam, whats the motive of the people saying protect our climate? To me it seems there is much more motive and resource behind people who dont want the world to change behaviours. And truly, I acknowledge I'm not an expert and there is a limited probability it could be larger weather natural patterns creating this rapid shift. Here is the key question; can we take the chance?
- sintaxi 9y ago> And if there is a scam, whats the motive of the people saying protect our climate? The motive appears to be money and power. Al Gore's net worth went from 1.7M to 300M in 15 years. Looking back at Inconvenient Truth it make one unproven claim that CO2 was accelerating warming and the rest was entirely appeal to emotion. > can we take the chance? The alternative is we an lift the 3rd world out of poverty which would be awesome and it would stabilize the global birth-rate. Seems worth the risk given how terrible the climate predictions have been.
- e40 9y agoThe motive appears to be money and power. Al Gore's net worth went from 1.7M to 300M in 15 years. Looking back at Inconvenient Truth it make one unproven claim that CO2 was accelerating warming and the rest was entirely appeal to emotion. He made $30M from selling Apple shares, he got in 2003. I call that "the power of having been VPOTUS" and nothing more. He also sold Current TV for $500M. I think you want to see what you want to see, and no comment here will turn you away from that.
- ThomPete 9y agoHe sold Current TV to the Saudis mind you which he got a lot of criticism for and haven't really been able to respond to without it feeling a little weird given his stance on fossil fuel. Everyone sees what they want to see but once you dig into it you realize that there is more to the story than just being VPOTUS here.
- __s 9y agoGlad to see someone putting in the effort to patiently explain this 'anecdotes are not evidence' logic. Another anecdote based client denial one is the 'Greenland was green' anecdote, generally told with exaggeration: https://skepticalscience.com/greenland-used-to-be-green.htm https://skepticalscience.com/greenland-used-to-be-green.htm
- ThomPete 9y ago"And if there is a scam, whats the motive of the people saying protect our climate?" Well, one thing could be funding. This subject is highly politicised Its a much more complex discussion which I learned when I decided to dig into it and understand what the skeptics actually was saying (instead of what the media and many climate scientists say they are saying. I always get suspicious when someone claims there is no discussion that always means there is one. Especially something based on computer models. One thing I learned which helped me understand the discussion a little better was that very few if any so called "climate deniers" say that there isn't climate change. In fact, they all say that of course there is climate change and as long as there is a climate there is climate change. Furthermore, most of them completely acknowledge humans affect the climate however and this is where it gets really fuzzy, the debate is how much and if it's enough to be concerned about. Once you dig into the data you realize there are so many uncertainties involved in this and so much guess work. The ICSC have had to change their forecasts several times to much less problematic temperature rises in the future. Even more, confusing to the layman, the arguments for on the "catastrophic climate change is coming" is changing and actually have been changing. That reminds me a little bit of the creationism which evolved into intelligent design discussion. There is something that needs more transparency if the argument changes. Now it's the ocean we have to worry about. I am just a lay man and all of this might have a perfectly rational explanation but I have to say that I have changed my perspective on this quite a lot once i digged into it. Then there is a whole other discussion which people like Alex Epstein is proposing about the morality of ex. oil and the fact that removing fossil fuels right now would do more harm than good. It's a difficult discussion because people are so tribal about it which leaves very little room for freethinking and trying to explore different perspectives without being labeled either a climated denier or a treehugger.
- codecamper 9y agoEven if you think there is a 20% chance climate change exists, wouldn't it be a good strategy to try & fix it? It's a 20% chance of massive, horrible problems. Especially given that you are a technologist & the solution here is better technology.
- tomohawk 9y agoI've heard this argument (something bad might be happening! we don't know the solution, but we must try Something!) about so many things over so many years, and it has not ever once resulted in a positive change. It's an argument from fear instead of knowledge.
- lostapathy 9y agoI always look at it from a pollution angle. Even if global warming is a farce (I don’t think it is), cleaner air is a win. Cleaner water is a win. Etc. If you don’t want a greener world for climate reasons, why not a cleaner world for your lungs?
- tomohawk 9y agoRemembering the days of very polluting cars and leaded gas, etc, its great to not have to deal with that. Definitely a win. But, you have to consider the cost and possible implications of any change, or you're actually more likely to make the situation worse, or end up wasting a lot of time/money/lives.
- ThomPete 9y agoThen you should be happy because the water and the air have never been cleaner. The places where pollution is the worst is poor places, not rich places which indicate that making societies more prosperous is better, not worse for the environment. This includes access to cheap energy which currently also means coal and fossil fuels. The problem is that when you present this to those who are worried about the climate they don't actually rejoice and say, phew great. Instead, they get upset which I find weird.
- 9y ago
- jonsen 9y agoSubstantially thickening sea ice since the 50's would indicate climate change, or?
- sintaxi 9y agoClimate changes, there just is no climate crisis in my opinion.
- epaga 9y agoCompletely impossible like...this video? https://youtu.be/PSE9Zjh364M https://youtu.be/PSE9Zjh364M
- sintaxi 9y agoNorth Pole 1958 https://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/uss-skate-open-water.jpg https://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/uss-skat... North Pole 1987 https://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/3-subs-north-pole-1987.jpg https://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/3-subs-n...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- detaro 9y agoThere have been submarines surfacing around the north pole in recent years though.
- Proven 9y agolol
- tomohawk 9y agoOr, is it just alarmism? https://notalotofpeopleknowthat.wordpress.com/2018/02/21/noaa-continue-to-pump-out-arctic-lies/#more-32408 https://notalotofpeopleknowthat.wordpress.com/2018/02/21/noa...
- spodek 9y agoThe meaningful question is what you, the person reading these words, will do about it. Most will think something like "I want to help, but if I act and no one else does it won't make a difference" or "they should pass laws to stop people from doing what causes this and after they do I'll act." To act against your values to follow others is the opposite of leadership. Some will realize that their actions can make a difference, that they are responsible for the results of their actions -- flying, overheating or overcooling their homes, dietary choices, etc -- and they will choose to hurt others less. One of my biggest discoveries is that making those choices improved my life. I thought they would feel like sacrifice, and they did in the short term, but in the long term they improved my life. My diet is more delicious for avoiding packaged food and eating from local farms. My life has more adventure and cultural exchange for not flying. It's not what you stop doing, but what you replace it with. In other words, there is no dichotomy between polluting less and improving your life.
- cardamomo 9y agoYes, personal choices are important. I believe that many people around with world will need to make significant changes to their lifestyles, whether by choice to lessen their carbon footprint or by necessity to adapt to new realities in the coming decades. I'm wary of that common strain of techno-utopianism that takes the stance that we can maintain our current lifestyles if only we switch to electric cars, renewable energy, and compostable shopping bags. But we also need to think about what choices are available to people and what we can do on a larger scale to confront carbon pollution and global warming. Let's think critically about personal choices as they relate to climate change: - Does my family have access to quality, local food? - Do I have enough information about my the way my produce, grains, etc. were grown to make a purchase decision based on its climate impact? - What is the transportation infrastructure like where I live? - How does my local, state, or national government incentivize car or home ownership? ...and so on. EDIT: Formatting.
- spodek 9y ago> But we also need to think about what choices are available to people As long as people act on what they can and not bog themselves down in analysis. The main reason is that the more people act, the more they find more opportunities to act more, whereas the more they analyze, the less they act. In an entrepreneurial community like HN, it's like realizing that acting on your venture is the best way to progress. Of course, that doesn't mean to act thoughtlessly, but you don't have to think much for most low hanging fruit. I would rephrase all your questions from passive analysis to active. For example, instead of > Does my family have access to quality, local food? I suggest "What can I do to increase my family's access to quality, local food?" Instead of > Do I have enough information about my the way my produce, grains, etc. were grown to make a purchase decision based on its climate impact? I suggest "What can I do to improve how food is produced around me..." We're not passive recipients of what systems created based on no-longer-credible beliefs about the Earth. We are active participants and can influence these systems.
- andrew_ 9y agoIt's really disappointing to see that this article has been upvoted. No, not because I have theories to share, I'm not an armchair scientist on any side of the debate. But because these kinds of politically and socially charged (if one thinks anything on climate change isn't at this point - wow) articles were the primary reason I stopped visiting Slashdot. With so much quality content flowing through this site, the last thing we need is more like this article being upvoted.
- cardamomo 9y agoResearch about climate change may certainly be politically and socially charged, but we're not going to make progress in addressing it by burying articles that share recent findings. It's not the science that we need to debate -- at least not the general trends and forecasts -- but rather the political and social causes and implications of climate change. Personally, I am always happy to see articles such as this posted here, because it at least means a community of smart, critical thinkers are aware of climate issues.
- andrew_ 9y agoHeh. Post a dissenting opinion, watch the karma disappear. Surely I can't be the only one that thinks we see enough of this from all angles on a daily basis.
- pillfill 9y agoThere's nothing inherently political about the this article or the science in general here. There is, however, a very concerted effort to convince people that the science of climate change 'is political' in order to give those who find the issue uncomfortable license to question the legitimacy of the entire field of study. That's as dangerous as it is absurd, and it's important that it's challenged whenever it's encountered.