4 ms·
If I understand it correctly the Trump admin wants to institute something more akin to the AU and CA visa systems --preferring people who fill skills voids in t
by mc32 9y ago
If I understand it correctly the Trump admin wants to institute something more akin to the AU and CA visa systems --preferring people who fill skills voids in the US. It's not a return to pre-60's policies.
I think this aligns with most other modern economies out there. If anything, we're the outlier allowing randoms to come in without regard to skills or means.
- aianus 9y agoWhy is this controversial? Why would Americans prefer immigrants chosen at random through a lottery vs. those who are skilled and vetted? Or worse, giving illegal immigrants immunity?
- mc32 9y agoI don't think it's controversial. Any country I've been to that can control ingress does control ingress and will promptly deport people who didn't enter the proper way. Japan, S Korea, China, Singapore, etc., would be extremely hard for anyone to work off the books without having to resort to the underworld. Otherwise you may last a month or two, but most people will get kicked out without a visa. What's more regular police have the authority and responsibility to make sure anyone without a visa gets expelled.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rjsw 9y agoDoes that work even if the visa-less person can't remember which country they came from ?
- mc32 9y agoThis would be so rare that it'd be of little impact. That said, they would likely investigate who this person was, who originally employed them, and use those records along with any other trails left at points of entry and use that info to return the overstayer.
- sangnoir 9y ago> Why is this controversial? Why would Americans prefer immigrants chosen at random through a lottery vs. those who are skilled and vetted FYI: the immigrants who are chosen at random by the lottery are thoroughly vetted. They go through criminal and medical screening. All they win is the opportunity to be interviewed at a US consulate/embassy after the screenings; the interviewing officer (a US diplomat) considers skills and resources and decides whether or not to grant a visa. It's not as if they win today and buy a ticket tomorrow.
- adrianmacneil 9y agoNot entirely true. For the diversity visa (green card lottery), there are (extensive) medical and background checks, but the US consulate does not consider skills and resources beyond verifying that you meet the minimum requirements (high school diploma). The consulate interview for this category is basically a rubber stamp. However, as others pointed out, the DV is a small fraction of green cards granted, and the process for family based immigration may differ. Source: I went through this process.
- sangnoir 9y ago> the US consulate does not consider skills and resources beyond verifying that you meet the minimum requirements (high school diploma). This is wrong; they use their judgement to gauge the likelihood of you ending up being a "public charge". Even if you meet the bare minimum (high school), but have no/inadequate skills and/or you are broke, I guarantee that you will not get a visa. This is what I meant by "skills and resources". It's most certainly not a "rubber-stamp", but might have seemed like it to you because you met the requirements.
- adrianmacneil 9y agoSource? Also, even if they verify you meet some minimum bar of being able to support yourself (which I was not asked about in my interview, other than turning up looking generally presentable), this is still a far cry from a more rigorous points-based immigration system. Per GP, DV immigrants are still basically chosen "at random".
- ta76567656 9y agoWhat do you mean randoms without regard to skills or means? You need either a family based justification (spouse or parent, mainly) or labor certification to apply for a green card. It's not a government defined point system, but an employer has to deem you worth the trouble to sponsor. Indirectly, at least, that measures the need for the applicants skills. Means are also examined. E.g. to get a student visa you have to prove you can pay for tuition and living expenses without relying on working in the US.
- theandrewbailey 9y ago> What do you mean randoms without regard to skills or means? Perhaps mc32 means the diversity visa program? https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/us-visas/immigrate/diversity-visa-program-entry.html https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/us-visas/immigrat...
- Jedi72 9y agoThis is a tiny fraction of new visas, but significantly opens up the possibility for genuine diversity immigration
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- learc83 9y agoWe don't allow people to come in without means. You can't even bring your spouse in unless you make a certain multiple over the federal poverty level.
- mc32 9y agoPeople (relatives) sponsored by lawful immigrants are not means tested.
- newfoundglory 9y agoThe sponsoring immigrant is means tested on their behalf.
- mc32 9y agoAt some point those people will be responsible for themselves and the sponsor's responsibility expires.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoOnly after the person either becomes a US citizen or has done 10 years of qualifying work.
- learc83 9y agoThat's not correct. 1st, the citizen who is sponsoring an immigrant is means tested. 2nd, UCIS must use their judgment to determine the immigrant has the means to support themselves and won't become a public charge. This applies for all immigrants applying for permanent residency. Also I'm not just talking about relatives sponsored by lawful immigrants, I'm also talking about relatives sponsored by citizens. Btw unless a permanent resident is sponsoring their minor child, sponsoring another immigrant is generally a multi decade process. Even the spouses of green card holders aren't considered immediate family and the average wait time when sponsoring is over a decade.