3 ms·
Fourth paragraph: "Sometimes I think there are direct biological factors at work—a type of education, feeding, and physical training which has produced a new ki
by mkempe 9y ago
Fourth paragraph: "Sometimes I think there are direct biological factors at work—a type of education, feeding, and physical training which has produced a new kind of human being with an imbalance in his nature."
She's ascribing an inclination to Nazism to feeding and physical training. There is no charitable interpretation.
Added [I'm blocked from responding]:
Near the end: "L is the strongest natural-born Nazi in this room... He has the brains of Neanderthal man, but he has an infallible instinct for power."
She constantly ascribes adherence or willingness to adhere to Nazism to a biological cause -- being born, one's feeding, a physical training, Neanderthal man, or instinct.
This is not how to understand Nazism, or its causes; nor is it how to fight it.
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> First paragraph: "I have come to know the types: the born Nazis, ..." [emphasis added] > Fourth paragraph: "Sometimes I think there are direct biological factors at work—a type of education, feeding, and physical training which has produced a new kind of human being with an imbalance in his nature." It's obvious that she's talking about upbringing rather than genetics, despite the word choice. You're being way too literal.
- mkempe 9y agoThere is no charitable interpretation possible for "born Nazis."
- MereInterest 9y agoThe distinction made, throughout the article and all the descriptions it gives, is between those who would be a Nazi were it profitable to do so, and those who would be a Nazi wholeheartedly. The former are Nazis by circumstance, while the latter are those termed as "born Nazis". It does not refer to one's birth or heritage, but the enthusiasm with which one would join a despicable movement.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoShe says repeatedly that Nazism is not genetic but is potentially rooted in the earliest upbringing. When she talks about "young D," "the only born Nazi in the room," she says a lot about his upbringing and nothing whatsoever about his heritage. That's what "born" means to Dorothy Thompson. The word "born" is clearly an awkward choice--perhaps it worked better in the idiom of 1941--but you're not doing any good by ignoring context and stubbornly insisting on a literal dictionary reading.
- mkempe 9y agoActually, there is not a single mention of genes or "genetic" in that article. What are you referring to? Your interpretation of the word "born" is bizarre. She is repeatedly describing someone's Nazism to be directly caused by biological breeding and processes (such as feeding, physical training, or Neanderthal brains).
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoHang on, what are you actually arguing for? I thought blaming politics on genetics was what you were upset about in the first place. Are you actually saying it's immoral to say that the circumstances of a person's upbringing can affect their adult behavior? Because that goes way beyond just misinterpreting the article.
- psyc 9y agoThere certainly is, since that phrase is almost always used figuratively, to mean "that really suits them." You seem to have decided to choose this instance as the one time it absolutely couldn't be figurative. Focusing on one word is poor rhetoric.
- Natsu 9y agoHow are education, feeding or physical training biological factors? That sentence is very confusing to me.