3 ms·
I interpret that there is an implication in what is described in the article that, when you set the region on your apple device, you get region specific iCloud
by motohagiography 9y ago
I interpret that there is an implication in what is described in the article that, when you set the region on your apple device, you get region specific iCloud keys provisioned to it.
If that were the case, there is no reason why you couldn't provision from to an HSM domain that hadn't had its keys shredded.
The implied architecture is there is a secure element on the phone with a unique key provisioned to it during manufacture - likely one that is derived from one of the HSM keys at Apple. However, since Apple cannot produce this individual device key themselves to do 3rd party device decryption, they must generate keys randomly in SE hardware on the device, using the user PIN as a derivation component - and somehow use SE firmware to set a fuse on the number of PIN tries. I don't know specifically how Apple does this, but the list of secure/viable approaches is short. (edit: unnecessary if they shred hsm keys.)
I don't doubt Apple's integrity on this, given the heat they have taken over it in the west. But an "adaptation" of their infrastructure to serve that regional market wouldn't surprise me either.
I'm skeptical of any scheme, and one that isn't presented in BAN logic tends to mean protocol designers have handwaved over where they are hiding things. Good examples of this notation are here. (http://www.lsv.fr/Software/spore/table.html http://www.lsv.fr/Software/spore/table.html).
If they have weakened the scheme, the technical ways Apple may have conceded to Chinese requirements, are all discoverable.
Breakable? I doubt that's viable given the security difference is an HSM with shredded keys vs. one where the keys still exist somewhere (probably in a duplicate HSM that operates the decryption service for Chinese govt). So still at least as good as any EMV payment system.
We can speculate about how this is implemented but reality is tech companies while ubiquitous, are not sovereign. Yet, anyway.