5 ms·
What saddens me about wind is that it destroys the landscape. You used to be able to drive across Kansas on I-70 and just look at the emptiness of the Plains, n
by exabrial 9y ago
What saddens me about wind is that it destroys the landscape. You used to be able to drive across Kansas on I-70 and just look at the emptiness of the Plains, now the drive is dotted with wind turbines nearly the entire way.
[Ironically, the EPA was harassing gas companies in Kansas about drilling rigs disrupting the breeding habits of the greater prairie chicken. Not sure if the same happened to the wind companies]
I'm happy to see renewables, but they are coming at a cost.
- s_kilk 9y agoYou know what else will destroy the landscape (and to say nothing of the human capacity to enjoy it)? Climate change.
- rudedogg 9y agoKansas is a bad example with all the earthquake issues!
- madengr 9y agoBetter to have several small ones than a single big one.
- nerdponx 9y agoIt's hard to be sad about natural processes doing their natural process thing. Or did we cut down all the trees and dig up all the grass that was preventing the soil from blowing away?
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoOP is not saddened by the existence of air currents, but by 'wind' as an energy source, specifically the tall turbines that extract wind energy. One thing that I do appreciate is that most wind energy installations bury their cables. It's only a few percent more expensive than poles, but looks so much better and has fewer maintenance needs. It's a tragedy of economics that we as a society have selected elevated transmission lines.
- maxerickson 9y agoDrive along the giant freeway admiring the natural landscape?
- tibbetts 9y agoI can’t speak to Kansas, but driving across Spain I found the wind turbines a pleasant part of the landscape. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
- ghouse 9y agoI can speak to Kansas. The land owners appreciate the rents paid, and the counties appreciate the property tax base and jobs that come with the turbines.
- Feniks 9y agoYeah here in Europe lots of farmers are happy with wind turbines on their land. It helps them earn a stable income.
- DrScump 9y agodriving across Spain I found the wind turbines a pleasant part of the landscape Don Quixote, not so much.
- eigenvector 9y agoHydro power floods huge areas of land and destroys fisheries. Fossil fuels produce harmful air pollution that kills both wildlife and people, in addition to the long term effects of climate change. All energy sources have impacts, at least with wind once you decommission the plant the landscape is left largely intact. Try doing that with a hydro reservoir or open pit coal mine.
- jefflombardjr 9y agoThe Good Rain by Timothy Egan is a great read related to this if anyone wants more perspective on how hydropower impacts the environment.
- skybrian 9y agoI don't know, this is sort of like the people who didn't like the Eiffel tower. Seems rather subjective? http://articles.latimes.com/1987-04-23/news/mn-722_1_eiffel-tower http://articles.latimes.com/1987-04-23/news/mn-722_1_eiffel-...
- ldiracdelta 9y agoI agree. Wind machines are a landscape blight, as well as being massive bird choppers. Solar on all south-facing roofs and consideration of altering designs to create nice south-facing roof faces is where renewable should be accomplished. So long serene rolling hills of grass and wheat; hello nasty looking tech.
- pjc50 9y ago> as well as being massive bird choppers This is a fairly minor issue that the planners are usually required to mitigate as much as possible, and the non-renewable sources have a significant cost to bird habitats as well. The various bird protection societies are usually cautiously in favour of wind power provided it's not in a sensitive habitat. It turns out that glass-windowed skyscrapers and domestic cats are far more deadly to birds. Monocultural wheat fields are also a highly artificial industrial landscape, just a more familiar one.
- Animats 9y agoExcept for Altamont Pass. It's one of the few breaks in the California coastal range, so it's a big migratory bird corridor. It was one of the first big wind farm areas, and it has row after row of small wind machines for several miles. At peak, it had 5,000 wind turbines in a valley that's less than a mile wide. It's a Veg-O-Matic for birds. The little wind turbines are being replaced with fewer and bigger ones, which are less of a hazard to birds.
- specialist 9y agoI've read that painting the windmills white attracts insects, which attracts their predators. I dunno if anyone's experimented with other colors, to see impact on avian mortality.
- Frondo 9y agoThey aren't massive bird choppers. That's a persistent myth from some very early wind farm that used short turbines with small, faster-moving blades.
- sandworm101 9y agoChickens perhaps dont care as much about windmills than they do about noisy/smelly drilling rigs. The mills probably do kill a few chickens but not in the same way as pollution. Note that these turbines are near the highways for a reason. Those who care enough about the view to get out of thier cars will always find windmill-free vistas.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoThat reason being the presence of long straight right-of ways and easy maintenance access, right?
- sandworm101 9y agoOr that if you are going to bring big heavy things in by truck, closer is always better.
- Terr_ 9y ago> destroys the landscape On the other hand, consider the character of the landscape knowing that anyone can see it from a public highway. What you saw had already stopped being wilderness. It's like receiving a bouquet of flowers and then complaining when they don't last. The same underlying changes that brought you the experience is the one that ensures it is temporary.
- zimzam 9y agoAcres and acres of corn, soybean & wheat fields aren't natural landscape either.
- exabrial 9y agoIt's hard to tell sometimes whether someone is being sarcastic, or just truly ignorant. If you're sarcastic, well played, if you're serious, you probably need to get out of your echochamber and travel a little bit!
- lifeformed 9y agoI find the wind turbines to be really cool to look at, at least from my experience with driving through central Oregon. The scale of each one, and the quantity of them are really awe inspiring. Maybe it's just the novelty of it though. But I really enjoy coming across a field of them.