3 ms·
Applying this paradox in reverse (which is paraphrasing the wiki article) - if introducing energy efficiency measures causes energy use to go down then someone
by roenxi 9y ago
Applying this paradox in reverse (which is paraphrasing the wiki article) - if introducing energy efficiency measures causes energy use to go down then someone needs to ask probing questions about what is going on. Increased efficiency should be linked, all else equal, to increased use of a resource.
- topbarcolor 9y agoIt's not hard to find examples where this "rule" doesn't seem to hold. If you give me water heated for free, I may shower twice on some days, but I will not take infinite hot showers. If you gave me shoes that cause less ablation of the pavement I walk on, I wouldn't find other ways to remove the same amount of material, I would simply use up less resources wherever I go, being none the wiser.
- heavenlyblue 9y agoThe parent does miss the point of market saturation, but I think that's on purpose, since it makes the question more complicated. For example, a reversal: nobody would drive their cars at all if the fuel prices would be the same for 5 seconds of driving as it is for a distance of 1000 miles now.
- rm445 9y agoDo you think such a private individual's behaviour holds for all society? First example: if lots of people had that free hot water, there would pretty soon be companies offering them money for the use of it. A bitcoin miner hooked up to a stirling engine under the hot tap, perhaps? Second example: shoe materials are probably fungible for other petrochemical products. Reduced-wear elastomers might result in fewer pairs of shoes wearing out but higher demand in other markets.
- roenxi 9y agoActually, Jeveron's paradox would hold in the case you mentioned. Someone who gave you heated water would give it to you with an implicit quota otherwise a rational actor use an infinite amount of it. If I actually had free no-holds-barred heated water, I'd run a pipe down to the local laundry and sell it at a profit. That is the rational response - the reason you don't see people doing that is because nobody offers free heated water at scale. Your mistake here is thinking that resources have an implicit purpose (hot water => warm showers). If that were true, Jeveron's paradox would not hold. The paradox holds because once something becomes more abundant, it can be used for totally new activities.
- srtjstjsj 9y agoIf hot water were free, you couldn't sell it. There is a point at which people don't need more water; they aren't Singularity-minded water maximizers.
- Isinlor 9y agoIn communist countries, hot water was sort of free i.e. the cost was shared. People were having open windows during winter in order to have fresh air and heating in order to have warmth, also heating outside as a by-product :) . Hot water usage went drastically down in building where capitalist rules were introduced and water meters were installed per flat.
- danieltillett 9y agoIntroducing energy efficiency measures does cause usage to go down in the short term, but assuming demand is elastic, then it will go up over time as people consume more. Where Jevons Paradox has most utility is showing the futility of unilateral individual action. Don't think you are doing anything to help the environment by turning off that light switch.
- omgwtfbyobbq 9y agoTurning off a light switch isn't futile, it's just not optimal. What you're describing can happen, but isn't common. In that situation, someone using less decreases price such that someone else uses more to the point where price recovers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_elasticity_of_demand#Effect_on_total_revenue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_elasticity_of_demand#Eff... In the real world, efficiency increases aren't perfect, and we do use something more if it's efficient, but the vast majority of the time, the efficiency increase still reduces usage. It's usually not a maximal reduction because of the redbound effect (except for some appliances), but in every recent case, overall emergy use does drop. https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20010730_RS20981_bebfb5655ab124bbbc7f8e4a7791e4316b7ed83f.pdf https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20010730_RS20981_bebfb5...
- qubex 9y agoThat’s not true, actually: it strictly depends on which is the effective constraint in play at that particular point in the configuration space.
- whack 9y agoIf you look at the inelastic demand graph, in the "cause" section of the wiki, it answers your question. Even if there's increased use of a resource, total energy consumption often still goes down, because each resource now consumes less energy.