4 ms·
This is ridiculous. That "useless clock" is actually a significant engineering challenge: how do we design a system that lasts 10.000 years? Are you sure that
by oblio 9y ago
This is ridiculous.
That "useless clock" is actually a significant engineering challenge: how do we design a system that lasts 10.000 years? Are you sure that no valuable insight came from the project? And before you reply, think of how many valuable insights we got from what some could consider the "useless manned mission to the Moon", in hindsight.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoThere is a major difference between the two projects: we can tell whether a manned mission to the moon has succeeded or failed. There is no way to tell whether the effort you put into making a clock last for 10,000 years had any value; you cannot observe the results unless the clock fails incredibly quickly.
- fooker 9y agoAre you saying we should only do those things, the results of which can be determined in a short amount of time?
- thaumasiotes 9y agoWhat is the point of doing something that has no results?
- URSpider94 9y agoA lot of the mechanisms and designs involved in the clock will be testable from Day 1, for instance the effectiveness of the energy harvesting system, which is designed to power the clock from the beginning without external power inputs. Additionally, things like corrosion and wear resistance performance will be measurable after just a few years of operation. There is an entire field of engineering, Reliability Science, based on the fact that we can predict the lifetime of a system based on a combination of accelerated tests and detailed physical models.
- chris_va 9y agoNitpicking here... making a 10,000 year clock is fairly easy: Take a thermoelectric RPG and attach it to a quartz crystal. The goal of the project is to build one that can be understood by a primitive society, which has questionable application to modern technology.