6 ms·
You know, the problem I have with Proof of Work isn't that it costs in electricity—it's that the Malthusian race-to-the-bottom of mining efficiency has complete
by derefr 9y ago
You know, the problem I have with Proof of Work isn't that it costs in electricity—it's that the Malthusian race-to-the-bottom of mining efficiency has completely destroyed the computer hardware market (for regular consumers.) It's to the point that GPU manufacturers are trying to make classes of cards that only work with games, so that consumers will have something to buy that's actually in stock.
- sandGorgon 9y agoThis can be fixed - e.g. cryptonote used in monero, reduces the advantage of using GPU significantly
- mythrwy 9y agoGPUs are still much better than CPUs for cryptonote though. In both hashrate vs intial cost and hashrate vs power consumption.
- panarky 9y ago> so that consumers will have something to buy So that they can price-discriminate by raising prices for mining and machine learning.
- lazyjones 9y agoThat's a bit of an exaggeration, no? The high-end graphics card market isn't that big and consumers (as in "not PC games fanatics") have plenty of low-end cards to choose from that perfectly suit their need.
- TomVDB 9y agoThe lowest practical gaming GPU from Nvidia is the GTX 1050. Its launch MSRP was $110. Today, they are either sold out, or available for $160 or more. GTX 1060 6GB: launch MSRP was $250. Today it's either of stock or selling for $350. It's no different for AMD and for higher end GPUs.
- neilwilson 9y agoIt doesn't cost in electricity. Like everything it costs in time. It's always ten minutes whatever happens. Bitcoin is increasing the amount of nonsense and waste we can generate in ten minutes. And under standard economic guff like that expressed in the OP that's considered an increase in productivity.
- AznHisoka 9y agoWhich is more beneficial to society? Proof of work or entertaining people?
- rudedogg 9y agoThere's also machine learning.
- LyndsySimon 9y agoProof of work - as proven by the fact that this is what the resources are being spent to provide.
- jadedhacker 9y agoThe resources were spent on obvious speculation, which adds less than zero value to humans (other than speculators). As an analogy, if resources are spent on war, I think it's not so far fetched to say that there is an extraordinary amount of waste in terms of human talent, life, physical infrastructure, and diverted resources. Just because someone spends money doesn't mean it was well spent (unless you measure such things in money).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fardo 9y agoIf we only get to pick one as a society, entertaining people, hands down. Society happily survived without proof of work for millennia, but I think it’s important to remember that entertainment is the good part of life that proof of work is ultimately supposed to enable. I mean this in the same sense the founding fathers did when the wrote stuff like: >“I must study politics and war that my sons may have liberty to study mathematics and philosophy.” That is, proof of work is the tradeoff that ultimately should enable people’s personal entertainment and happiness. If more of the former means less of the latter, I think we are in a bad way.
- nicky0 9y ago
- mquander 9y agoHow can this be? GPU manufacturers are unhappy that demand for their GPUs is skyrocketing, so they are trying to make GPUs that are less in demand? That makes zero sense to me. Why would a GPU manufacturer prefer that an end user use their GPU for games rather than cryptocurrency mining?
- psyc 9y agoThey are absolutely thrilled about the demand, and very reluctant to bank on it going forward.
- raverbashing 9y ago> Why would a GPU manufacturer prefer that an end user use their GPU for games rather than cryptocurrency mining? Because one is a fad the other is their major customers (though the market for ML is growing and nVidia is investing there as well)
- ThomPete 9y agoNext year that one is a 10 year fad.
- raverbashing 9y agoIt will be fun when people realize "ASIC resistant cryptos" are anything but
- GeneralMayhem 9y agoPerhaps they don't believe that GPU-based mining will be profitable enough to sustain the industry. In that case, they need to do everything they can to keep the PC gaming market alive, so that they have someone left to sell to when the cryptocurrency market crashes.
- maldeh 9y agoIn addition to dealing with a vast surplus of used cards on any secondary markets if the crash gets bad enough. It would be rather convenient for them if older miner GPUs were quickly made 'incompatible' with the needs of the consumer gamer / PC market.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- croddin 9y agoYea but this is only temporary. In the long turn (hopefully) mining will end up making gpus cheaper and better from the increased demand.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Fr0styMatt88 9y agoI think this is an anomaly that will sort itself out one way or another. The major reason for this anomaly is that everyone is trying to hedge themselves against cryptocurrencies 'going to zero'. From the perspective of the card manufacturers, they don't want to chase the mining market and ramp up card production to match it as they view the end of mining demand as a potential risk. From the perspective of the card buyer, they don't want to buy a 'mining only' card for much the same reason, with one addition. Mining profitability for the individual drops over time, due to rising difficulty. Which means any card you buy has a finite profitable shelf-life. This makes both ASICs and special-purpose mining GPU cards (basically cards with regular GPUs but no video outputs) unattractive -- they aren't worth much on the second-hand market. At least with a gaming card, once you're done mining with it you have a card you can game with that has essentially paid itself off. I personally think it would be silly and dangerous for graphics card manufacturers to gimp their own hardware in an attempt to appease the gaming market. GPUs are useful for a whole range of things now, which could be impacted negatively by such a move (including things that might be important for gaming performance in the future). To be clear, I say this as an avid gamer myself. The near future is going to be very interesting, especially if the sentiment that 'cryptocurrencies might go away' disappears. There is always the ever-looming 'Proof-of-Stake' also. If that gets popular, the dynamic will shift again and you might see a flood of cheap graphics cards hitting the second-hand market. That would be nice. I think that PoS is fairly risky though; I keep hearing people saying that Ethereum won't be able to deliver on it.
- Fnoord 9y ago> There is always the ever-looming 'Proof-of-Stake' also. If that gets popular, the dynamic will shift again and you might see a flood of cheap graphics cards hitting the second-hand market. Cards which have been very much used. Not sure if that's a problem, seen conflicting info for each side on that one.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maehwasu 9y agoThis is a really good point, and it's also funny, because Sztorc claims (correctly) that PoS has a higher cost than thought, because of the opportunity cost of locking up capital. However, we see here that there are really social utility costs, beyond the environment, to locking up GPU hardware. I suspect that the capital lockup costs are less damaging for the same dollar amount, because capital is more fungible, so the void can be filled by more sources of capital. In the case of GPUs, however, the void can only be filled after a time-lag in changing production focus.