3 ms·
Some people take the position that it's better for the US government to have access to Chinese people's data than for the Chinese government to have access thei
by wmf 9y ago
Some people take the position that it's better for the US government to have access to Chinese people's data than for the Chinese government to have access their data because the US government is better (e.g. more due process).
- John_KZ 9y agoDoes PRISM count as due process? I get how americans could be biased thinking "I live here and nothing has happened to me", but that's a very naive mode of thinking. Masking strategic actions under the "just helping you from yourself" umbrella isn't new, but isn't very convincing either. It's like trump saying he'll nuke north korea because it's an oppressive regime. Caring doesn't work that way.
- tzs 9y agoI think one could make a decent case that in general if you are a citizen or resident of country X, you are probably better off having your data stored in some country Y that you are neither a citizen or resident of...simply because (1) Y has less reason to be interested in your data, and (2) if they do look at your data, it is less likely they can use what they find against you. A counterargument might be that since Y has no connection to you, Y has less interest in protecting your data from third parties than your own country, X, would.
- wmf 9y agoMLATs can throw a wrench in that, though.
- darpa_escapee 9y agoSerious question: what due process does a foreign citizen not in the US have?