3 ms·
Of all the failures that led to the big meltdown, the most aggravating is the failure of the bond-rating agencies. These people took good money for pasting AAA
by nl 16y ago
Of all the failures that led to the big meltdown, the most aggravating is the failure of the bond-rating agencies. These people took good money for pasting AAA credit ratings on piles of the most implausible shit imaginable, and what’s irritating isn’t that they did it, it’s that apparently they didn’t break any laws and thus there’s little prospect of the long prison terms that anything smelling of natural justice would require.
If anyone is looking for a YC application idea, there's one right there. To be more explicit:
Ratings agencies currently are paid by investment companies to rate the risk associated with the products they are bringing to market (ie, the fox is paying the farmer to tell the chickens how safe the hen house is ).
The financial incentives for ratings agencies are aligned with the sellers, not the buyers. That creates a huge risk for the buyers, because they can't (or shouldn't) trust the ratings.
There's an opportunity there to create a company that does ratings but takes money from the buyers, not the sellers.
(Note that entrenched players will go to huge lengths to tell you how hard this is, and how smart all the "financial engineers" are. From my very basic investigations, I'm not at all convinced that it's as hard as they try and make it seem.)
- anamax 16y agoYou're forgetting that many institutions can only accept/rely on ratings from regulator-approved companies. For example, the SEC has granted a ratings monopoly to three companies. The idea is that ratings are too important to be left to some unapproved company. If anyone could issue ratings, folks might be led to make bad investments.... This is one example of how regulation is systemic risk.
- nl 16y agoIt might be possible to market directly to consumers in the retail market. I assume you'd need a licence to give financial advice, but that should be easier to get than the rating agency license (I assume). This is one example of how regulation is systemic risk. Well it sounds more like bad regulation to me.
- anamax 16y ago> > This is one example of how regulation is systemic risk. > Well it sounds more like bad regulation to me. Every regulation can be bad. However, unlike individual firm policy, regulation is system-wide, so the risk is necessarily systemic.