2 ms·
> Excellent! It used to be that the tech community was the most vocal against any scheme to increase the use of tech in voting. That consensus seems to have wea
by vkou 9y ago
> Excellent! It used to be that the tech community was the most vocal against any scheme to increase the use of tech in voting. That consensus seems to have weakened.
What is excellent about this? Paper ballots, with multi-party observers are incredibly secure, auditable, and transparently fair ways of running an election.
Yes, you can have shitty ballot designs, and insane voting machines (Florida, 2000), and your entire electoral process may be infiltrated by Reptilians, who take the ballot boxes out into the woods, to use for kindling, but the same can be said for electronic devices. The UX, and security procedures for the Canadian elctions I have voted in was very simple.
Shade in the circle by the name of the candidate you want to vote for. Fold your ballot. Drop it in a box. At the end of the night, the box is opened, and the ballots get counted. There are eyes on the ballot box, for the entire duration of the process.
Adding a closed-source, opaque electronic voting machine to this process solves a non-problem that nobody has.
- dmckeon 9y agoAn alternative: Mark ballot, feed to scanner, which either successfully scans a ballot, or returns it to the voter to be re-marked (modulo write-in votes, see link). The scan is the fast & easy result, and the paper ballot can be the separate source of a reproducible result. https://www.verifiedvoting.org/resources/voting-equipment/sequoia/optech-eagle/ https://www.verifiedvoting.org/resources/voting-equipment/se... Also a note for international HN readers - elections in the USA often have 20+ races on the same ballot - we really like elective offices - and that makes hand counting more difficult.
- specialist 9y agoThat's a complimentary tool, not an alternative. Most election integrity activists / experts are fine with precinct-based opscans used to tabulate paper ballots the moment the polls close.
- dmckeon 9y agoThe nice thing about scanning either by the voter or while the voter is present is that spoiled ballots - by stray, faint, or partial marks, or overvoting for too many multiple candidates - are reduced to near zero, and are replaced by fresh voter-marked ballots, which simplifies all later tabulation, and reduces confusion and challenges about mis-marked ballots, thus increasing voter confidence in the whole election process. Anyone who is interested in election processes should volunteer to work an election, either helping operate a polling place, or as a poll watcher, or similar. This is one of those areas that looks simple, but has a lot of difficult edge and corner cases. I've been a poll worker and a registrar of voters, and it is not as simple as most people would think.
- specialist 9y ago+1 Emphatic agreement that everyone should work the polls a few times. A lot the silly rhetoric would be quickly mooted if the belligerents had direct experience. Sorry to pendant, because I know you already know this: some jurisdictions have (selectively) disabled the second chance feature for spoiled (or unreadable) ballots, effectively disenfranchising voters.