15 ms·
Words for “yes” in Romance languages
- dewiz 9y agoOc => Ok
- interfixus 9y agoSo, 'si' does survive in French after all. I never would have guessed. Perhaps somewhat interestingly, the Scandinavian languages (Danish/Norwegian, Swedish, Icelandic, etc.) make a similar distinction between plain 'yes' ('ja') and the affirmation of a negation ('jo). English seems to have largely discarded that subtlety, despite the presumed influence of vikings from the north as well as those from across the channel. Sligthly reduced use of shit and fucking would not have been seriously detrimental to my enjoyment of the article.
- frooxie 9y agoEnglish used to have a four-form system, where yes and no were the responses to a question posed in the negative, whereas yea and nay were the responses to positively framed questions. I know German has "ja" and "doch" as ways of saying "yes" to positively vs negatively framed questions. One thing I've found interesting is that in English you answer positively and negatively framed question in the same way, whereas in many East-Asian languages, you take the internal logic of the sentence into account, leading to confusing dialogues for English teachers working abroad in Asia: "Didn't you do your homework?" "Yes. Yes, I didn't do my homework".
- namenotrequired 9y agoDutch makes this distinction as well: "ja" and "jawel". "jawel" is a contraction of "ja" and "wel", which both mean "yes", but are used differently. "Ja" would be the opposite of "no" and "wel" the opposite of "not".
- Slavic 9y agoStopped reading at "some slavic shit"
- mjfisher 9y agoI've become increasingly interested in how people become offended recently. Offence tends to be bound up in notions of identity, and I think the way people offend and become offended is increasingly a factor in a world becoming more polarised. Would you be able to expand a little on your feelings? Would you expect people from other cultures mentioned in the article to be similarly offended? I'm not asking you to justify or defend your position - I'm genuinely curious about the feelings you have.
- gigogkggi 9y agoThe tone is dismissive, duh. Let's try another version, some Mexican shit. Trump comes to mind? Yup! You got it.
- mrow84 9y agoIt is only dismissive ironically - the author is not really belittling Slavic languages. Context and intent are important, and it is possible to be unduly sensitive. I think it is worth expecting readers to expend a small amount of effort to try and assess a writer's intent, so that we might live in a world where people can use colourful language. Teasing someone is not the same as insulting them.
- gigogkggi 9y agoIn a world where pointing out that pure facts such as that Chicago has already had 200 gun homicides this year with its strict gun control laws will get you labelled as a white supremacist, I'd definitely like people to chill out, but alas, no.
- mrow84 9y agoAs I said, context is important, and other people might perceive your intent incorrectly, depending on your choice of words, and your timing. People should not give a knee-jerk reaction without some effort to understand you, but if you ever feel you are misunderstood you should simply say so, and clarify what you mean. That way, people won't mistake you for a white supremacist.
- nkkollaw 9y agoOne thing that is driving me crazy while learning Polish is that "no" means "yes" (informal).
- voltooid 9y agoDoes anyone else have problems reading that blog because of the font?
- uph 9y agoYes. Use Firefox Reader View by clicking the icon in the address bar or press CTRL + ALT + R.
- saagarjha 9y agoIt's some legacy thing called cufón (http://cufon.shoqolate.com/generate/ http://cufon.shoqolate.com/generate/) that literally overlays images on top of text as a polyfill for lack of font-face support in CSS.
- M_Bakhtiari 9y agoThe tone of the article has a certain “How Do You Do, Fellow Kids?” tinge to it.
- cryptonector 9y agoClearly intended because the whole point is that the relatively new use of "this" for affirmation online is... not new.
- kleiba 9y agoI personally find the use of single word "This." in reply to a comment on forums (such as e.g. HN) really annoying. (But then again, I've reached an age where you tend to find everything new awful.) I guess the reason why it pisses me off is that it doesn't do anything that "Yes.", "Exactly.", "I agree" couldn't already do, but at the same time it has this overly sweet smell of kool-aid that just makes you sick.
- nasredin 9y agothis. times a 1,000. [image of a text] sorry gotta go. my raw water delivery just arrived [emoji].
- arwhatever 9y agoI can't tell which earlier message you're thissing.
- js2 9y agoFor me (I’m 46 so I think I’ve reached “get off my lawn” age), it’s short for “this [is the correct answer.]” So I’ve never had a problem with it and probably used it once or twice myself. A couple summers ago at the pool I heard a teenage girl exclaim “poned!” after besting her friend at something they were playing. It took me a moment to realize she’d just said “pwned” since I’d never heard it said out loud before and in my mind I’ve always read it “owned.” Now that was a “get off my lawn moment!”
- andybak 9y agoThis! (Sorry... Fantastic article in any case. I send anything similar to a friend who studied linguistics. This one is going to her immediately.)
- twiss 9y agoWhile it's a superb article, it strikes me as being distinctly aimed at laypeople, and I suspect someone who studied linguistics might already know large parts of it. (I haven't, but I know parts from having had Latin in school.) (Also, it contains the words "This is not exactly what happened but it is basically what happened, please just fucking roll with it, this shit is long enough already." so I suspect there might be more in-depth material somewhere.) Anyway, all of this is not aimed at you directly, but more of a general pondering of whether sending people articles on their subject matter is useful. Family members occasionally send me news articles on technology, which I usually find only moderately interesting.
- unscaled 9y agoThis should be pretty common knowledge to any linguist who studied historical linguistics, although if you never did any historical linguistics you could easy miss that. This should also be common knowledge to anyone who studied late-medieval Latin texts, as many of them use this feature to distinguish the 3 major Romance vernaculars of Europe, e.g. Dante's De Vulgari Eloquentia. There is even an entire region called Languedoc in France, which refers to the language its inhabitants speak (or used to speak). Having say that, although I perfectly know about the distinction between languages of si, oil and oc, I was still intrigued enough to click on the article and it was a nice read (except for the tiny font) and I even learned something new: I didn't know that 'oc' was a calque from Gaulish 'to'. The common case of people sending me articles about linguistics is worse: I often get heavily distorted pop-sci articles full of mistakes and misconceptions.
- frooxie 9y agoDo you have any books to recommend for people who aren't interested in learning in-depth about historical linguistics, but like reading about the sort of interesting trivia found in the Tumblr post?
- masters3d 9y agoYaaassss https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/yas https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/yas
- posterboy 9y agoyus?
- make3 9y agoI really like profanity laced erudite articles, for some reason. Maybe it scratches a similar hitch that Rick does in Rick and Morty. Which makes me think, man I'd love to read a scientific paper written by Rick! :)
- mprev 9y agoIt took away from the whole thing, for me. Almost like the author is not wanting to look like a nerd and, so, over-compensating.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoIn Greece we had a writer called Nikos Tsiforos whose schtick was exactly that. He wrote entire history and mythology books in a Greek argot (the language of the "manges" and the rebetika, which you probably won't find about on the 'net). He used the slang of a criminal subculture that was full of profanity, sarcasm and disdain for authority and polite society to treat scholarly subjects like the Francocracy, the Conquistadores and the histories of Greece, France, Britain and the United States. That was back in the '50s or so and his books were widely panned by the literary critics of his time but they were still popular several decades later when I was growing up.
- bartread 9y agoThis idea isn't particularly new: even the New Testament is written in what was basically street Greek rather than the more formal variant usually employed for written documents.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoThe language in the New Testament is not formal, yes, but it's not "street Greek" in the same sense that we mean "street speak" today. At the time, Greek was the lingua franca of that part of the world, basically the Roman empire, so it was used by people who didn't have another common language to communicate in their daily interactions. It's not a slang though, nor a subculture's secret argot. For instance, today the de facto lingua franca spoken around the world is English. So, if the New Testament was written today- it would be obviously written in English to reach the broadest audience possible. Now, imagine if the apostles decided to write about Christ's life not just in English, but in the kind of English used in gangsta rap. I have read the New Testament in the original and I can assure you that is not what it sounds like :)
- labster 9y agoThose are sum (sic) rhymes!
- posterboy 9y ago> so it was pronounced like “seek” How do you know? I doubt it, but maybe my stress on seeek is just too long. Good to know it's not as sick, anyhow.
- tetrazine 9y agoI believe ancient linguistic nuances like this are sometimes divined from formally structured poetry, among other sources. Also analysis of languages thought to share a common ancestor could imply near-identical pronunciation in the past
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I believe ancient linguistic nuances like this are sometimes divined from formally structured poetry Given that formally structured poetry in English (not sure if the same is true of other current languages) often uses somewhat different from usual pronunciation (in ways that are both immediately obvious to a reader familiar with the poetic style, and understandable if unusual to a listener hearing the spoken poem), I would worry that leaning too heavily on this as evidence might potentially be misleading .
- stevula 9y agoIt would more likely be pronounced with a vowel sound similar to a long i in Italian, but this is a pretty good approximation for English speakers. [Vox Latina](https://www.amazon.com/Vox-Latina-Guide-Pronunciation-Classical/dp/0521379369/ https://www.amazon.com/Vox-Latina-Guide-Pronunciation-Classi...) is a good resource for reconstructed classical pronunciation.
- jek0 9y agocf "What Latin Sounded Like - and how we know" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_enn7NIo-S0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_enn7NIo-S0
- chepaslaaa 9y agoCool article
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lbebber 9y agoInteresting. In (Brazilian) Portuguese, "isso" and "isso aí" ("this", "this there") is used to confirm or agree with something, so it seems the expression survived the times.
- jacquesm 9y agoCurious coincidence how that sounds like 'it's so' and 'itsso, eh'!
- kaoD 9y ago> "isso aí" > 'itsso, eh' Trivia: notice 'isso aí' has an acute accent on í which indicates the syllable is stressed. Doesn't sound much like 'eh' https://translate.google.com/#pt/en/a%C3%AD https://translate.google.com/#pt/en/a%C3%AD similar to 'itsso ah-E'.
- hessart 9y agoTechnically, “isso” translates to “that”, whereas “isto” translates to “this”. Good point, anyway.
- felipelemos 9y agoBoth translate to 'this'. Isso is a coloquial form of isto. Aquilo translate to 'that'.
- kaoD 9y agoThat sounds similar to spanish' esto, eso, aquello so I guess their usage is similar? Esto (isto) = this (at hand's reach) Eso (isso) = that (close but out of reach) Aquello (aquilo) = that (far away) Isto and isso are both "close" but they're still different degrees of closeness. I would still translate 'eso' as 'that'. EDIT: But I guess you speak Brazilian Portuguese: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/isto#Portuguese https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/isto#Portuguese https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/isso#Portuguese https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/isso#Portuguese > isso: (demonstrative, informal, Brazil) this
- danans 9y agoSanskrit also lacked a single affirmative particle, instead using various words/phrases meaning "true" or "it is so" (sat, satya, astu) Also similar to Latin, most of it's daughter languages standardized on a single affirmative particle "haan".
- omazurov 9y agoLoved that pun from Baudolino by Umberto Eco: "I know, Master Niketas, that the center of the universe is your city here, but the world is vaster than your empire, and there's even Ultima Thule and the land of Hibernians. True, compared to Constantinople, Rome is a pile of ruins and Paris is a muddy village, but even there something happens every now and then. In many vast, vast regions of the world people don't speak Greek, and there are those who, when they want to agree with something, say, oc." "Oc?" "Oc." "Strange. But do go on."
- schoen 9y ago> Paris is a muddy village https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lutetia#Etymology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lutetia#Etymology
- gpvos 9y agoWould the old Celtic root luto-/luteuo- (marsh, swamp) mentioned there be related to Latin lutum (mud, loam, sand, dust)?
- jxub 9y agoIn Spanish lodo is mud, it looks more similar to the Celtic word to me. Interesting.
- henriquemaia 9y agoWell, in tandem with Spanish, we also say it like that in Portuguese. But I always take it to mean sludge, not just any mud. For plain mud, we use the more common word lama.
- lokopodium 9y agoInteresting subject tainted by crappy narration.
- cryptonector 9y agoWorked for me, and clearly for others.
- acobster 9y agoGreat article. On a side note, I took five years of French and never learned that si is specifically for contradicting a negative. Sup with that.
- benzor 9y agoAs a native French speaker from Quebec, I can tell you it's much more common in France, so if you went to school in North America that might explain it.
- umanwizard 9y agoIn the US, french from France is taught. The Quebec dialect is barely mentioned. Btw, in France, “si” in that context is not just common, but absolutely required. People would be confused if someone used “oui”.
- bluesmoon 9y agoIt was covered in second year French when I studied it in India through Alliance Française.
- jxub 9y agoOn a similar vibe, in Catalan oi is used instead of sí in questions, like in "T'has menjat el desdejuni, oi?", which may surely come from oui or the ancient oil in French.
- ggm 9y agoI love that the end of the bog on 'this' is a huge chain of people whose click of affection adds them to the list of '...x liked this' immediately after he says: I guess what I’m getting at is that when you reblog a post you like and tag it with “this,” or affirm a thing a friend said by nodding and saying “Yeah, that”: you’re not new
- cobbzilla 9y agoI always wondered why the French "oui" was so different from most other romance languages. Great explanation, and a fun read.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kiliancs 9y agoIt's interesting that in Catalan you may say oi [0] in addition to sí. It is more commonly used in questions and to answer such questions. For example: Plou molt, oi? Oi. There's a construct that is very common and redundant: oi que sí? == right that yes?, which would be translated as an emphatic "right?" [0] http://mdlc.iec.cat/results.asp?txtEntrada=Oi&operEntrada=0 http://mdlc.iec.cat/results.asp?txtEntrada=Oi&operEntrada=0
- mbroncano 9y agoIt sounds like a calque of regular Spanish 'a que si' rather than anything else.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoNot oui in French?
- kiliancs 9y agoIf you read the article, this is a pattern in a number of languages, so there's no reason for it to come from French. It's also unlikely because the pronunciation is very different: https://forvo.com/word/oi/#ca https://forvo.com/word/oi/#ca
- mixmastamyk 9y agoCatalonia borders France and has some similarities though.
- kiliancs 9y agoBordering with French is a newer phenomenon, though. Catalonia has traditionally bordered Occitan-speaking territories to the North so it has way more influence from Occitan than from French.
- kiliancs 9y ago
- davidgay 9y agoMy favourite on the yes/no front though is the border between Greece and Bulgaria where "Ne" (Не) means no in Bulgarian and, IIUC, yes in Greek. And then the Bulgarians also have approximately reversed vs Western Europe head movements for yes and no, to maximise confusion :)
- pessimizer 9y ago> And then the Bulgarians also have approximately reversed vs Western Europe head movements for yes and no, to maximise confusion :) This is strangely the most shocking fact that I know. It's one of those facts that remind you that just because something is universal doesn't mean that it's not cultural.
- loggedinmyphone 9y agoShaking one's head for "no" is far from universal - it means "yes" in parts of India as well.
- apendleton 9y agoIndia also has its own head motion that, for lack of better way of explaining it, is in aircraft terms a roll as compared to our pitch for yes and yaw for no. (Or maybe that's what you're talking about?). It doesn't mean "yes" exactly from what I've been able to gather, but more like "uh-huh" might be used as marker of paying attention in a running conversation. Like "I hear you, please continue" without explicitly agreeing or disagreeing.
- loggedinmyphone 9y agoThat's probably a better description. At first blush it looks like something you might interpret as skepticism - rocking the head side to side as if to say "That's not quite right." It took me a while to figure out it indicates a positive response to a question like "Does this bus go downtown?" rather than a negative one.
- 9y ago
- jay-anderson 9y agoSardinian for yes is 'eja' which I've read is derived differently from the two methods suggested here though I haven't seen any suggestions on what that derivation might be.
- asveikau 9y agoSounds a lot like "etiam" in Latin which if you break it apart looks like et + iam or "and now", but this site has some translations including "yes" http://archives.nd.edu/cgi-bin/lookit.pl?latin=Etiam http://archives.nd.edu/cgi-bin/lookit.pl?latin=Etiam
- posterboy 9y agoI just suggested greek "eu" for oi in another comment. Close enough in my book.
- posterboy 9y agoBut do other languages also have "jein" (blend of German ja and nein)? "meh", perhaps.
- magnusjonsson 9y agoSwedish has "nja" (blend of Swedish ja and nej).
- pjmlp 9y agoPortuguese has nim, a merge of não and sim.
- illo 9y agoItalian has "ni", a merge of "no" and "sì".
- midhir 9y ago"So we can look at, for example, Old Irish, where they said tó to mean yes" Really? In modern Irish we substitute Tá for yes but it's not really yes. We don't have yes or no, we repeat the verb of the question positively or negatively. Tá is kind of 'am', níl 'am not' like "Are you going to watch Mrs Browns Boys tonight?" "I am not." Are they really comparable? Maybe somewhere along the line Tá (pronounced 'taw') was taken for 'yes'.
- jodrellblank 9y ago"Are you hungry?" "I am and I amn't". "Will you run away with yourself" "I willn't!"
- danaliv 9y agoI was wondering about this. Thanks for chiming in. I don't know Irish but I do know a bit of Scottish Gaelic, and it is as you say: there is no word for yes (or no), not even in the way the author suggests. Affirmation or negation is done by repeating the verb of the question. In the case of simple "to be" questions, that verb is either tha or 's. But a question like "have you read the book?", which would be structured "read you the book?", would be answered either "read" for the affirmative or "(not) read" for the negative. In any event, tha—which I presume is the Scottish equivalent to Irish tá—doesn't mean yes either.
- DFHippie 9y agoIn Welsh you use "do" to assent to things asserted about the past. "Wyt ti wedi bwyta?" [Have you eaten?] "Do." [Yes.] The negative is "naddo". If you ask a question with something other than the verb initial, the affirmative is "ie" and the negative "nage". Otherwise, it works like you say in Irish or as in an English wedding ceremony. "Do you take so-and-so to be your lawfully wedded spouse?" "I do."
- talideon 9y agoThe 'tó' and 'náthó' mentioned in the article are actually borrowings from Middle Welsh into Middle Irish, but they fell out of fashion again. Old Irish didn't have yes/no equivalents. 'Tá' (present tense independent form of the verb 'bí') and 'tó' aren't thought to be related.
- DopamineHigh 9y agoNow this is a cool article. It's funny and ironic that an article uses slang while talking about how old languages acquired other phrases from other languages, calques. I do wish future articles take note how adding humor to an article shows a level of care and understanding about the subject/ideas.
- jdonaldson 9y agoAgreed. So many technical blogs try to strike the same to to sound edgy or cute. Here the author uses it masterfully to reinforce his points on language.
- posterboy 9y agoI wonder, is occitan not related to occident and orient? and oil, well, that's norse for beer, remember where normandy has it's name from? That doesn't explain yes, no; but eu, as in euphemism might[1]. Heureka! In other news, what does si in greek letters look like? "σι"! Pretty close to oi nowadays and Celtic druids are speculated to have visited Greece. That doesn't invalidate the "this there" story, but maybe precedes it. The disdain for Slavik in the article is confirming a slight bias. [1]: also europe, eukaryote, oi-punk, Euler. Well, almost. "arobe" means harbor (ger. Heimathaven?) in some European language but I CBA to look up which it was or how it's written, right now.
- schoen 9y ago> I wonder, is occitan not related to occident and orient? Nope! The orient is where the sun rises and the occident is where the sun sets. All of these have been traced back to Proto-Indo-European and have different origins: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/orior#Latin https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/orior#Latin https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/occido#Etymology_1 https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/occido#Etymology_1 https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/ob#Latin https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/ob#Latin https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/hic#Latin https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/hic#Latin Edit: the eu- also has a different PIE etymology. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%CE%B5%E1%BD%96#Ancient_Greek https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%CE%B5%E1%BD%96#Ancient_Greek
- posterboy 9y agoYeah, I can google myself thank you very much. Your inability to speak or to read properly makes me really doubt your general premises, because neither had anyone talked about ob and you didn't explain the relation to the thread either, nor did you notice my precaution to note that I the theory for oil from the article might still be valid. Instead you seem to have come panting and frothing from the mouth as soon as you had read the first few lines hardly being able to read the rest of my post. I know how it is, I do that too sometimes. No harm done. > the eu- also has a different PIE etymology. I know, why do you think I would have mentioned it otherwise?! If you had to guess in percent how certain a single PIE root is, and then take the combined probability for ll f the roots of the rather young PIE studies, which are very well known to have produced a metric shittonne of false results not even a hundred years ago that we are still wading through, how likely is it that the patient has cancer? To repeat, what's "ob" have to do with this?
- woodruffw 9y agoInteresting notes about Latin. I always learned that Latin didn't have a direct analogue to "yes," with the closest thing being "ita vero"[1] (not just "ita"). But "sic" makes sense in many contexts. [1]: "thus it is so," or "it is true," or "and how!".
- blowski 9y agoIn Portuguese, although ‘sim’ means yes, when answering a question in the affirmative you often use the same verb as the question. For example: “Gosta frango? Gosto.” “Do you like chicken? I like it.” Also, it’s common to say ‘isso’ to agree with something. It means ‘this’ and Anglophones are now doing the same thing, at least online.
- icebraining 9y agoPedantically, "isso" means "that". "This" is "isto".
- ralmeida 9y agoTo be fair, it’s almost uncommon to say an articulated ‘isto’ in colloquial spoken language.
- namenotrequired 9y agoMy impression is that the Brazilians use "sim" a bit the same way the french use "si". "Você vai?" "Vou" ("are you going?" "I am going") "Você não vai?" "Sim" ("Aren't you going?" "yes I am")
- MayeulC 9y ago> So they combined hoc with ille, which means “that” (but also comes to just mean “he”: compare Spanish el, Italian il, French le, and so on) Well, I have to disagree on this bit. French for "he" is actually "il"; while "le" is "the". If you are more interested, "that" would be "ce", or if you want to stress it/be more accurate, "cela" (can be contracted to "ça"), or "celui-là" -- literally "that him there" -- while "this" would be "ceci". Yeah, lots of words to mean the same, you would usually be fine just picking one. Interesting read nonetheless.
- gugagore 9y agoIn American Sign Language, the signs glossed as THAT and as YES also resemble each other. The sign YES is http://www.lifeprint.com/asl101/pages-signs/y/yes.htm http://www.lifeprint.com/asl101/pages-signs/y/yes.htm which looks like a head nod, but also it is the general motion your hand takes when you spell Y-E-S in the manual alphabet. (Lots of ASL signs are lexicalized fingerspellings. They started off as just being fingerspelled, but over time they became words themselves) The sign THAT can be used to agree with someone emphatically (and also as backchanneling, as in THAT THAT THAT, is like "yeah, uh huh, oh, ok, mm") For an example see the second image on http://www.lifeprint.com/asl101/pages-signs/t/that.htm http://www.lifeprint.com/asl101/pages-signs/t/that.htm Notice that THAT is made with the Y handshape, same as the initial letter in Y-E-S, and moves like YES. Hmm!