5 ms·
"Only assholes get patents." Marco rubs me the wrong way. Blanket statements like this are not meaningful. What the post is saying is: there is nothing you ca
by whalesalad 9y ago
"Only assholes get patents."
Marco rubs me the wrong way. Blanket statements like this are not meaningful.
What the post is saying is: there is nothing you can do. At the end of the day it doesn't matter who does it first, it matters who does it best. Do it best and you'll win.
Very clickbaity title. This could have been a tweet (and it was: https://twitter.com/sandofsky/status/966721199052013568 https://twitter.com/sandofsky/status/966721199052013568)
- makecheck 9y agoIf patents were usefully enforced and practical to obtain, it would matter who files first because that’s how patents work. The $20,000 part of patents (and additional legal fees) are a problem because we are clearly at the point economically where tons of people who need stronger protections will never have the resources to obtain those protections. You can’t do that when it’s impossible to sell anything for more than 99 cents.
- 0xCMP 9y agoAnd we can't expect everyone to pay more for many of these things when there is so much inequality, lack of wage increases, student debt, etc. etc. etc. Of course I go ahead and pay $50/year for ulysses or $20 for each Things 3 app, but my sister won't pay $3/m to iCloud on her filled up iPhone nor $5/m to Spotify or Apple Music to listen to music.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- soneca 9y agoWith an interesting reply: "Coincidentally, superior execution is also the most effective way to steal a good idea."
- choward 9y ago> This could have been a tweet Right. Everyone should give their content to third party if they want to share it.
- mankash666 9y agoOff topic. The OP meant to say that the crux of the article boils down to something conveyable in 140 characters or less. Does Mastadon float your boat, versus twitter?
- Cyph0n 9y agoI guess it's easy to say patents are bad when you're already a millionaire...
- JepZ 9y agoI think its the other way around: When you are a millionaire you probably don't care much about patents, because you can afford to pay for the license.
- Cyph0n 9y agoTrue, but I was looking at it from the point of view of publishing patents to guarantee a source of income.
- criddell 9y agoUnless you are prepared to start suing other developers like yourself or sell to a patent troll, there really is no path to income, is there?
- gnicholas 9y agoYou don't have to sue people if they recognize that you invented and patented something. I've licensed patented tech to folks who range from solo devs to large nonprofits, and discussions never veered toward litigation at any point. I think it depends a lot on what you've created and whether your patents are likely to stand up.
- Cyph0n 9y agoYou can make money by either licensing the patent or selling it. Large companies are usually prepared to buy out your patents if they think the tech is worth it.
- cookiecaper 9y agoQuite the contrary. The millionaire knows he can take any idea he wants from a young upstart if it's not patented. He can hire more people, spend more money marketing his clone, get the big PR firm working for him, and relegate the true innovator to a historical footnote (at best). If there's a patent, the force of law can be leveraged by the upstart to protect himself from such incursions, at least theoretically, and it requires expensive, tedious effort for the millionaire to circumvent the patent and/or defend himself against claims that he has infringed. Even if most inventors aren't going to pursue this course, the fact that the possibility exists is a deterrent. Patents are not necessarily done well, but like many systems that have been co-opted by large corporate interests, they exist precisely to prevent such exploitation. Software people must understand that software is not very hard or expensive to replicate. You don't get acquired because your software is good. You get acquired because you have a brand, an audience, a trademark, or a patent. There has to be some asset that the prospective acquirer cannot easily recreate by throwing 3-5 coders into a dark closet for a year or two (this costs around $1M / yr, much cheaper than any newsworthy acquisition). So yeah, millionaires are likely to be very irritated that there's a patent that may force them to compensate the original innovator, or worse, buy their company entirely.
- JepZ 9y agoI think he meant it in the context of "Defending your app from copies and clones" (aka "to defend you intellectual property"). If you hold patents just to make them available for ever and free to anyone but patent trolls, that might be a different game.
- debt 9y agoIt's literally the ONLY way to defend against copies and clones. At least, if you're dealing with lots of money and big ideas. Marco is coming at from the perspective that everyone is a nerd, reads hacker news and knows the difference between "free beer" and whatever the other one is. Most, nay, all software companies get shit patented. It's the difference between having a legal document protecting your ideas and, well, not.
- Zanni 9y agoYeah, this is just bad advice. I think for most indy developers patents aren't worth the trouble for defending your IP against other indys--which, in the context of the article is probably what he meant. But for defending yourself against major players? Absolutely. And if you want a major player to buy you (instead of buying one of your competitors) it'll be the key differentiator.
- paulcole 9y ago> But for defending yourself against major players? Absolutely The point is that you have no chance to defend yourself. Can an indy developer afford a legal defense of the scale required to "defeat" a major player? If they can will it even be worth their time and energy?
- Parcissons 9y agoOh, i tend to disagree on that. He who comes first trains user-interface behaviour expected. If s/he is fast enough, the people will expect a certain behaviour - and be always annoyed if the others do not have it. So if you are good and stay in the race, and you are first- that can be something that binds customers.