3 ms·
There is no FTL or energy conservation problem with the theoretical or the experimental experiment. They explicitly ask for a clear path between A and B after
by gus_massa 9y ago
There is no FTL or energy conservation problem with the theoretical or the experimental experiment.
They explicitly ask for a clear path between A and B after they choose which message to send, so the "signal" can travel from A to B and from B to A. And they explicitly ask for enough time. So there are no time paradox or break of energy conservation problems.
The weird part is that in the experiment they use a single photon instead of two photons as usual. It's weird because you expect that it's clear if the photon is traveling from A to B or from B to A, but there are very similar experiments with the same problem.
For example there is the classic double slit experiment, where you send light through two slits and see the interference pattern. The weird part is that you can repeat the experiment using a very low power system that guaranty that you are using a single photon each time. So for each photon you have the question: Did it pass though the upper left slit or the right slit? The answer is that the question makes no sense in quantum mechanics. A popular answer is to consider that the photon passed through both slits, this is an useful idea in the calculations but it's misleading and prone to weird interpretations.
More info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment#Single_particle_experiments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment#Single_...
So in the double-slit single-photon it's not clear if the photon pass though one slit of the other, and in this experiment it's not clear if the photon goes from A to B or B to A. In both cases, the answer is that it's difficult to explain the quantum mechanics effect accurately with a good classical analogy.