3 ms·
...offensively wrong... Why wasn't 'wrong' enough? Why should any honestly-presented, based-on-experience opinion like Arrington's generate 'offense'? Why not
by gojomo 16y ago
...offensively wrong...
Why wasn't 'wrong' enough? Why should any honestly-presented, based-on-experience opinion like Arrington's generate 'offense'? Why not assume good faith?
- Towle_ 16y agoIt's "offensively wrong" because the author (a male) is striving for an image of being genuinely sympathetic to The Plight. "Look at me, I'm so understanding."
- gojomo 16y agoSo you think he's lying about his internal mental state and specific efforts in areas he controls? Why not assume good faith?
- Towle_ 16y agoI don't think he's lying to us, I think he's lying to himself.
- 146 16y agoI think that's a rather unfair assumption to make. Do you have evidence that he's being disingenuous?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Towle_ 16y ago'Disingenuous' isn't quite the word I would use. I'm sure the author really does think he's contributing to The Crusade, which is precisely the problem. He can't just dissect the errors in Arrington's logic. No, that's not good enough. He needs to put on a Crusader uniform and act like he thinks those people are supposed to act: offended. He can't just BE offended, he must explicitly tell you he's offended, and start swinging his sword around so you know what a noble Crusader he is. If he were responding to a blog post offensive to men, would he have used that language? No, because being offended for yourself isn't noble, it's being offended for others. And telling everyone about it as much as you can. How else will people know what an altruist you are?
- gojomo 16y agoAll this thread I thought you were criticizing Arrington as having been genuinely offensive! (Note to self: avoid pronouns in replies, so anaphor collisions are recognized asap.)
- gxti 16y agoBecause the entire discussion is bogged down by people trying to signal how egalitarian they are, and if anyone has a marginally differing viewpoint then they must be distanced as far as possible as violently as possible lest the speaker be perceived as a bigot. Personally? I don't think this is something that needs to be fixed. If women want to get into tech, they'll get into tech, and that'll be that. Many already have, and many more will continue to do so. Forcing the issue just keeps people on edge, overreacting to try to keep their perceived latent bigotry under wraps.
- tbrownaw 16y ago"Wrong" means "not correct". "Offensively wrong" means "not Politically Correct".