4 ms·
>> I don't get why deep learning researchers are so hung up on learning everything from scratch. It is easier to formulate the problem when you are dealing wit
by tanilama 9y ago
>> I don't get why deep learning researchers are so hung up on learning everything from scratch.
It is easier to formulate the problem when you are dealing with only one specific task. Transfer learning is useful, but in its current format it is limited, and can only borrow features from tasks that are similar. Meta-learning is trying to tackle this problem specifically, promising result is presented, but still long way to go to be useful in real-world production.
In order to NOT learning from scratch, we need understand the representation of knowledge. For neural networks, the knowledge is parameters that learnt. However, the parameter is tied to the task that your trained your network with, so we are back to square one. I doubt continuous differentiable tensors are the ONLY representation of human's knowledge. It might represent the hard-to-explain intuition part of it, however, a large, probably larger part of our knowledge is better represented by category/hierarchy/graph/rules that is not easily differentiable, which current deep learning techniques struggle to model.
So, IMO, it is not really that researchers are obsessed with supervised learning, it is probably that they have no better alternatives.
- sharemywin 9y ago"Do not try and bend the spoon, that's impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth...there is no spoon. Then you'll see that it is not the spoon that bends, it is only yourself." ―Spoon Boy to Neo category/hierarchy/graph/rules are important but I suspect only our conscious/social minds works in that abstraction.
- tanilama 9y agoNevertheless, our brain is able to model such abstractions just fine. The capacity to represent such non-differentiable structure is the key.
- sharemywin 9y agoBut the representation isn't static. We can learn new symbol systems and adjust them all the time. Plus create rules of thumb to make re-processing easier. and go back and/forth. Think of an elephant. now an Asian elephant walking by a river. your image probably was pretty abstract then got more vivid. Then re-adjusted to add the river. So you went from symbols to a more detailed model like a generative model, but you probably only have had a few examples of elephants to generate from.