4 ms·
The fact that this seems demonstrably impossible on its face, and yet he is raising money, always makes me curious. During the 'Star Wars' period in the US whe
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
The fact that this seems demonstrably impossible on its face, and yet he is raising money, always makes me curious.
During the 'Star Wars' period in the US when the military was going to buy up thousands and thousands of launches to low earth orbit there were probably 1/2 dozen companies pursuing a single stage to orbit (SSTO) type solution. Gary Hudson, the CEO of Rotary Rocket (one of the SSTO companies at the time), gave a great example that showed that because the atmosphere was thick at ground level and thin at altitude you wanted a velocity that proportional to altitude. As he explained it, everything you do to a rocket to reinforce it adds weight, and every pound you add is another 90lbs of fuel (or what ever your mass fraction is). In that way your rocket could be as delicate as a feather if you went very slowly down near the ground and hypersonic near the edge of the atmosphere.
But systems that attempt to impart enough kinetic energy at altitude zero to allow the rocket to coast to orbit require a rocket that is structurally extremely rigid because it withstands both the force of acceleration and the atmospheric drag at its worst. That is astonishingly hard to pull off.
I a serious challenge, first you have to actually start at higher than orbital velocity because you're going to exchange a lot of energy with the air around the air frame. Volcanoes are currently the champions at throwing things up into the air, Mt St. Helens through ash over 100,000 feet up. But if you start your orbit going straight up you won't be able to miss hitting the planet post apogee. The more angled you make your initial shot, the more air you have to go through before you are in space, the more energy you're going to dump in the atmosphere, and the faster you'll have to start.
And all of that makes me really wonder about an engineering solution that fits within all those constraints. What ever it is, it will be super amazing.
- anvandare 9y agoThe "Lazy Kerbal" approach: go straight up to get out of the atmosphere as soon as possible (stupid drag) and turn right once you pass the Kármán... Err, Kerman Line (at 70km). Start burning near apoapsis until your periapsis is >=70km as well. If your initial apoapsis was high enough, you'll make it to orbit before re-entry. If not, revert to launch. Efficient? Not at all, but certainly effective and simple.
- pitaj 9y ago> it withstands both the force of acceleration and the atmospheric drag at its worst Not to mention that the payload must also be able to survive these high accelerations.
- mannykannot 9y agoAny viehicle of useful size de-orbiting, even from a low orbit, needs a heat shield to reach the surface intact, right? And this thing needs to be going faster than orbital speed at the surface - I don't see how that could work out without it becoming a fireball. At one point, I was thinking that perhaps a de-orbiting vehicle needs a heat shield only because it has to fall several tens of miles before it encounters enough atmosphere to matter, during which time it accelerates, but that cannot make a difference, because at that altitude, a ballistic vehicle being launched needs to be going at least as fast as the re-entering vehicle in order to end up in the same orbit.
- cwkoss 9y agoI wonder if you could sink a very buoyant rocket to the bottom of the ocean with a weight, and then fire up the rocket engine as it breaks through the surface of the ocean with a positive upward velocity. Presumably drag in water is the biggest issue, which would be somewhat mitigated by the aerodynamic shape of the rocket. I wonder what is the maximum theoretical exit velocity from the ocean, using only buoyancy as propulsion.
- cwkoss 9y agoRelated interesting idea: creating a hydraulic catapult to launch the rocket. https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-we-launch-spaceships-from-underwater/answer/Bernard-Peek https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-we-launch-spaceships-from-und...