2 ms·
For me the biggest problems with the HomePod are that (a) for the same price you can have a stereo pair of Sonos Ones and (b) I haven't found a surround sound o
by majormajor 9y ago
For me the biggest problems with the HomePod are that (a) for the same price you can have a stereo pair of Sonos Ones and (b) I haven't found a surround sound or center channel story for the HomePod a la Sonos soundbar/base station + Sonos Ones.
Going from point source to multiple sources makes a very substantial difference.
I'm very curious about just how much DSP magic the HomePod is doing (as opposed to what's physical enclosure magic), since in playing with my Sonoses I can't spot a huge effect from their TruePlay tuning in most configurations I've tried out. It's there, but minor sounding for most typical arrangements - perhaps it would be greater if I tried more and more sub-optimal placements, but trying to sabotage my setup isn't my ultimate goal. ;)
If Apple let the DSP be shut off so it could be measured that would be interesting from a technical perspective, but should it actually affect the reviews? If anything, the HomePod makes reviews better if now reviewers are actively aware that they should think about what it'll sound like in the user's room vs in an ideal layout.
- threeseed 9y ago1. The quality is better than a pair of Sonos One. 2. AirPlay2 will support multiple units. 3. All of the magic behind the HomePod is in the software. Otherwise it is just a bunch of tweeters in a circular shape and a woofer. It's the software that determines what each tweeter is going to output and the strength of the woofer output. 4. The reviews I've read have been careful about not just testing the HomePod in ideal conditions. Since the ability to "just work" in non ideal conditions is what the entire device is designed for. Anyway all of this is moot. Sound quality is important but more so this is an ecosystem play. HomePod reinforces investments in HomeKit and iOS.
- majormajor 9y agoI've seen as many reviews contradicting your first point as supporting it. Distributed source vs point source - the Sonos's have a huge advantage out of the gate in terms of ambience and imaging, and adding additional units helps with volume and quality as well. I've seen a lot of talk about stereo AirPlay but not about surround. What would you use as the center channel, another homepod? That would look awkward, though sound fine. The enclosure has always been a huge part of speaker design. The software side, ever since the computing power got cheap enough to enable stuff like Audyssey, has been a newer but not unheard-of part. Apple would be fools if they didn't optimize the physical design of the speaker as much as the software side. Ecosystem lock in only works if you have a reason for me to buy a HomePod to use with my iPad instead of a Sonos in the first place. Sonos+Alexa+iPad works perfectly fine for me, so...