4 ms·
There is PC, and there is the accusation of PC. One is held to be self-censorship. The other is a tool to disarm your opposition by accusing them of behaviours
by ggm 9y ago
There is PC, and there is the accusation of PC. One is held to be self-censorship. The other is a tool to disarm your opposition by accusing them of behaviours which disfavour their intellectual honesty, or claim your own views are being excluded.
Speaking in code is normal. "we dont like your sort" is a phrase which can crop up in a western, bad guys talking to good guys, or in a realtors office "white realtor to black purchasor" or in a cake shop "christian cake maker, to gay couple" -There is no visible pejorative quality to your or your sort but contextually its understood.
The PC moment, is denying the existence of the power relationships in the topic. I have an intense dislike of a six letter word used in the times of Mark Twain and others to discuss african-americans. I cannot abide the word, I walk out of conversations where it comes up, and I avoid its use. I am appalled by the ?ironic? re-adoption of this word by the rap community, it is a huge thorn in the side of millions of people worldwide. Is this being PC? its what I feel. If somebody cannot rationally discuss race relations in the USA without use of this word, what have we come to? is english as a language so bancrupt, we have no alternatives?
The odd thing for me, is that the five letter alternative also starting with N, Negro, is now also a pejorative, when for so many years it wasn't. Truly, this is a minefield to negotiate. Then African-American, now people of colour. I like "people of colour" a lot. But I also know, in some time to come, it too will fall from grace. Yet, my residual hate for the six letter word remains. Nothing said here about PC will rid me of a sense the word is wrong, its use is wrong, and the intentionality using it, strongly disposes me to characterise somebody as belligerent in a power relationship.
Even used ironically.
- hippich 9y agoUSA was country of immigrants, and still is. Should newcomers carry same baggage of language? Should they be shamed for using these words?
- ggm 9y agoHow do newcomers acquire the use of these words? If we shift to one side slightly, how do lebanese arrivals learn to laugh at Polack jokes? What moment says its ok to laugh at those crazy poles, call them polacks, and have to sit by while the other guy tells jokes about rag-heads from the middle east? its a perpetuating hell. the only path out (I feel, but possibly wrongly) is to break the cycle.
- fapjacks 9y agoI don't think we'll be able to break the cycle until we encounter aliens and there's a whole new spectrum to use as a measuring stick to label outsiders. The cycle persists because of how different the outsiders are compared to "us" insiders. The human animal is like many animals, matching patterns in past experience and applying labels to those patterns in order to survive. Religion and superstition are fine examples of this behavior. As is racism and classism and politics, etc. I don't think this will change unless the pattern-matching, label-applying biology/behavior is eliminated, e.g. the human animal is changed into something that isn't human, or through semantics, e.g. unless the human animal is presented with something so extraordinary and counter to the status quo that the definitions are changed.
- hippich 9y agoIn ex-USSR at least, and, I bet, in many spanish speaking countries, word "negr" or "negros" refers to any dark-skinned person without any baggage of slavery, diminishing mental capabilities or anything like that. (Word "nigger" is not really used in ex-USSR except may be some teen groups who listen too much to rap music, and still does not carry same baggage) Why these immigrants should be shamed for use of these words, why some should be offended by words? Intent should matter. And if bad intent is not there - there should be no judgement. That how empathy works both ways.
- mirimir 9y agoI get strange looks sometimes, when I say that I like the Norwegian deathpunk group Turbonegro. And then there are those Texan punk groups with names that I self-censor.
- classicsnoot 9y agoEvery country is made up of immigrants. Stating this brings nothing to the table. Language is an enormous part of culture and social interaction. It is incumbent upon the people that relocate to a region, country, or community to adapt to those that are already there, particularly if there is a thriving and productive community in place. It would be completely unfair if a bunch of Liberal Americans who are fed up with Trump moved to a small East Asian country and expected them to put English on all the signs just because they were fleeing a political faction they abhorred. This is not a right v. wrong situation; there is a logical process to the civil redistribution of population. If it is not civil (be it desperation ((Syria)), enforced ((German speakers after WWII)), or appropriative ((Europeans in North America))) then this point is moot, but in the 21st century we cannot act like people just accidentally end up in more economically beneficial areas.
- stcredzero 9y agoIt would be completely unfair if a bunch of Liberal Americans who are fed up with Trump moved to a small East Asian country and expected them to put English on all the signs just because they were fleeing a political faction they abhorred. Somehow, various Chinatowns in the US seem to do alright, even though many of them have signs in Chinese. There is an amazing amount of wealth generated there, though there's also often a greater degree of squalor. (One exception is Houston's Bellaire, though there may be seedier parts of that I'm not familiar with.)
- hippich 9y agoI think USA is much more `immigrantish` than many other countries. Compare USA to Japan for example. Of course it is expected that most immigrants adopt most of cultural aspects of the new life, but not all of it. And each immigrant brings part of his cultural heritage too. So culture will change over time. Accordingly to this - https://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/immigrant-population-over-time https://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/imm... - immigrants are close to 15% of total population. This chart also does not mention number of children of these immigrants. These are people who do not have this inherited and ingrained guilt for enslavement simply because they did not live here when that was happening, nor their ancestors to tell them stories.
- stcredzero 9y agoI have an intense dislike of a six letter word used in the times of Mark Twain and others to discuss african-americans. I cannot abide the word, I walk out of conversations where it comes up, and I avoid its use. The mother of my ex-girlfriend of 7 years had the same attitude about that word. Is this being PC? its what I feel. It matters how those feelings are used. If feelings, like offense, are used as emotional/moral bludgeons and accusations, primarily to silence opponents, then it's dishonest and counterproductive. Likewise, if words are primarily used as emotional sandpaper, to wear away at an opponent, then it's equally dishonest and counterproductive. Nothing said here about PC will rid me of a sense the word is wrong, its use is wrong, and the intentionality using it, strongly disposes me to characterise somebody as belligerent in a power relationship. The solution is rational discussion. I don't think there are productive uses of that word. I also don't think that the majority of accusations of racism and sexism are meaningful, used as they have been as bludgeons in a cultural war of feelings and ideas. What's more the shame, is that I think there is very good reason for discussion. There is racism. However accusations at this point will generally make things worse. The cure for it, which I have seen work in the real world, is interchange. Discussion, watching things together, sharing food, just getting to know people -- this is how toxic -isms are defeated. Acrimony isn't that. Acrimony is the fuel to the in-group/out-group mentality of the mob. Acrimony is the fuel of toxic "-isms."
- DanielBMarkham 9y agoAgreed. A key question is whether or not a person can enter into a public forum, such as a discussion on town policy, use a slur, and continue to be heard and engaged intellectually. If they can, then the process of self-governing can continue. If they can't -- and to the degree they can't -- we are shutting people down and making them lesser citizens because of our desire to be "language police". That's PC. In small groups, of course, there are completely different rules, set by each community. That's how it should be. If combat soldiers are worried over one person's use of bigoted language, they've got their heads in the wrong place. (That language might need to be corrected. It's a decision for each group to make.) If academic or religious groups talk about language, it might be a completely different discussion. Or not. What Political Correctness seeks to do is create a universal language standard for all types of communication, then punish or silence those who fail to abide by it. It's the type of thing that might be spot-on for the local model railroad club or bowling league -- but is completely anathema to the foundations of our way of life if applied universally. Modern communication systems continue to exacerbate rather than mitigate the problem. Many people do not see the big deal, wondering "what's wrong with requiring all of us to be nicer to one another?" These people do not understand the problem and are just making things worse for society overall in their desire to be "nice". Quite ironic.
- Pica_soO 9y agoMy beef is with people who are heroic fighters against past injustices, while the company the work for walks over the rights of the same people today. Who cares for a politicly loaded word used- when somebody perfectly nice and gentile - can manage a hedge-fund that deprives a whole african country of basic infrastructure for profit or a chance to boot-strap some basic industry with market protection laws. I dont care, if my anger ruins anyones "we-can-have-nice-things" party on a mountain of bodys. If somebody uses the N-Word as a battering ram to get to the rotten Core behind these PC- Disney Castles - here have a megaphone.