2 ms·
The problem with giving animals rights is that ultimately they'd have to be able to communicate in court, and it's not clear that assigning them a proxy is suff
by cryptonector 9y ago
The problem with giving animals rights is that ultimately they'd have to be able to communicate in court, and it's not clear that assigning them a proxy is sufficient to represent the animal. But if ever we find a way to communicate well enough for an animal to understand the concept of "court", or even just "tell us how you feel about this", then such an animal must be accorded rights commensurate with its ability to communicate and self-control.
(An animal that cannot keep from committing what to us are "crimes" can't be given all the rights that a human has. But supposing we figure out how to communicate such concepts to, say, orangutans, and they can handle them, then they must have rights equal to ours.)
Merely having personality and feelings cannot enough, otherwise we'd be obligated to eat no vertebrates -- I'd not be pleased to go that far!
- maxxxxx 9y agoWe have children who can't communicate in court but still have rights so that wouldn't necessarily stop an animal rights movement. But I agree that giving rights to all animals would make our life much less convenient. We probably could make the lives of a lot of animals much better without too much effort though. For example, abandoning factory framing and reducing meat consumption would be very doable.
- cryptonector 9y agoYeah, but children (and non-communicative disabled adults) do not have quite the same rights as you or I. In fact, their rights are not too unlike those of, say, pets. Except that when children grow up, or the non-communicative issue is resolved in an adult, they become emancipated. Animals don't reach that stage, and it's not a stretch to say that it's about communication capabilities.
- RikNieu 9y agoThis is an interesting comment and made me consider various scenarios and situations. For one instance, 'Right to Live' would mean we can eat/use animal products anymore - but what about plants then? If you listen to the RadioLab episode Smart Plants, who knows what will be discovered about them in the future. And for most of humanity, most cultures have survived on animal consumption and animal products. Also, would these laws be enforceable on animals too? How would you feed predators and omnivores? But what about instead of instead of specific rights like those afforded to people, we adopt more general 'kindness' rights to other living beings. For instance; the right of any animal to not being tortured, the right of kept animals to not be subjected to reasonable sized spaces(however that might be determined), the right of kept animals to medical treatment, the right of kept animals to the food it would be consuming in nature, ect. Not sure how this would all be controlled and enforced(or even how this applies to current animal rights laws), but interesting to think about.
- cryptonector 9y agoOne might say that obligate carnivores (e.g., felines) get to eat other animals. Humans aren't quite obligate carnivores (though some of us might feel that we are :)... We already do have animal cruelty laws -- we already forbid cruelty to animals. And we forbid hunting of endangered species' individuals. Some jurisdictions have laws about how much space domesticated animals must be accorded to live in. So it's not like we accord animals no rights.