3 ms·
The answer is regulating data - not algorithms or hardware - the data. I'm not saying it should happen, but if you want to regulate AI then you have to regulate
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
The answer is regulating data - not algorithms or hardware - the data. I'm not saying it should happen, but if you want to regulate AI then you have to regulate the data that it learns from. That means strict rules on storage, retrieval, scale, uses of, collection etc... of images, video, text, metadata, EM emissions, really anything that produces a measurable "signature" of some sort.
It's how we regulate nuclear [1] - the "source material" is the most important part, while the refineries, delivery mechanisms etc are secondary.
Doing this would put serious brakes on the tech industry so I don't see anything close to this happening honestly.
[1]https://www.nrc.gov/materials/srcmaterial.html https://www.nrc.gov/materials/srcmaterial.html
- kakarot 9y agoAre you serious? That kind of widespread banning of information is fundamentally incompatible with a democratic society. It's absolutely preposterous to think that I could prevent someone from downloading and using a database of pictures, EM emissions, basically anything that a government deems dangerous, via threat of State violence. That is as draconian and authoritarian as it gets. How do you even enforce such a law? You would need unrestricted access to every system. Otherwise, you are only harming legitimate researchers and enthusiasts, not criminals. Criminals are still going to access and download whatever the hell they want. How do we determine what can "help" AI and what can't? Is it the number of sources you have that should be restricted? Is there a committee that decides this? Are the proceedings open to civilian involvement? Who decides what is okay and what isn't? Can corporations or government organizations (military) apply for this data? Why can groups of people with lots of money and infrastructure have it, but not me? How does this prevent a further segregation of socioeconomic classes? Comparing nuclear "source material" to random data like images, video, metadata, etc is downright deceitful. If you aren't being purposefully deceitful, you really need to reflect upon exactly how such a law would be carried out, the logistics of its enforcement, and the limitations. It's a logistical nightmare and is infinitely more complex to enforce than it should be, not to mention downright anti-democratic. Damn right it shouldn't happen.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoAgreed. Again, it would be terrible for society, but if you wanted to regulate AI it would be the more effective way to go about it IMO. There was a short story based on an implementation of this, I don't recall what it's called.
- kakarot 9y agoIt's not at all the most effective. It's only the most effective if you severely limit what factors into that.