6 ms·
>In two recent articles, Professor Shawn Bayern demonstrated that anyone can confer legal personhood on an autonomous computer algorithm merely by putting it in
by nabla9 9y ago
>In two recent articles, Professor Shawn Bayern demonstrated that anyone
can confer legal personhood on an autonomous computer algorithm merely
by putting it in control of a limited liability company (LLC). 10 The algorithm
can exercise the rights of the entity, making them effectively rights of the
algorithm.
>The rights of such an algorithmic entity (AE) would include the rights to
privacy, 11 to own property, to enter into contracts, to be represented by counsel, to be free from unreasonable search and seizure, 12 to equal protection of
the laws, 13 to speak freely, and perhaps even to spend money on political
campaigns. 14 Once an algorithm had such rights, Bayern observed, it would
also have the power to confer equivalent rights on other algorithms by form-
ing additional entities and putting those algorithms in control of them. 15
---
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2758222 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2758222
Shawn Bayern, The Implications of Modern Business Entity Law for the Regulation
of Autonomous Systems, 19 S TAN . T ECH . L. R EV . 93 (2015) [hereinafter Bayern, Entity
Law]; Shawn Bayern, Of Bitcoins, Independently Wealthy Software, and the Zero-Member
LLC, 108 N W . U. L. R EV . 1485 (2014) [hereinafter Bayern, Wealthy Software].
>Abstract
>Nonhuman autonomous systems are not legal persons under current law. The history of organizational law, however, demonstrates that agreements can, with increasing degrees of autonomy, direct the actions of legal persons. Agreements are isomorphic with algorithms; that is, a legally enforceable agreement can give legal effect to the arbitrary discernible states of an algorithm or other process. As a result, autonomous systems may end up being able, at least, to emulate many of the private-law rights of legal persons. This essay demonstrates a technique by which this is possible by means of limited liability companies (LLCs), a very flexible modern type of business organizations. The techniques that this essay describes are not just futuristic possibilities; as this essay argues, they are already possible under current law.
- xenadu02 9y agoRight up until the first real court challenge where any competent judge will declare algorithms are not persons, cannot own property, and an LLC without any legitimate ownership interest is an abandoned entity (making all its assets abandoned property). Alternatively for criminal purposes the courts will simply "pierce the veil" and declare the actual owners to be the humans profiting from the algorithm's actions. Judges don't, as a rule, enjoy "cute tricks".
- hedvig 9y agoI think the idea is that the ai could be emancipated from whatever "owner" it had, and then would control everything. It would be more efficient for profits to go back into the corporation instead of to any owner.
- Slansitartop 9y agoI don't see how that in any way counters the parent comment. If the judge thinks the "AI" is not a person, it cannot be emancipated by some trick with an LLC.
- hobofan 9y ago> and declare the actual owners to be the humans profiting from the algorithm's actions It counters the parent comment in that there would be no humans profiting from the algorithm, since all the profit is kept in the LLC and governed by the algorithm.
- Slansitartop 9y agoThen, by the parent comment's compelling logic, the profit along with the LLC would become abandoned property: >>>> and an LLC without any legitimate ownership interest is an abandoned entity (making all its assets abandoned property). The bit you quoted was in the context of assigning criminal liability, if the need arose. However, I don't think that "profit" would be the most important part of the analysis, but rather who was responsible for designing and setting up the corporate entity.
- r00fus 9y agoThe idea being corrupted by the fact that at some point the AI was owned by someone - it would be a real stretch to assume that any subsequent emancipation is not going to be scrutinized heavily. It's the weak legal point here in the entire idea.
- clord 9y agoIt would still have to buy the services of the former owner (or someone equivalent). there are after-all things only a human can do, still, and presumably this corp would have to pay for those things.
- marshray 9y agoWhat jurisdiction allows corporations to be created without filing articles of incorporation that list human officers?