4 ms·
This is a really long list. How much of this is needed due to US securities law and how much to say "hey, you are really doing this on your own volition, all of
by baybal2 9y ago
This is a really long list. How much of this is needed due to US securities law and how much to say "hey, you are really doing this on your own volition, all of our cards are on the desk?"
So much for a private sale of shares. In Pakistan, a proper listing agent can put your company on the stock exchange in under 2 month with most of this time just waiting for permits to arrive through snail mail.
- jacquesm 9y agoThis list is absolutely tiny, think of it as a starting point rather than an exhaustive list of what a typical data room looks like for a mid-sized merger, acquisition or investment. Pakistan is not exactly known as a hotbed for serious start-up activity, clearly the list is US centric.
- baybal2 9y ago>think of it as a starting point rather than an exhaustive list of what a typical data room looks like for a mid-sized merger, acquisition or investment. And that is stunning by itself. This is a reason to think one more time about US business culture. Especially for people repeatedly poking developing countries for dysfunctional bureaucracy. >Pakistan is not exactly known as a hotbed for serious start-up activity, clearly the list is US centric. Hmm. You should put this view to doubt. As a former British colony, Pakistan used to have a lot of stock exchanges even in relatively small cities. Most companies being listed there were small and medium businesses while "reel-old-money" big business groups were kept private. A typical listing just few years ago could've been from an entrepreneur who opened a concrete factory, or a trucker cooperative opening an industrial commodities company all popping no more than 10 to 20m USD a year. In US, the size of stock market just few years ago was tiny in comparison to the titanic debt market. The ratio of stock to debt market size does look much favourably to me in the "not-a-hotbed-for-serious-startups" Pakistan than in the US
- jacquesm 9y ago> This is a reason to think one more time about US business culture. I am not in the US but in Europe and it is much the same here. > A typical listing just few years ago could've been from an entrepreneur who opened a concrete factory, or a trucker cooperative opening an industrial commodities company all popping no more than 10 to 20m USD a year. Those are not the kind of companies this is aimed at, a series A as referenced in the article is typically seen as the first serious investment post validation of a concept. The stock market has very little to do with any of this, most of these companies are - and will remain - privately held, it's a rare exception that one of them will make it to IPO.
- shimms 9y agoYup - tiny. Just checked the DD we did on a recent acquisition: 503 rows just in the "checklist", most of which resulted in further documents, statements, references to other systems, explanation, reports, exports from HR systems you name it. Took a few weeks to compile, even though we had all the information readily accessible. The initial check list was pretty fast to do, but it spawned subsequent requests, discussions, etc which required more documentation to be found and provided etc.
- patio11 9y agoThere is a saying in certain engineering fields that all regulations are written in blood; an accident was once caused due to the lack of a particular line item and now that line item is on the list. This is a relatively short list for due diligence. While far less dramatic than an engineering fault which could actually kill someone, there have absolutely been extremely expensive incidents in the US which occasioned each item on this list. A portion of them are due to peculiarities of doing business in the United States, which is organized to accomplish many forms of dispute resolution via a professionalized process backstopped by formal legal process, in a fashion which may not be similar to e.g. Pakistan, Japan, most European countries, etc. US companies do frequently generate more legal work than comparable situated companies in other jurisdictions. (There are varieties of work they generate less of, but I'll leave that out of the scope of this comment.) The legal profession, like all service professions, sometimes recommends work which is not directly in the customer's interests, but in the main it is in the business of decreasing transactional risk. There are material risks involved in investing in a company with undisclosed baggage. Additionally, insisting on a certain level of professionalism helps to shake out other problems, because firms which cannot self-organize to e.g. provide a list of all employees and the paperwork related to them are almost certainly catastrophically managed under the hood. You might not even be creative enough to successfully predict how they're going to blow up, because the theoretical space of mistakes one can make is infinite, but you know that anyone who can't produce a signed copy of an employment agreement on demand is highly unlikely to have a level of risk which is roughly representative of your experience from the distribution of companies which are at least minimally competent.
- siegel 9y agoI disagree with almost none of this. I would just note two quick things: 1) Due diligence requests are made by the investor, not offered by the company. So, it's not about the company's desire for full disclosure or the company's interest in complying with SEC regs. (SEC regs require certain types of disclosures in connection with certain types of placements of securities. The typical VC funding round doesn't require such disclosures.) 2) Yes, lawyers are in the business of decreasing transactional risk. But, relatedly though slightly different, the reason VC lawyer due diligence requests are so long is that lawyers are risk averse. There is no downside to the lawyers to add something to the DD list, but there is certainly a potential cost if they leave something off. And the junior lawyers who deal with these things aren't being paid for creativity or independent judgment...(Not a knock on them. It's just not what junior lawyers are tasked with.)