4 ms·
Tesla's autopilot function is horribly named and not at all identical to plane autopilot. Modern autopilots are actually fully capable of handling takeoff, fli
by gamblor956 9y ago
Tesla's autopilot function is horribly named and not at all identical to plane autopilot.
Modern autopilots are actually fully capable of handling takeoff, flight, and landing without interaction from the pilot. However, pilots continue to handle takeoff and landing procedures to maintain skills in those areas as generally an autopilot failure during those times would not be recoverable.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoCapable of handling _each_ of the functions (NOT switching between the modes - "sit on tarmac, punch in destination, go take a nap"; plus I'm not entirely sure if the feature you describe as autotakeoff even exists outside Hollywood), exclusively on the happy path with strict minima, with pilots required to take over at once in case of any irregularity. Highly convenient, but not a self-flying miracle.
- gamblor956 9y agoThe features I have described are available in the Dreamliner and the Airbus 380, and have been more than a Hollywood fantasy for at least a decade... Self-flying isn't as difficult as people think it is. There are fewer obstacles and risks to deal with.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoNope. There are features such as thrust assymetry compensation, and you could technically engage the autopilot as low as 200 ft AGL, but I maintain that there is no automatic takeoff available on commercial aircraft (there's something related on catapult-launched fighter jets, but that's quite another world). If you're claiming a feature exists "in the Dreamliner and the Airbus 380...over a decade" - well, [citation-needed], then: all the sources that I've managed to find are unanimous that it doesn't, e.g. http://www.askthepilot.com/questionanswers/automation-myths/ http://www.askthepilot.com/questionanswers/automation-myths/ To quote the pilot above: "That fantasy insists on outpacing reality is perhaps symptomatic of our infatuation with technology, and the belief that we can compute our way out of every dilemma or complication."
- Chriky 9y agoSome modern airports REQUIRE pilots to use auto landing if their plane supports it. I know because I have a friend who is a commercial pilot and they don't like flying those routes because it is boring. Most airports let the pilots fly manually if they want.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoPossible. What I'm saying is "the plane can do many things, but 1. won't switch modes e.g. from cruise to autoland, and 2. even so, it's just a different way of controlling the plane, it does not fly itself."
- mschuster91 9y ago> Modern autopilots are actually fully capable of handling takeoff, flight, and landing without interaction from the pilot. No they're not. The pilot needs to initiate the sequences first, and good luck when something unexpected happens - a Tesla (or any truck/car with auto-distance-control) will brake when a car changes lanes right in front of it, a plane will blare sirens (okay, to be fully correct: it will tell the pilot a preferred course of action to avoid a collision) if another plane comes too close for comfort but not do any evasive action on its own. Even in a perfectly ordinary flight there are always the ATCs to serve as master controllers for all airplanes... something you also have in railways, but not at all on the road. On the road everyone is on his own.
- ghshephard 9y agoModern airplanes are pretty good at avoiding head-on collisions though - so good, that pilots are trained not to override the planes judgement, and just let it communicate with the other plane and make the best calls as to whether to climb or dive...