3 ms·
I think many people would like to institutionalize the homeless I absolutely do not want to institutionalize the homeless. I want to institutionalize the ment
by cperciva 16y ago
I think many people would like to institutionalize the homeless
I absolutely do not want to institutionalize the homeless. I want to institutionalize the mentally ill.
For sure there are mentally ill people that are homeless but I'd be highly surprised if that was the majority. For the most part they're just ordinary people down on their luck abandoned by friends and family
You're right that the vast majority of people who become homeless are not mentally ill. However, the vast majority of people who stay homeless are mentally ill.
- jacquesm 16y ago> However, the vast majority of people who stay homeless are mentally ill. That's likely true but it is only a very small portion of the total. And many of those are still not mentally ill, just substance abusers (which has it's own long term effects on mentality, compounding the problem).
- cperciva 16y agomany of those are still not mentally ill, just substance abusers Drug addiction is a form of mental illness. (Also, many long-term homeless drug addicts are "dual diagnosis", i.e., have some other mental illness as well.)
- jacquesm 16y ago> Drug addiction is a form of mental illness. No it isn't. If I inject you with heroin for a couple of weeks steady that makes you a drug addict, but not mentally ill.
- cperciva 16y agoDSM-IV counts substance abuse as a psychiatric disorder, and research has shown that it is far more effective to treat substance abuse as a health issue than otherwise. But I think we may have to agree to disagree here.
- jacquesm 16y agoI think we're already agreeing for the most part: Substance abuse is a different thing than being addicted, you can't use the terms interchangeably. The one is a mental problem, the other has to do with the brain in a very specific biochemical sense. I think that for the most part there is plenty of overlap between the two in terms of the people that are afflicted but there is a direct biochemical reason behind being addicted to any drug that is not directly related to mental illness.
- natep 16y agoTo clarify, addiction is a disease. According to Dr Drew Pinsky in an interview on "The Eyes of Nye" (yes, that's another Bill Nye show) > The definition of a disease for me would be 'an abnormal physiological process brought on by a relationship between the genetics of the individual and the environment. That path of physiology would create a set of signs and symptoms that progress in a predictable way that we would call a 'natural history' and by affecting the natural history we create a predictable response to treatment [...] and addiction does fit that, but people get hung up on where the physiology goes wrong. They don't understand that it's a brain disease.
- mattchew 16y ago> I want to institutionalize the mentally ill. Institutionalize is a nice, clinical sounding word, but what it means is incarcerate. Imprison. You are talking about locking up people without them committing any crime, without any trial, without them having any appeal or defense, for a week, or a year, or their entire life. You, I suspect, would condemn a police authority who wanted to imprison whoever it liked, for however long it liked, on grounds of serving the general good. It is just as wrong to give a medical authority those powers and declare they'll only be used to help the people they're imprisoning.
- ghshephard 16y agoWell - let's keep this in context. I lived in Vancouver both Pre/Post Institutionalization - and I'm pretty certain those people who are chronically homeless lived much better and happier lives when they had a warm home to sleep in, and people to watch out after them. And, I don't know what institutions you are referring to, but Riverview (one of the mental health institutions) had a Bus Stop in it. Crazy people were always getting on board - It's true that people who posed a threat to themselves or others, or were in for evaluation to determine if that were the case had their ability to leave restricted - but I don't think "Institution" and "Prison" are synonymous.
- cperciva 16y agoYou are talking about locking up people without them committing any crime, without any trial, without them having any appeal or defense, for a week, or a year, or their entire life. Not at all. In Canada, at least, people in psychiatric institutions have ample opportunity to challenge their detention. Their cases are reviewed and they are considered for release far more often than those who are convicted of crimes are.
- mattchew 16y agoIn the bad old days in the U.S., crazy people, or people deemed crazy, could be kept in a mental institution against their will for years and years. When I hear people decrying deinstitutionalization, I assume they want to return to those bad old days. I don't know about Canada, past or present.