6 ms·
Stories like this make me wish that it was easier for homeless people to be declared mentally ill and placed into mental health facilities. (Damn you, deinstit
by cperciva 16y ago
Stories like this make me wish that it was easier for homeless people to be declared mentally ill and placed into mental health facilities. (Damn you, deinstitutionalization.)
There are some people who are homeless because they're poor, but in the vast majority of cases it seems that the primary problem has nothing to do with not having a home.
- pyre 16y ago> (Damn you, deinstitutionalization.) Read up on what actually happened in those places. Read up on 999 Queen St. (for a Canadian example) or watch "Mental: A History of the Madhouse" (a BBC Documentary for a British example). I would agree with you if those places didn't end up being worse than prisons... ("No one will believe the crazy girl when she says that I raped her!", etc) [edit] In general, Canada seems to have better support for mental health issues than the US does.
- cperciva 16y agoI would agree with you if those places didn't end up being worse than prisons... Thing is, the streets are worse than (Canadian) prisons, too. It's not unheard-of for homeless people to ask judges to please send them to jail. But more significantly: We need to fix mental health institutions. Saying "making functional mental health institutions is hard, let's go ride bikes" is fundamentally failing in our obligations to the mentally ill.
- jacquesm 16y agoAnother big issue is failing to provide a social security network that actually works in that it helps those in real need and has enough of an incentive to get out of the program again. There seem to be only two versions of this, one that leaves people without incentive to go back to work (the European model) and another that says 'you're on your own' tough luck. Another thing that jumped out at me in these stories was the lady that had daughters but was living on the street anyway. If my mom were about to be homeless she'd be living here, not on the street and I'm sure my brother and sister would think about it just the same.
- cperciva 16y agoAnother big issue is failing to provide a social security network that actually works in that it helps those in real need and has enough of an incentive to get out of the program again. Canada's welfare system is just fine, actually. The "Jason" in the article is a good example of how it works -- shortly after becoming homeless, he talked to the welfare office, he found an apartment which rented for the standard welfare rate, and if he hasn't already moved in, he almost certainly will within the next week. The vast majority of instances of homelessness are resolved quickly in exactly this manner. Why doesn't this happen for the small minority who end up being long-term homeless? To a very large extent, it comes down to one thing: Mentally ill people aren't very good at doing paperwork. People who are addicted to drugs or are schizophrenic aren't very likely to accomplish the steps Jason went through to get welfare-funded housing.
- jacquesm 16y agoTo put paper obstacles in the way of those in need that are unable to pass those hurdles is not a system that is 'fine'.
- philwelch 16y agoIt's not unheard-of for homeless people to ask judges to please send them to jail. There's a fairly simple algorithm to ending up in jail: commit a crime and get caught for it. I wonder why you don't see more of that if homeless people are so desperate for shelter. (Though if they're mentally ill, that might explain why it doesn't occur to them, or why they're not terribly effective at making and implementing effective plans.)
- cperciva 16y agoThere's a fairly simple algorithm to ending up in jail: commit a crime and get caught for it. For minor crimes, that's ineffective: You'll be arrested, charged, and released back onto the streets with an order to turn up in court at a later date. As for why such people don't commit more serious crimes -- homeless people aren't (necessarily) psychopaths. Wanting to have a warm place to sleep and decent meals doesn't mean that they'll go out and kill someone just to get themselves arrested.
- natep 16y agoThere was an article in the past few months (or maybe longer, if it was a reading assignment) about one homeless man in NYC that had a yearly tradition of putting on his nicest coat, going to a fancy restaurant and eating a large meal, and then saying he couldn't pay. He would then go to jail for the winter. He cost the city upwards of hundreds of thousands of dollars. So yes, it happens, and yes, it is far more expensive than simply providing the necessary social services to begin with.
- pavs 16y agoI have been reading up a lot of Neuropsychology books and articles recently (not to be confused with pop-psych), and I have noticed that I have gained a lot of understanding, tolerance and acceptance of other people (and my own) and their mental quips. Once you start to understand how the brain works (not superficially, but _really_ have a good grasp), you start seeing yourself and world around you in a different way. I might go as far as proposing that studying psychology is as humbling experience as studying cosmology and astronomy.
- izendejas 16y agoI've had the same experience. Truly humbling, indeed. One mental condition that really fascinates me is schizophrenia as you begin to understand reality is the brain's way of interpreting chemical, visual, auditory, tactile and other external stimuli, but also via its internal chemical reactions, neural connections that can go haywire. Cognitive dissonance is another topic I'm fascinated by and wish everyone would know about it. Anyway, if your interested in these subjects, but don't want to read very technical papers, I recommend reading Jonah Lehrer as he'll point you in some interesting directions: http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/frontal-cortex http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/frontal-cortex
- mkramlich 16y agoAgreed. It would make "intelligent, successful" people be more humble about their accomplishments, if they realized that they were really lucky to have the genetic dice roll just the right way that their brains worked basically okay, with no significant distortions or blind spots in their reasoning and functioning ability.
- pavs 16y agoI have Jonah lehrer's blog on my feed. However I wouldn't recommend his books though (or most other mainstream pop-psych books). We recently read it on /r/NPBC (Neuropsychology Book Club) and I thought the book was an oversimplified interpretation to sell his predeterminer narrative of the book. Currently we are reading Antonio Damasio's "The Feeling of What Happens" (really enjoying it so far, very dense.) You can read Lehrer's unofficial reddit interview here (The OP, subtextual, is a professional Neuropsychologist): http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/d1pib/jonah_lehrer_author_of_how_we_decide_answers/ http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/d1pib/jonah_lehrer_aut... You can read my thoughts on his interview and his book on the comment's section. Same username.
- izendejas 16y agoSame goes for many criminals. The brain is a complex bunch of grey goo. So many ways the wiring can go wrong. We have a long way to go before we can fully understand psychiatric/psychological conditions, much less treat them.
- jacquesm 16y ago> Stories like this make me wish that it was easier for homeless people to be declared mentally ill and placed into mental health facilities. (Damn you, deinstitutionalization.) It's actually good that it is not so easy to declare people mentally ill, especially when they're not. Canada has a history of having it's 'social services' go completely out of control when given too much power, one nice example is the service that ostensibly protects children from abuse. (But in fact is just as likely to do great damage to both children and their families). I think many people would like to institutionalize the homeless just so the 'problem would go away', but homeless people are a symptom of a society that has issues, not just of those people. For instance, banks and lawyers contribute to the number of homeless people by making it too easy to declare people bankrupt, seizing their possessions and means of generating income or their house, or to destroy someones life in divorce proceedings. And then there are those that simply don't want to be part of the 'rat race' that have no other option but to become homeless (the Roma in Europe for instance). That used to be 'ok', but these days everything has to be owned by somebody so there is no way to be out of it all without trespassing. It's not all clear cut. For sure there are mentally ill people that are homeless but I'd be highly surprised if that was the majority. For the most part they're just ordinary people down on their luck abandoned by friends and family. And plenty of them hit the bottle or drugs after becoming homeless, not before.
- philwelch 16y agoThis article was posted here before (http://www.gladwell.com/2006/2006_02_13_a_murray.html http://www.gladwell.com/2006/2006_02_13_a_murray.html) and suggests homelessness might be a power-law problem. Ordinary people who are homeless because of everyday misfortune don't stay homeless for long and don't contribute to the homeless problem--chronically homeless people, many of whom are either mentally ill or mentally adapted to life on the street, are the biggest part of the problem.
- jacquesm 16y agoThe power law in the article refers to the costs associated with individuals, and to the number of people that were found to have returned to 'normal' life. So a relatively small number of people are responsible for the majority of the costs attributed to all homeless people (in that case mostly for hospital treatments), they stay homeless because they can't get out or don't want to get out. Those homeless people that are very motivated to stop being homeless will usually do so, those that are mentally ill or serious substance abusers have little to no chance. Those that have 'adapted to life on the streets', I find it hard to find fault with them, they chose that path, the problem is with 'us', the ones that are not homeless because we see them as a problem, but they might disagree. Being homeless is no picknick, but being in the rat race isn't either and some people might prefer the one over the other.
- xtho 16y agoDid you talk to those people when they became homeless or did you watch them after years of homelessness during which they were at best ignored by common people?