5 ms·
I like how you could throw one of these up on a single Falcon Heavy launch. The lack of windows seems challenging to me, if you're going after tourists I would
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I like how you could throw one of these up on a single Falcon Heavy launch. The lack of windows seems challenging to me, if you're going after tourists I would think this would be a priority feature.
- whatshisface 9y agoI imagine that one could attach a "window section" to one of the docking ports. You could build those things up modularly kind of like the ISS.
- j-pb 9y agoI wonder how big one of these inflatable stations could get if your strap it on top of the BFR ^^'. Any takers for a quick, back on the envelope calculation? Although, come to think of it. One reason why the BFR has such a f* huge passenger capacity is because structure that would normally be dead weight and only used for payload packaging like the nose cone and adapter, are replaced by the spaceship itself.
- sq_ 9y agoGive me a few minutes, and I'll see if I can come up with a rough number. Edit: got something, commented above.
- sq_ 9y agoOk, I have a very rough number for the possible size if launched on a fully reusable BFR with payload based on a talk Elon gave in late 2017 [1]. I'm assuming that internal space scales roughly linearly and that deflated width isn't a factor when flying on the BFR, so I could be way off. Here's the math: Fully reusable BFR can do ~150,000 kg to LEO, Bigelow B330 weighs ~50,000 lbs or ~22,676 kg [2] B330 has 330 m^3 of space [3], and the BFR could lift roughly 6.6 B330's 330 * 6.6 = 2,178 m^3 So, with my assumptions, a fully reusable BFR would be able to lift a Bigelow module with about 2,178 cubic meters of internal space. Of course, I'm probably forgetting something and my assumptions are probably off; however, I think that it's safe to assume that a fully reusable BFR could lift a very big module to LEO. [1] http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/making_life_multiplanetary_transcript_2017.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/making_life_multipl... [2] http://www.bigelowspaceops.com/b330.php http://www.bigelowspaceops.com/b330.php [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B330 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B330 Edit: based on what @hughes said below, it looks like I did forget something: volume scales at a different rate than surface area. So it looks like the internal volume would be more like 5600 m^3.
- hughes 9y agoApproximating the station as a hollow shell of constant thickness, the mass would scale with the surface area. The volume would scale proportional to the surface area to the power of 3/2. So 6.6x the mass gets you 6.6x the surface area, which gets you about 17x the volume, or ~5600m^3
- sq_ 9y agoAh, figured I was forgetting something. Editing my comment to reflect what you said. Thanks for the correction!
- avmich 9y agoEven though volume grows with 3rd power of size and area with 2nd, you'd still better calculate volume here as 2nd power. The reason is that you usually want to have progressively thicker walls when the size of the object grows, and that - linear with diameter - growth of thickness reduces available weight, so the volume still grows as 2nd power. But even then FH would deliver huge volumes on orbit.
- j-pb 9y agoOk, here's the kicker! I spun heh this a bit further, and imagined an inflatable torus with the same surface area and thus weight. With an inner radius of 30m you get a comfy diameter of ~2.5m. [1] If we throw this into spincalc [2] and ask it to compute the rotation rate of such a station to get mars gravity levels of 0.376g. Then we get ~3.2 revolutions per minute, which is well within human comfort levels according to this study [3]. (4 is the max) So yeah this would basically allow you to shoot up a retrofuturistic rotating space station with comfortable gravity levels for future martians in one shot. Wow! [1] http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=outer+radius+of+a+torus+with+1525+square+meters+surface+and+inner+radius+of+30m http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=outer+radius+of+a+torus... [2] http://www.artificial-gravity.com/sw/SpinCalc/ http://www.artificial-gravity.com/sw/SpinCalc/ [3] http://www.spacefuture.com/archive/artificial_gravity_and_the_architecture_of_orbital_habitats.shtml http://www.spacefuture.com/archive/artificial_gravity_and_th...
- 9y ago
- sq_ 9y agoIf I remember correctly, the B330 is too big in terms of width to launch with the current fairing on a Falcon Heavy; although I think that Elon indicated at some point that they could do bigger fairings at customer request. It'd definitely be awesome to see essentially an entire space station go up on top of one FH though.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoIt would be better to design the B330 to be its own fairing with just a launcher specific adapter ring at the base. That would provide a significant weight savings, reduce the volumetric constraints, and eliminate fairing separation mishaps.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOh I like that idea. I'm not sure how it would expose the docking ports once in orbit though.
- greglindahl 9y agoFairings are an extremely tricky thing to design, and the B330 is not made out of materials that can survive a launch.
- avmich 9y agoFalcon's fairing is about 5 m diameter, B330 is about 6 m diameter. Don't think B330 can't fit given that when not inflated it has smaller diameter.
- nkoren 9y agoIt's actually the length of the fairing that's the issue. The Falcon fairing can only accommodate payloads 11.4m long. The BA 330 is 16.8m long, and that doesn't compress at all.
- avmich 9y ago> The Falcon fairing can only accommodate payloads 11.4m long. Are you sure? I was under impression I've read about 17 meters long fairing. Maybe for FH only. Edit: "The fairing itself is 43 feet high and 17 feet wide, big enough, as the company points out, to hold a city bus." http://www.cleveland.com/science/index.ssf/2013/05/nasas_plum_brook_station_tests.html http://www.cleveland.com/science/index.ssf/2013/05/nasas_plu... So, 43 feet or 13,1 m. And this perhaps include nose part, which is conical rather than cylindrical. OTOH Bigelow can definitely adjust the size. And from what I saw on the explanation video, B330 grows both in diameter and in length when deployed. So - ?
- curtis 9y agoYou could attach something like the ISS Cupola module to it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cupola_(ISS_module) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cupola_(ISS_module)
- jessriedel 9y ago> The lack of windows seems challenging to me I think it actually has 4 windows along the torso (i.e., not just the end caps), albeit fairly small. See the slides here https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/robert-bigelow-visio-future-living-space-180958698/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/robert-bigelow... and the first image here http://newsok.com/u.s.-company-plans-to-send-inflatable-hotel-to-moon/article/5570952 http://newsok.com/u.s.-company-plans-to-send-inflatable-hote...