3 ms·
I'm not saying it doesn't happen, because it probably does, but it would be a surprise to me if using child labour is really cost competitive. I'd expect a coup
by roenxi 9y ago
I'm not saying it doesn't happen, because it probably does, but it would be a surprise to me if using child labour is really cost competitive. I'd expect a couple of small and desperate suppliers. Do you have a link handy?
Mining for bulk materials (iron ore, coal, copper, aggregates, etc) is going to be 100% mechanised at the scale that big buyers are interested in. If cobalt is still mined by the vein then maybe child laborers get used because they are smaller, but as battery production is getting serious child labour just won't work.
Take gold; you couldn't supply gold to a bullion bank with child labour because they do not produce fast enough. Big gold suppliers are happy with an orebody with grades measured in parts per million, and child cannot move a tonne of dirt as quickly, cheaply or consistently as a machine.
- philipkglass 9y agoI think that you're neglecting legality/stability issues. Artisan mining can eke out a profit at low productivity rates if the laborers are operating in locations that are de jure protected from mining, but de facto have weak law enforcement. That's a big driver of artisan mining of gold, including that using child labor. High-efficiency, high-capital-investment mining processes also require a certain amount of expected stability to justify the up-front costs. If big multinationals think that an armed group is likely to take their equipment at gunpoint, or destroy it, they'll stay away and never be in direct competition with the capital-poor, low-productivity small scale methods.
- XR0CSWV3h3kZWg 9y ago> Mining for bulk materials (iron ore, coal, copper, aggregates, etc) is going to be 100% mechanised at the scale that big buyers are interested in. Why do you assume that? It seems to be not the case for cobalt: https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/batteries/congo-cobalt-mining-for-lithium-ion-battery/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/batteries/c... Mechanization makes sense in much of the world because there is a high up front cost, but the ongoing costs are dominated by energy and maintenance costs. If those costs are higher than the general labor cost then why would you mechanize? Congo has been dominated by civil war for a long time, that generally depresses the cost of labor.
- roenxi 9y ago> Why do you assume that? I'm a mining engineer. If a western company has a choice between using manual labour and mechanised they will choose mechanised because it is cheaper, faster and more reliable. They don't care what the law is, because human mining is barely competitive even at small scales. Yes, it is a fact that there is child labour is used in some third world mines. I'm observing that it doesn't make sense to me that it is large-scale, because it only makes sense if the margins are huge, the volumes physically small and if there is an impoverished workforce. If Apple is going to negotiate with someone directly, it doesn't make sense to me that that someone using child labour, because purely economically they shouldn't be cost effective. They would be a marginal, higher-cost producer. Isn't there a more cost-effective producer that Apple could negotiate with? If there is a situation where human labour is cost effective at a scale Apple finds interesting, I am professionally curious because I didn't expect it to be possible. Hence a request for links. Even before negotiating, are their suppliers of serious quantities of cobalt that use human labour?