4 ms·
So... competition > ethics? Ethical software with less competition seems better than unethical software with more competition, eh?
by carapace 9y ago
So... competition > ethics?
Ethical software with less competition seems better than unethical software with more competition, eh?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rocqua 9y agoI worry that Ethical software will lose out to unethical software. There is too much pressure and low-hanging fruit to do any kind of gate-keeping that won't be circumvented. If you want to take the required measures to not circumvent the gate-keeper, that is strangling the entire sector. Since most developed countries see this sector as the basis for future growth, so doing that seems unlikely. Beyond that, the growth would probably move to less restrictive places.
- Bartweiss 9y agoI suppose the question is how much faith you have in oversight boards to actually produce ethical outcomes. My worry wouldn't be "they'll cut down on competition to ensure ethical behavior", it would be "they'll block competition and protect their member instead of ensuring ethics." I think the top-level essay here is extremely cogent: oversight is almost always limited to ensuring competence. In medicine, that gets us 'ethics' when ethics means "providing good care and avoiding bad care". (It hasn't gotten us ethics when the question is anything complicated, like defining mental illness.) Competence in data science and software is largely orthogonal to ethics, so I expect an oversight board would achieve very little in that regard.