3 ms·
> How this solves anything for the user? Is it not obvious? It would motivate major websites to clean up their act and sort out the bloat problem, with no need
by MaxBarraclough 9y ago
> How this solves anything for the user?
Is it not obvious? It would motivate major websites to clean up their act and sort out the bloat problem, with no need for yet another web technology.
- mrtksn 9y agoThat's a hypothesis that assumes that the major websites will get motivated until the users get frustrated by the low quality of search results. With AMP it's cheap and quick to implement, how long will it take for the websites to re-implement their codebase and all the tooling to match the performance criteria? Anyway, you're missing the point that I'm trying to make here: It's about the user's experience, it's not about the user's distribution to businesses. It's not your god given right to have users and make money.
- MaxBarraclough 9y ago> assumes that the major websites will get motivated until the users get frustrated by the low quality of search results. Fair point - changes to Google's rankings apply more pressure to small websites than to established ones. > it's not about the user's distribution to businesses. It's not your god given right to have users and make money. What?
- mrtksn 9y ago>What? What?
- MaxBarraclough 9y agoWell, what are you trying to say? Why are you telling me "It's not your god given right to have users and make money"? Why do you think this has any connection to our conversation?
- mrtksn 9y agoWhy do you think that web businesses are complaining about AMP but not the users? I'm yet to see a user that's not happy with AMP. The web community acts as if the users are a commodity like oil and Google just made a change in its flow and now begging Google to make it flow like before to accommodate their business setup and promising that from now on they will be nicer to the commodity and store it in golden barrels. I just don't buy it.
- MaxBarraclough 9y ago> I'm yet to see a user that's not happy with AMP. But you're talking to one. > begging Google to make it flow like before My understanding is that AMP doesn't necessarily impact ad revenues ( https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Accelerated_Mobile_Pages&oldid=825558132#Monetization https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Accelerated_Mobil... ). If it did, it wouldn't see adoption, no?
- mrtksn 9y agoI don't see your argument for not being happy with AMP as a user, so I can't tell.
- MaxBarraclough 9y agoYou've not responded to my point. I dislike AMP for essentially the same reasons listed in the article. Additionally, I value parsimony, which isn't mentioned in the article. I disdain anything that further bloats the web stack. Unless there's a very good reason for a new web technology - and here, there isn't - then we shouldn't further complicate the standards or our browsers.
- mrtksn 9y agoYour dislike is political. You dislike AMP the same way a Vegan doesn't like kebab, the problem is not that the kebab isn't delicious but that animals are harmed in making it. As for your ad revenue argument, not all the benefit from users is the direct ad revenue.
- mercer 9y agoIt's more than a little cynical to assume that most of us only care because we want to make money or grow our business. The way I see it, as people who have more knowledge about this domain than the average user, it's actively our responsibility to act in the best interest of the user (our parents, friends, etc.), even if said user might not appreciate or understand the effort. In the same way that I appreciate, say, doctors actively working against stupid/pointless stuff (homeopathy, avoid vaccination), I appreciate IT people trying to think beyond the immediate convenience of AMP.
- mrtksn 9y agoGood point, i’m also not THAT cynical but I don’t think that the web developers community as general has any integrity that resembles let’s say the medical community. Maybe the developers themselves are more idealistic but the web based businesses themselves more often than not are quite exploitative towards the users and that’s we have this sorry state of the web in general.