4 ms·
I think it's very important to address the reason why AMP is possible in the first place: Websites are so extremely slow these days. From users perspective, wh
by mrtksn 9y ago
I think it's very important to address the reason why AMP is possible in the first place: Websites are so extremely slow these days.
From users perspective, when I see the lightning icon on my search results I feel happy because it means that the page will show me it's contents as soon as I click it.
It means that the website is not going to show me white page for 15 seconds then start jumping around, changing shape and position for another 30 seconds until everything is downloaded.
I hear all the ethical/economical/strategic concerns but the tech community resembles the taxi industry a bit, that is, claiming that a tech that improves users experience significantly is bad for the user and must be stopped politically instead of addressing the UX issue that allows this tech to exist in first place.
- MaxBarraclough 9y agoThe tragedy of it is that web browsers have never been faster - it's just that websites insist on bloating, and bloating, and bloating. It's not unusual for modern websites to have literally megabytes of pointless JavaScript. (Reminder: Super Mario 64 weighs in at 8MB. The whole game.) AMP strikes me as a clever technical solution to a problem that doesn't need a technical solution. It just needs restraint and better web development with existing standard technologies, and ideally a strong taboo on bloated web-sites. See also two other technologies, the existences of which damn the web: Opera Mini (cloud rendering! and it's useful!), which can only exist for as long as the web is laughably inefficient, and Reader Mode, which improves modern web-design by removing it entirely.
- mrtksn 9y agoWhat people do when a website that goes popular on HN or Reddit is too slow or can't respond at all? Someone on the comments links to Google Cache and more often than not this js-less basic HTML snapshot is good enough. AMP is just a way to do this properly and automatically. The Webdev community chooses to ignore the speed of the content delivery and Google seized the opportunity. What can a modern webpage do for the user that 2008 webpage can't? For most of the web, the answer is nothing, all the improvements are about better tooling for the management(measure and monetize) of the webpage.
- tankenmate 9y ago"AMP is just a way to do this properly and automatically." I don't automatically dispute the second part of that statement, but the "properly" bit requires more than a handwave to prove its point.
- mrtksn 9y agoProperly means properly for the user, that is, without the aesthetically breaking the page or losing content(as it happens with google cache sometimes). Nobody cares about the business that runs the website, businesses don't have god given rights to get users and make money. If some other business serves the users better(i.e. Google with AMP) they can get all the users. Who felt sorry for MySpace when getting killed by Facebook or who advocated the right of having users for Digg when everyone moved to Reddit? Another thing is being a monopoly and exploiting that position, which is always a concern with giants like Google but at this moment with AMP doesn't seem to be the case.
- tankenmate 9y agoIf nobody cares about the businesses at the other end then one day you'll wake up to find that the only business left on the other side is Google, and then where will you turn? Roper: So now you'd give the Devil benefit of law! More: Yes. What would you do? Cut a great road through the law to get after the Devil? Roper: I'd cut down every law in England to do that! More: Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned round on you — where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country's planted thick with laws from coast to coast — man's laws, not God's — and if you cut them down — and you're just the man to do it — d'you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety's sake.[0] [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUqytjlHNIM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUqytjlHNIM
- mrtksn 9y agoHow this changes the fact that nobody cares? Uber is probably also a threat to the public(apparently the people who run Uber are not very nice, remember all the scandals?) but people are so fed up with the taxi industry that they welcoming Uber to "slaughter" their local cabbies. It's just business and that's why we don't live in a libertarian world and we have government bodies that regulate businesses.
- Agebor 9y ago> It just needs restraint and better web development with existing standard technologies, and ideally a strong taboo on bloated web-sites. Restraint can't appear out of nowhere, especially when bloating the website frequently works - more ad revenue, more information about existing visitors and potential new customers. These needs won't just disappear, so yes, the problem needs a technical solution.
- danieldk 9y agoRestraint can't appear out of nowhere, especially when bloating the website frequently works - more ad revenue, more information about existing visitors and potential new customers. Rather than pushing for AMP, Google, Bing, etc. could just penalize websites (more heavily) for size in search rankings.
- mrtksn 9y agoHow this solves anything for the user? The better way is to provide the tech(AMP) so that content that is good for the user can be delivered properly instead of not delivered due to performance. Remember, it's about providing a good experience to the users, it's not about choosing the losers and winners in the industry. The taxi companies are making the same mistake against Uber, they assume that the users are an exploitable resource and want a solution that distributes this resource more "fairly to the businesses". From Uber's perspective, the users are the clientele and the resources are the cars and the drivers. The web tech community is acting like the taxi drivers, angry that their user resource is being taken away.
- MaxBarraclough 9y ago> How this solves anything for the user? Is it not obvious? It would motivate major websites to clean up their act and sort out the bloat problem, with no need for yet another web technology.
- mrtksn 9y agoThat's a hypothesis that assumes that the major websites will get motivated until the users get frustrated by the low quality of search results. With AMP it's cheap and quick to implement, how long will it take for the websites to re-implement their codebase and all the tooling to match the performance criteria? Anyway, you're missing the point that I'm trying to make here: It's about the user's experience, it's not about the user's distribution to businesses. It's not your god given right to have users and make money.
- underwater 9y agoI work for a publisher that zero ads. We have fast pages with minimal JS. We rolled out AMP purely for the SEO win and saw a huge uptick in traffic. If Google really cared about performance they’d reward publishers doing the right thing on their regular pages (which would benefit the web as a whole), not just those using AMP.
- r3bl 9y agoYes, this is my exact same take on AMP. I understand their problem, I understand their solution. I have nothing against their solution. But I'm freaking out that there's absolutely no way for me to compete with websites that are trafficking everything through Google, even if I create a product that's speed-wise compatible with AMP pages.
- codedokode 9y agoI have JS disabled and websites are not that slow for me.
- Angostura 9y ago> Websites are so extremely slow these days. I must have extremely low standards, but I simply don't find this to be the case. A few, yes. The vast majority work fine.
- remir 9y agoI don't blame Google for AMP. The industry could have come together to offer a better experience and speedier page load, but of course they didn't and preferred having countless scripts and poorly optimized ads and that translated into a poor experience for users. This created an opportunity for Google to come in and offer this solution and now we're stuck.
- lucideer 9y agoTo the contrary, one of the most frustrating things for me about AMP is Google's contributions to "the slow web". They're not in any way the cause, not even a majority contributor, but look at Google's influence on frontend web development, from providing drop-in-with-zero-thought script CDN links, popularising the @font-face standard through their Web Fonts service to the point of its use being expected and non-optional in many web design teams, Google's terrible Page Speed tool favouring large complex pages over small simple ones, and the general cavalier "hey just paste this snippet of JS into your HTML, don't worry about what it does" attitude that things like GA have helped to make the norm.
- sureaboutthis 9y agoSlow web sites shoot themselves in the foot. They need not be slow. My company develops high performance web sites. We can beat any AMP site you can find and we do it without CDNs or Google-like networks. Like-minded thoughts: https://www.quirksmode.org/blog/archives/2018/02/linkbait_37.html https://www.quirksmode.org/blog/archives/2018/02/linkbait_37...
- lllr_finger 9y agoIt's not a technical problem at all, and it's not the developers being bad. If the top 1000ish sites can make millions a year from tacking on Outbrain, Taboola, etc. and the analytics to support those revenue streams, why do they care if the page speed is 3 seconds vs 500ms?
- sureaboutthis 9y agoThe faster the site, the longer a visitor stays and the more likely they are to purchase. Even Google acknowledges that as well as many other sites that study such things. Sites don't gain income by just displaying an ad in many cases. You have to have visitors click on them and, often, make an actual purchase.
- oldcynic 9y agoGoogle should be penalising the actual problem - page weight, not building their walled garden. So encouraging speed is ok to a point. Do they stop there and create AMP because Google is so invested in their ad ecosystem? Serious question, as it's hard not to feel cynical when the solution appears to avoid the actual problem. AMP seems a way of actively avoiding the issue. It's so far beyond ridiculous that a website downloads from 30 domains, and pulls down so much JS that you have more code than an entire 16 bit OS, GUI and game, just to see one text only page.
- ksk 9y agoIf they did that, then all websites with ads will be deprioritized, and it would be obvious (if it weren't already) that ads create a shitty experience. Google probably doesn't want to highlight that.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 9y agoAMP is a pub/sub agreement to host content masking as a 'protocol'. You're selling the feature of 'it's faster', but the POINT was 'Google hosts'.