3 ms·
That's not Let's Encrypt's role to play though. As a user, I'd be much more skeptical of an LE cert'd site than a Verisign cert'd site. That's not a knock on LE
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
That's not Let's Encrypt's role to play though. As a user, I'd be much more skeptical of an LE cert'd site than a Verisign cert'd site. That's not a knock on LE, that's just recognizing a higher barrier to entry. Let's Encrypt's goal is to get everyone encrypted, not necessarily to ensure everyone is who they say they are.
And as a fellow person who does real business at times, I often prefer paid products because I know I can get support from the company backing it. I don't think Let's Encrypt will replace the entire CA industry, and I don't think it should. (As tyingq says, monocultures are bad.)
- BrandoElFollito 9y ago> not necessarily to ensure everyone is who they say they are How does Verizon (to take your example) ensures this? They have the same zero verification process for the non-EV cert.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoAt bare minimum, getting a cert almost anywhere else requires a credit card.
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoThis is not something which helps to decide whether the target website is what they claim to be. I can use my CC to buy faccebook.com, and I will get it (again, outside of EV). I may then be tracked by Interpol for fraud, but to the end user this does not change anything: Verizon has issued a certificate for my faccebook.com
- ams6110 9y agoIYAM, any major web property such as google, facebook, credit card issuers, etc. should buy up all the most likely typo-ed versions of their domains so that this doesn't happen. The average user is going to blame Facebook anyway if they get duped into logging in at faccebook.com, and it goes to protecting their brand (trademarks are weakened if the owner doesn't defend them).
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoThey do, and if they don't, they end up like the White House a few years ago when whitehouse.<I forgot the TLD> was bought and an almost exact replica was created, according to Rule 34. My point is that you can buy any site from a CA and no verification is done, exactly as with Let's Encrypt. Even with an EV there is no guarantee that the requester is genuine ("best effort" to check)
- tialaramex 9y agoWith EV the checks basically care about: 1. Does this entity exist, e.g. it's in an official government business directory and the address details match what was specified 2. Use a third party directory (e.g. Dunn & Bradstreet) to look up this entity, and phone them. Ask to talk to some specific role at the company e.g. "Head of the IT department" and then confirm the details with that person. This involves actual humans, albeit basically call centre employees, looking at paperwork, making telephone calls, that sort of thing. I guess you could label it "best effort" but to me that signifies much less. For Americans a surprise problem with EV is that your country doesn't _have_ a central business directory. Each State runs its own directory, most businesses are registered in Delaware, regardless of their actual home state. https://stripe.ian.sh/ https://stripe.ian.sh/ has a completely genuine Stripe, Inc. EV certificate, issued to a Stripe, Inc. just not the one that's famous.
- kalleboo 9y agoI can get a prepaid VISA card at any convenience store
- acct1771 9y agoWith no billing address, though, right?
- tialaramex 9y agoSo, Verisign is an interesting example. Verisign sold their certificate business a long time ago to Symantec. Symantec had a contract with a Korean company "CrossCert" in which Symantec would issue certificates (including "Verisign" certificates) based on CrossCert's validation. We don't actually know what CrossCert's validation practices were, because during investigation of problematic certificates Symantec found that CrossCert wouldn't give them the paperwork they should have been keeping to track this work so that it could see what they'd done. It had never asked to see that paperwork previously (over years of the relationship) and had simply accepted a Korean auditor's finding that everything was fine without really inspecting anything itself or letting anybody know about this arrangement with CrossCert. Did you know about? When you see "Verisign" do you think "Or, you know, maybe some Korean company, but that's fine?" Never mind, this scandal eventually resulted in Symantec exiting the CA business late in 2017, and today "Verisign" certificates are issued by DigiCert, another company you've probably never heard of.