6 ms·
This reminds me of things like https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ and when
by userbinator 9y ago
This reminds me of things like https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ and when I was (briefly --- thankfully) involved in teaching CS courses a few years ago. More than half the class clearly hadn't actually passed the prerequisites. Lots of begging for leniency and remarking, some extremely emotional appeals. It's a difficult situation because if you let them through, it only creates problems further down the line; and if you don't, then everyone questions your teaching ability (but strangely enough, not the learning ability of the students, which most certainly has a huge effect on how well they do.) I chose the latter and don't regret it --- and left that industry before long, although not before accumulating a pretty negative reputation, because my class' grades would always be a strongly bimodal distribution with one of the peaks well below the failing point.
School district leaders, including Wilson, defend the use of makeup work, arguing they want to give students "multiple opportunities" to show they understand material.
Contrast this with the attitude of some more demanding professions like piloting an aircraft: "If you don't get it right the first time, it could be the end of your career, or even your life."
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> if you let them through, it only creates problems further down the line; and if you don't, then everyone questions your teaching ability (but strangely enough, not the learning ability of the students, which most certainly has a huge effect on how well they do.) American policy is dedicated to the principle that no two people differ in learning ability.
- throwaway5752 9y ago"American policy is dedicated to the principle that no two people differ in learning ability." That would benefit from a reliable citation.
- eadmund 9y agoOur government passed a bipartisan law, to great fanfare, entitled No Child Left Behind, which assumes that every child is capable of graduating … when of course that's complete nonsense.
- throwaway5752 9y ago"no two people differ in learning ability" != "every child is capable of graduating". Your reply is barely related to my request for citation. And it's not clear to why it's complete nonsense either. Do you have some sort of data about what the cognitive needs are to graduate secondary school, and what percentage of the population lacks them? Considering real world schools have varying grades and varying tracks of difficulty from remedial to advanced, it seems like they recognize a wide range in learning ability.
- anonytrary 9y agoOne-to-many (one teacher, 20 students) might superficially appear to be efficient, but one-to-one is where the real teaching happens. Mentors are highly underrated. Over the next 20 years, I suspect peer-to-peer mentoring will gain huge appeal, and the number of people going to college will decrease.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 9y agoNo, it's not. It's obviously not, as any parent knows.
- aidenn0 9y agoIt does have its weird quirks though. My daughter is in 4th grade. At the beginning of 2nd grade she was assessed at about 1.5 grade levels behind. She was just assessed again and is about 1.5 grade levels behind. We raised the possibility of holding her back a grade and were immediately told that was not an option. This was all very foreign to me since I was held back in elementary school, at my teacher's recommendation. It just seems to me that the amount of extra work they have put in to keep her advancing while in a classroom where most of the work is above her ability could be put to better use.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> American policy is dedicated to the principle that no two people differ in learning ability. No, its dedicated, depending on how cynically you view it, to either bringing up the performance of the lower-end of the distribution or to painting public schools as failing to support privatization. It is absolutely not dedicated to the principle that no two people differ in learning ability, and, in fact, rather directly addresses the existence of learning disabilities.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoIt is dedicated to bringing the performance of the lower end all the way up to the level of the higher end. This can't be done if you're willing to concede that the higher end might be able to learn faster. If an innovation in education improves outcomes by 3% for stupid students and 5% for smart students (you know... because they respond better to education), that's actually a bad thing from the conventional viewpoint, because "the gap" has widened instead of narrowing.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> It is dedicated to bringing the performance of the lower end all the way up to the level of the higher end. No, its not. (Though if it continues without change it will probably have the effect of narrowing that gap to near zero, but largely by bringing the higher end down through neglect rather than by bringing the lower end up to it.) > This can't be done if you're willing to concede that the higher end might be able to learn faster. Its quite possible if you acknowledge that but then consciously plan to neglect serving the upper end.
- DaiPlusPlus 9y agoI think you’re referring to the No Child Left Behind act - is that still relevant today? I was hoping that Obama’s education secretary rolled-back the worst parts of that.
- Alex3917 9y ago> Contrast this with the attitude of some more demanding professions like piloting an aircraft CS isn't a profession though, and AFAIK no one has ever died due to a CS mistake.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mattnewton 9y agoPeople have definitely died due to programming errors, if that is what you mean. The classic example that comes to mind is Therac-25[0] accidentally giving thousands of times the radiation dose. It’s a miracle these kinds of consequences aren’t more common, given how much code runs machinery and how undisciplined many engineering firms are. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25
- Alex3917 9y ago> People have definitely died due to programming errors, if that is what you mean. It wasn't.
- fao_ 9y agoPlease show me this mythical world where there is no confusion and no huge overlap between computer science and software engineering, a magical place where you can have one without the other, and where they have no bearing on each other. The two are as intertwined as they can be, you cannot perform software engineering without practicing some part of computer science, and you cannot perform computer science in truth, without practicing some part of software engineering. Anyway, in the case of Therac-25 it was a concurrency error, so in other words, both a CS mistake, and a programming mistake.
- Alex3917 9y agoWhile it may not be possible to have programming without CS, it's certainly possible to have CS without programming. And if you're going to school for CS, you're there to learn math, not software engineering. Many (most?) people who study CS have no intention of writing software or becoming developers.
- lsiebert 9y agoThis isn't working a profession, It's education. You are supposed to be able make mistakes. And you are supposed to get help to overcome those mistakes and learn. Some students need more support than others. If all these kids aren't doing well, it's not a failing of the kids, but of the people who should be helping the kids succeed, and the system that graduated them. A high income student who struggles with their grade gets tutors and help. A low income student who struggles is passed along without getting support to learn, allowed to fall further and further behind.
- nitwit005 9y agoIf students are missing multiple months of school, I doubt they're going to show up for a tutor. My university offered free tutoring, and nudged the struggling students toward it. Most of them never showed. Of course, many of them were skipping the normal classes, so not too much surprise in that case.
- rimliu 9y ago> If all these kids aren't doing well, it's not a failing of > the kids, but of the people who should be helping the kids > succeed, My favourite "how many" joke goes like this: "How many psychiatrists does it take to change a light bulb? One, but lightbulb need to want to change". And there is a saying: "one man can lead the horse to the water, but even forty cannot make it drink". The point being: yes, there are people who "should be helping", but the key word is "helping". The kid should put some effort too. I find that attitude that everyone around is to blame except the one in the middle quite dangerous. It teaches not to be responsible for your own actions (or inaction). We had a president a few years back, whose long lasting infamous contribution to the society was the catchphrase "I am not responsible, the environment is". He was impeached. Let's not raise more like him.
- noobermin 9y agoRight blame a student who had to work at a fastfood job in high school, they're not putting enough effort in life and don't deserve help. What you're describing certainly isn't represented by the article, what I read is there are students who society is already failing, and so no doubt they don't win by its rules.
- zerr 9y agoYou're missing one crucial thing: interest. Being interested and getting enjoyment out of learning is crucial. E.g. there are people who are good at math, but terrible at humanities subjects, or vice versa.
- Larrikin 9y agoHighly specialized interest classes are for graduate school, after you've shown an ability to take in information from a variety of domains.
- timthorn 9y agoThat's not the university model everywhere. In the UK, for instance, deep specialisms start at 16, and university undergrad courses all focus on your area of interest or directly relevant subjects.
- DaiPlusPlus 9y agoThat’s a very callous attitude, and an incorrect one, I believe. Not everyone has the same ability to learn about different subjects equally - even amongst groups with the same intellignece levels. It sounds like you’re arguing that one’s entire future career, even in post-secondary and undergraduate level, is decided entirely by their grade-average across all their subjects. This will disqualify many talented individuals from studying (and consequently working in) areas that strongly interest them simply for having an inability to adequately perform in completely unrelated areas. How is that a meritocracy? Take myself, for example: I have ASD, I have “special interests” and my brain is incredibly stubborn and demotivated to do anything outside certain narrow interest areas. I did exceptionally well in my UK A-Level electives (maths/physics/compsci, etc, getting mostly top grades) compared to my GCSEs that we’re far more broader (English Lit, Biology, Chemistry, Theology, etc) where I got mostly B-grades. After getting my degree I landed a job at a high-profile software company in the US, launching me into a career and a very high tax bracket. Hopefully this means my net societal impact is positive. But under your proposal, my hardwired unwillingness to memorise Shakespeare and compare Dickens with Steinbeck should condemn me to never entering academia to study what I enjoy.