3 ms·
From the HN title I thought "fantastic, that's a brilliant idea", but I honestly can't imagine anyone I know using what you're building. If I wanted a remote s
by jdietrich 16y ago
From the HN title I thought "fantastic, that's a brilliant idea", but I honestly can't imagine anyone I know using what you're building.
If I wanted a remote session player to do some overdubs on a track, I'd FTP over a rough mixdown or use Indaba. Dependency management is a really difficult task given the amount of proprietary software and hardware in use - the people likely to pay you money for this sort of thing are unlikely to be using many free plugins. If you've got a regular collaborator then you can sort out a common toolset, but that rather nullifies the point of dependency management. Ableton Share works acceptably well, but only because it's deeply integrated with Live. Image-Line dropped collaboration because they considered it more hassle than it's worth. If you reckon that it'll be less hassle for you or that you can extract more value then I wish you the best of luck, but I certainly don't see how.
The project I'm working on at the moment runs to 1.6GB and that's just a 4 minute pop song. A full day of recording a band can easily produce 30GB worth of data and that's at low bit rates. The good DAWs manage alternative takes rather well, certainly well enough that I'd be loath to tie up my broadband for two days after every session for version control.
To take you on your own mission statement, I have absolutely no idea how your product would make me better at making music, help me waste less time with my computer or make it more convenient to collaborate. Maybe I'm totally atypical, but I don't think so.
You want my opinion? Discard everything but collaboration and focus on Reason. It's a closed box, so no dependency problems. It doesn't do audio recording, so no massive files. It can natively bundle project samples into its file format, keeping things simple for the user. I don't like Reason, I don't like people who do like Reason, but it appears to be the only thing that'll do what you're looking to do without a long list of caveats and ballaches.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jamesbkel 16y agoAs a side note, one of the most significant updates included in Reason 5, which was released this past week, was the addition of live recording of samples directly into Reason devices and a more complete integration with Record, Propellerhead's audio recording package.
- AndyKelley 16y agoYou've identified one of the limitations of this service: it requires the musician to think about file size when creating a project. I agree that it is a serious flaw, but I do not think it is a show-stopper. I generated 10 minutes of white noise and saved it as 320kbps mp3 and quality 10 ogg. The file size of each is 22.9 MB and 18.1 MB, respectively. Let's say we have a 10 minute long song (that's really long) with 4 layers, and you end up re-recording everything twice from start to finish. 20 MB * 4 * 3 = 240 MB for the entire project. That means in the Lite plan you get 42 songs. Sounds pretty reasonable to me. The obvious argument is that as a musician, you want completely lossless compression. I say that quality 10 OGG is good enough, although if you simply cannot accept that, I understand. Also, I have plans for creating a program that runs in the background of your computer and does all the dirty work for you.
- jdietrich 16y agoI think you may be badly underestimating the track count of a lot of projects. If you aren't banking on having access to all the project plugins at the other end, then any track that is generated or processed by a plugin that isn't part of the factory set will need to be frozen to audio. Obviously there will be no alternates for these tracks, but they still add up. If you're recording live audio, then think of a number, add your age and double it. I would typically mic up a drum kit with between eight and fourteen microphones, depending on the size of the kit and the quality of the room. That is by no means excessive - a bargain-basement set of drum mics will usually consist of seven or eight mics. An electric guitar should get at least three tracks - two mics on the cab and one for DI. A decent pop vocal sound usually demands several tracks for the lead, plus backing. To give you an idea, Greg Kurstin used in excess of 70 tracks on most of the songs on Lily Allen's "It's Not Me, It's You" - an album recorded with only one singer, one microphone and two real instruments. Lossy compression is absolutely unacceptable for work-in-progress files. The point of this exercise is to allow project files to be bounced back and forth between collaborators relatively seamlessly. Introduce lossy compression and you have to worry about generational loss - if the guy at the other end edits the file then it goes through the codec again and before long you've got a photocopy of a photocopy of a photocopy. All the major DAWs can import MP3s, but those that I'm familiar with need to decode them back to WAV/AIFF to handle them internally. This would demand something reasonably clever on the client-side to prevent all sorts of difficulties when an edited song is re-exported and uploaded back, because even without any edits the decode-encode cycle would mean that an exported track would diff with the originally imported version. It also takes bloody ages to bounce every track in a project to MP3, although that could be simplified somewhat if your planned client tool handled it. Also a 10 minute song isn't really long - it's long for a pop or rock single, but by no means unusual for a 12 inch mix in a lot of dance music genres. Seven minutes is about average for House these days.
- greendestiny 16y agoI was underwhelmed after reading the title as well. Good version control software for audio on my PC would be great. However while this might not be great for close collaborators, it would be very good for remix competitions and less structured collaborations. There is a bunch of sites devoted to these sorts of things, and this would have a huge advantage over them.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]