6 ms·
The AMP brand is only toxic on HN, among iOS users who don't know any better. The article itself perpetuates a common mistaken belief among iOS users — that AMP
by lern_too_spel 9y ago
The AMP brand is only toxic on HN, among iOS users who don't know any better. The article itself perpetuates a common mistaken belief among iOS users — that AMP implements its own scrolling. The problem stems from the root source of all of the author's listed problems — that AMP uses iframes. Mobile Safari had a bug where iframe scrolling is different from scrolling in the rest of the system. On every Android browser, it works just fine.
Similarly, that Mobile Safari's reader mode doesn't work with AMP is simply because it doesn't understand iframes and doesn't work on canonical URLs, unlike every other reader mode (both websites like outline.com and browsers like Firefox) I have used.
The real issue is that Safari is such a buggy, rarely updated browser that publishers have to choose between speed or UX.
- JoshMnem 9y ago> among iOS users The main arguments against AMP have nothing to do with iOS or Safari. I don't have any Apple devices. Also, how is that the top comment just a minute after being posted on a site where most people don't like AMP?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Also, how is that the top comment just a minute after being posted on a site where most people don't like AMP? I think that it's quite possible that there is a false impression the proportion of the HN community that dislikes AMP just because the people that do dislike it have intense need to wave that around, while the people that don't dislike it aren't rushing out to post their "eh, it doesn't really bother me." Or even to question the attacks, as that often fails to produce any kind of substantive response.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dfabulich 9y ago(Author here.) I think the AMP brand is toxic roughly everywhere. Many users don't know what AMP is, and don't really care—in fact, there's some evidence that users like AMP in search results, or at least they like the performance—but as far as I can see in tech communities like HN and Reddit, the vast majority of people who know what AMP is also know that they hate AMP. (Scroll up and down on this thread a bit!) As for why it's toxic, I don't think we have to agree about that, but it's not just the UI problem. The URL problem (AMP URLs point to google.com instead of the original site) is a real, significant problem in its own right. The URL problem is the root of the claim that "AMP is Google's attempt to take over the open web." IMO, if it were just an iOS scrolling issue, AMP would just be controversial: love the speed, hate the scrolling, eh, it's a wash. But the URL problem is what really gets the flamethrowers running!
- lern_too_spel 9y agoSaying that the URL problem is Google's attempt at taking over the open web is nonsensical. Google's main competitors in large markets, like Microsoft, Yahoo Japan, and Baidu, also implement AMP caches. How does that help any of them fend off any of the others? Each one of them gets to prerender the same provably prerender-friendly pages. I am not an AMP publisher or an AMP developer, but I vastly prefer AMP results, and I suspect my preference lines up with the majority outside of HN, or why else would all these search engines do this?
- tomc1985 9y ago> why else would all these search engines do this? if it expands the business in a positive way who cares what users think, right?
- dfabulich 9y ago> Saying that the URL problem is Google's attempt at taking over the open web is nonsensical. The point isn't that only Google can use AMP. (I agree that many people incorrectly think that AMP is Google-only.) The point is that with AMP, you've lost control of your web site. The fact that you've lost control not only to Google, but also to Microsoft, Yahoo Japan, and Baidu doesn't help at all!
- dmitrygr 9y ago> The point is that with AMP, you've lost control of your web site. Did I miss the news article "Armed googlers rampaging wildly and threatening all website owners with violence for noncompliance with AMP guidelines"? Who forces you to use amp?
- donohoe 9y agoWe are forced by the prominent AMP carousel that shows up in search results that drives meaningful revenue to publishers (but cannibalizes our traffic to the regular page where on a CPM level ads are worth more). If they removed that then AMP would die quickly.
- underwater 9y agoThe AMP brand is toxic because it’s a blatant example of Google trying to fork the web and take control of the new standard. It wasn’t done in collaboration with the community and outreach has been sloppy. I attended the AMP roadshow and the devs come across as condescending as hell and clearly have no interest in hearing about what the community wants. It was a poorly disguised sales pitch filled with unscientific cases studies. AMP has some good ideas, but Google can’t be trusted with the future of the web.
- htk 9y agoNo, the real issue is that the iPhone is so widely used that Google should do a better job at making AMP work without breaking a bunch of things. Or at least have the option to disable it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vernie 9y agoOh gee I wonder why AMP works fine on Android and not iOS.
- baddox 9y agoThis iOS thing is news to me. I’ve always had a great experience with AMP on iPhone Safari. No scroll problems at all.
- comex 9y agoThe scrolling issue is fixed as of iOS 11, which got rid of the inconsistency in scrolling physics between iframes and full pages. See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14386292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14386292
- baddox 9y agoOh, nice. I don’t remember having problems before iOS 11, but I don’t really encounter AMP links all that often anyway.
- monochromatic 9y agoNo, AMP is garbage in design and in execution.
- Angostura 9y agoIt’s toxic among anyone who try to copy and paste links from address bars