4 ms·
I am so interested in the modern car for it's sensor suite... but so uninterested for it's cloud features. My hope is, when I next buy a car, that I can still d
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
I am so interested in the modern car for it's sensor suite... but so uninterested for it's cloud features. My hope is, when I next buy a car, that I can still disable the manufacturer's network connection, even if I have to go under the hood or behind the dashboard to do it.
- gruez 9y ago>the manufacturer's network connection is that actually a thing for cars without a subscription? i'd imagine they forgo the monthly cost of a data connection (that they're not getting paid for), and download any data off the car when you take it in for servicing instead.
- __blockcipher__ 9y agoLet's take Tesla as an example. Not representative, but still. They are constantly connected and log __everything__. They own the data, and they will happily use it against you if it serves them (ie, you die in an "autopilot"-related car crash, they pull your location data and show that you were leaving from a bar at 2:00 AM). Since it's not encrypted to a device key that only you own, like how iOS devices work, Tesla is also forced to hand over your data to federal authorities as soon as they get subpoenaed. It scares me a lot, frankly. I don't have enough money to buy a Tesla either way, but I don't think I could pull the trigger knowing what their data policy is like. Of course, with the way automated license plate readers are going, you'll probably be location tracked even with a "dumb" car, but at least the data would be more fragmented.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoYeah, paying six figures to buy a car that's been built to rat me out if it serves the corporate interest is not what I'd call a good investment. They've also threatened to sue someone for interfacing with the software of their own car, vindictively banned a journalist from buying their cars due to a negative blog post, and the only place you can even see a Tesla repair manual is in a state that legally requires it... and Tesla charges $30 an hour for the privilege. They hinge heavily on how evil laws are requiring third party dealerships, while being a case-in-point example of why third party dealerships protect consumers from an overbearing mothership.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThey can turn a nice profit off the data. Also, consider that a car manufacturer can get a very sweet bulk deal on the network connections. Let's say it only downloads say, map directions and uploads metadata it collects. (The car can presumably get software updates and map downloads when it has Wi-Fi, or insist the user pair their phone and use it's data for the big stuff.) The data usage can be easily measured, and it's very restricted. The carrier can safely offer that line at pennies on the dollar, because they know nobody's gonna thrash their network trying to stream in 4K over it. Verizon definitely sells bulk service to companies for their connected devices, and they definitely don't pay as much per line as you or I do. If these connections are such low traffic and don't have significant performance needs, carriers can even sell them as 3G only, for example, and use older, less critical network resources to handle them.
- Slansitartop 9y ago>> the manufacturer's network connection > is that actually a thing for cars without a subscription? Subarus have them. As far as I could tell, all of their cars came with a modem, and all you had to do to enable it was call the dealer and subscribe to their "connected car" service. No installation or shop appointment required, that means the modem's there and always in communication to something. It's also pretty well known that all Tesla's have a cellular modem which they used to pull updates (and probably send back telemetry), and I don't think there's an associated subscription fee.
- rosser 9y agoThis will almost certainly be a warranty-voiding action, if it isn't made straight-up illegal.
- Slansitartop 9y agoThat might be less of an issue for a car, though, given they have useful lives far beyond their warranties. I'm not even sure how the warranty for the rest of the car would be affected if you replaced the head unit with a 3rd party one or clipped an LTE antenna.
- jacquesm 9y agoA fieldstrength meter and some wire snips should do the job.
- olympus 9y agoI worry that they will somehow tie the functionality of the sensors to an internet connection somehow. I wonder how hard it will be to write an entire car firmware from scratch.