5 ms·
Obviously all diets have to be LIMO - Less In, More Out. But the question is how you get there. Eating vegetables and whole foods without worrying about count
by btilly 9y ago
Obviously all diets have to be LIMO - Less In, More Out. But the question is how you get there.
Eating vegetables and whole foods without worrying about counting calories or limiting portion sizes doesn't feel like effort. You don't WANT to eat more. And your body becomes happier about burning fat rather than demanding that you eat.
Counting calories explicitly is a lot of work and a lot of self control. Few people can succeed at that.
Personally I follow the former strategy using http://www.weightgrapher.com/ http://www.weightgrapher.com/ to keep myself honest. About 15 years ago I decided to lose 20 pounds, and kept it off for close to a decade. Then I let my weight get away from me, because life got complicated. This time around I've decided to get back to that weight again, and I know it is sustainable. I'm not aiming for fast weight loss, I've been going at a comfortable pace for 3 months and expect to be dieting another 6 months to reach my target. But I know that I'll be able to get there and stay for years without a lot of willpower. Partly luck of genetics/gut biome. Partly because I'm doing it in a mentally easy way.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cies 9y ago> Obviously all diets have to be LIMO Diets designed to "cut" (loose weight), yes. Some people want to gain weight, their regimens are also called diets.
- msla 9y agoIf you want to be technical, any habitual pattern of eating is a diet. But technicalities don't define words, usage and context do, and, for the vast majority of people, including people here, diet means a change in your habitual pattern of eating designed to induce weight loss. That's how it's universally understood in this context. Being more technical does not mean being more correct.
- dwc 9y ago"Universally understood" shouldn't be true for this. I've known a number of people who were on diets to gain weight for medical or self image reasons, and it's known still known as a diet.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoYes, but we already knew in which context btilly was writing, so I'm not sure being pedantic is justified.
- zoul 9y agoObviously all diets have to be LIMO - Less In, More Out. Do they? What exactly does it mean? I had the impression that eating a lot of calories doesn’t mean keeping them – that it depends on what source they come from (fats/proteins/carbs).
- LargeWu 9y agoA calorie is a measure of engery. The laws of physics say that if you consumer fewer calories than you burn, you will lose weight, because your body needs fuel to operate. Now, your body might try to compensate and change metabolism in response to this, so that you unwittingly burn fewer calories than you consume. And yes, the types of food you're eating can affect this. But ultimately, our bodies are not perpetual motion machines, and cannot expend more energy than they take in as fuel, over the long term.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoThis has been a long-standing theme in this forum (HN). I've participated myself. Of course the arguments to physics are true. But they are largely irrelevant. Its not the truth that's going to help people. People eat too much, not because they don't know better (and physics! will teach them), but because they have some behavioral issue that prevents them from doing the good actions repeatedly. It always ends up here: "Just don't put the calories in your mouth. That's all you need to do." Which would be true, if food and eating were entirely volitional. But its an emotional need, a very fundamental one. Imagine saying "Just put the gun to your head and pull the trigger. That's all you need to do." While its undeniably easy, most of us, because of emotional needs to survive and avoid pain, would find it very, very hard to accomplish. (Not saying a gun-to-the-head loses weight; just comparing an easy instruction with the accompanying difficulty in performing it).
- LargeWu 9y agoOh, yeah, I totally understand that it's not useful diet advice. I have a desire to lose a few pounds, but that doesn't stop me from having a beer every night as I'm making dinner, or grabbing a piece of candy a couple of times a day while at work.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIn my (totally amateur) perception, there are three different ways to be "hungry". First is hungry for calories (blood sugar may be involved here). Second is hungry for nutrients (cravings may be at least somewhat caused by this). And third is hungry for volume - your stomach physically is empty. Eating vegetables and whole foods helps with the second and third, and somewhat with the first. By not eating highly processed foods, your blood sugar doesn't spike and then crash. (I think of it as the difference between using coal and jet fuel to make a fire.)