3 ms·
>Dr. Gardner said it is not that calories don’t matter. After all, both groups ultimately ended up consuming fewer calories on average by the end of the study,
by nabla9 9y ago
>Dr. Gardner said it is not that calories don’t matter. After all, both groups ultimately ended up consuming fewer calories on average by the end of the study, even though they weren’t conscious of it. The point is that they did this by focusing on nutritious whole foods that satisfied their hunger.
Of course calories matter. The weight loss problem is twofold:
1. Calories. Counting calories is solution to this. You can lose weight by eating junk food if you count calories.
2. Feeling hungry and self discipline problems. Quality and composition of the food and different ways of consuming food affects how easy it is to consume less calories in the long term.
- windexh8er 9y agoAt the end of the road calorie count doesn't matter as much as the precedence placed, quality of calories does. A calorie in a sugar packet isn't remotely the same value as a calorie of broccoli. The focus on count in this conversation is missing the point. And until someone goes down the path of trying a whole foods based shift in their diet long term I fully believe that is lost on people, unfortunately.
- RealityVoid 9y ago> A calorie in a sugar packet isn't remotely the same value as a calorie of broccoli. Caloric-wise it sure is. The difference is in the ability to eat the same amount of calories in sugar and not eating more.
- windexh8er 9y agoIt isn't in the context of nutrition. That was my point which I failed to convey. The failure in the discussion is that calorie count matters in the grand scheme. But if the focus was nutritional value per calorie that measurement falls apart much more quickly.
- Sohcahtoa82 9y agoI'm having a hard time interpreting your comment. It sounds like you're trying to argue against Dr. Gardner even though you agree with him. He's specifically not disputing the fact that calories matter.