4 ms·
> The Model S is more like a 5 series E Class in quality, strange that it gets slotted with cars solely on price The last Model S I drove in was more like a Ca
by FireBeyond 9y ago
> The Model S is more like a 5 series E Class in quality, strange that it gets slotted with cars solely on price
The last Model S I drove in was more like a Camry on some of the interior detailing.
Push down on the dash of a Tesla, listen to the creaking of flexing plastic. Do the same in a mid/high range Audi/MB/BMW.
Look at the gaps in trim detail on the door liner.
Give the center console a wiggle.
It's not -bad-, but it's not as polished, high quality, as some would like to believe.
- BoorishBears 9y agoI was being very forgiving and including size in that comparison. I couldn’t stomach paying S Class money for the thing and went with a Volt, which is at least priced to match its trim (And it was a lot better than I expected when well optioned)
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoYep and I bet 90% of the time you don't go beyond the battery range and drive it like it's an electric anyways. Having a huge 60kwh battery is great and all, but if I only use it 10% of the time, why would I want to pay another $10k for it? Better to just use gas occasionally. Love my Volt.
- greglindahl 9y agoYou might note that Bolt sells better than the Volt -- a surprise to me, but in general plug-in hybrids just aren't that popular with the car-buying public.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoOnly in the US. In Canada the Volt continued to outsell the Bolt all year. Then again, with supply limited it's hard to make any kind of analysis. But they're confusing to people and also GM doesn't market either of these cars.
- greglindahl 9y agoGM gets valuable EV credits for selling Volt/Bolt in California and all of the other US states in the club. Not surprisingly, they stock and market both cars more in those states. I don't think Canada has an EV sales requirement yet.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoQuebec does. Ontario has a high subsidy. To their credit, GM sells in all the provinces regardless. Once QC enacted California-style minimums, Ford stopped selling EVs in other provinces and allocated their inventory only to QC. That's a pretty dick move.
- greglindahl 9y agoYeah, it was similar in the US, in the sense that GM released Bolt first in California, then the other states with the EV requirement, and then at the end released them in other states at the same price. That last part was a pleasant surprise, because apparently GM loses money on every Bolt, and loses even more money when they sell Bolts in states without the EV requirement.
- interfixus 9y agoInterior decoration is a somewhat strange criterion to apply in the choice between contemporary technology and dinosaur ditto.
- blattimwind 9y agoYou're looking at gaps and clearances not necessarily because you don't want your car to continually insult your eyes, but rather to gauge the manufacturers ability to build things. If a car manufacturer can't get something as simple(1) as the clearance of doors right, how in the world would you trust them to get any of the more critical aspects right?! (1) Actually a hugely refined and seriously complex process involving dozens of companies which have been doing this for decades, at least for the German ones.
- erikpukinskis 9y ago> If a car manufacturer can't get something as simple(1) as the clearance of doors right, how in the world would you trust them to get any of the more critical aspects right?! I can imagine lots of cars: One where the insides are junk, but they put all their effort into making the surface of the interior perfect One where the interior is total crap, but they obsessed over the drivetrain until everything purred like a kitten One where the whole thing is junk One where every detail was obsessed over. ... which of these categories are you saying doesn't exist? Both of the first two?
- FireBeyond 9y agoWhen you consider that the primary difference is ICE vs Electric, that's about where your "dinosaur" analogy ends. All of those vehicles have similar technology to the Tesla, if not more: road sign comprehension, active steering, driving assistance (autonomy), side collision avoidance, auto parking, online maps. And when your market segmentation is "high end", "luxury" as it is here, why _wouldn't_ interior decoration, quality and features be considered?
- threeseed 9y ago100% of the time spend driving is inside the car. Hence it is very important that manufacturers focus on the in car experience more so than exterior. And in this respect Tesla is pathetic. There really isn't a better word to describe how Tesla can offer cheap-Korean interior quality at the prices they do.