7 ms·
I have no idea why the Model S sales numbers are being compared to cars like the 7 series by laypeople too. Even from a layman’s perspective... have these peop
by BoorishBears 9y ago
I have no idea why the Model S sales numbers are being compared to cars like the 7 series by laypeople too.
Even from a layman’s perspective... have these people driven a 7 series? They’re more quiet highway cruising than the Model S I test drove... until you feel like making them noisy, then you can floor it and hear a V12 roar to life... if that’s your thing.
The Model S is more like a 5 series E Class in quality, strange that it gets slotted with cars solely on price
- wodenokoto 9y ago> The Model S is more like a 5 series E Class in quality, strange that it gets slotted with cars solely on price No, that is not strange at all.
- cowsandmilk 9y ago> No, that is not strange at all. It is less quality that makes it strange than dimensions of the vehicles. Tesla is not the length of an S Class or 7 series. It is the length of an E Class or 5 series. 5 series, E Class, Model S are ~ 195 inches long 7 series and S Class are ~206 inches long.
- Retric 9y agoNo wireless. Less space than a Nomad. Lame. Price is a far more significant from of differentiation than random specs. The average person buying a Honda Civic can't afford a Model S, but the average person buying a Model S can afford to buy an S Class. People talk about market segments because they are meaningfully different. That said, taxes, maintenance, and fuel differences do make a Model S cheaper to own and operate. So they arguably have significantly different prices.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoThey have significantly different prices to produce, as well. The all-electric drivetrain costs less than an AMG supercharged V12. The BMW and the Mercedes have the same costs, so you can directly compare then, but the Model S does not. I think what we're both saying is that the big gas-engine luxury car segment is different from whatever new segment the Tesla Model S has created. But the point is that the new segment is taking buyers from the old.
- Retric 9y agoI don't know. Battery costs are currently massive, so Model S might cost more to manufacture. R&D and advertising also make the direct profit comparisons tricky. Have you seen a good direct comparison?
- FireBeyond 9y ago> The Model S is more like a 5 series E Class in quality, strange that it gets slotted with cars solely on price The last Model S I drove in was more like a Camry on some of the interior detailing. Push down on the dash of a Tesla, listen to the creaking of flexing plastic. Do the same in a mid/high range Audi/MB/BMW. Look at the gaps in trim detail on the door liner. Give the center console a wiggle. It's not -bad-, but it's not as polished, high quality, as some would like to believe.
- BoorishBears 9y agoI was being very forgiving and including size in that comparison. I couldn’t stomach paying S Class money for the thing and went with a Volt, which is at least priced to match its trim (And it was a lot better than I expected when well optioned)
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoYep and I bet 90% of the time you don't go beyond the battery range and drive it like it's an electric anyways. Having a huge 60kwh battery is great and all, but if I only use it 10% of the time, why would I want to pay another $10k for it? Better to just use gas occasionally. Love my Volt.
- greglindahl 9y agoYou might note that Bolt sells better than the Volt -- a surprise to me, but in general plug-in hybrids just aren't that popular with the car-buying public.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoOnly in the US. In Canada the Volt continued to outsell the Bolt all year. Then again, with supply limited it's hard to make any kind of analysis. But they're confusing to people and also GM doesn't market either of these cars.
- nilkn 9y agoFirst of all, I completely agree that the E class is more on par with the Model S, and the S class is significantly more luxurious. With that said, I do think it's interesting that the Model S has S class pricing and is outselling the S class despite being decidedly much less luxurious. I'd say many people spending upwards of $85k-$100k+ on a car don't just want luxury -- they want social status. And right now a brand new upgraded Model S is more attention-grabbing than a Mercedes S class.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt's mostly a tax issue. The operating costs of a Tesla can be much lower because of very favorable tax breaks, which is one of the main reasons the Tesla sold so well in Norway and The Netherlands (my home country), and why so many of them are fleet (lease) vehicles. Taxis alone account for a substantial fraction of all those sales. We'll see if that trend continues in 2018, there have been some substantial changes in the taxes regarding electrical cars in NL, not sure about Norway.
- nilkn 9y agoI didn't fully appreciate the significance of that point at first but now I think I do. It appears that in Norway in particular a Model S can be significantly cheaper than a 7 series or S class.
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoMost definitely in Norway, Model S is significantly cheaper than E-class or 5-series, too.
- 013a 9y agoReally, Price is the only thing you can compare. If you want complete luxury: S-Class, A7/A8, or 7-Series are going to be decidedly better in every way, at a similar price bracket. To be honest, Tesla doesn't even compete in this category. If you want the status symbol: Maybe Tesla is the best. You'd also probably be cross-shopping a Panamera or maybe an XJ. If you want performance: The best will be an E63S, RS5 (kind of a different category), or M5. A P100D is stupidly fast off the line, but most enthusiasts don't put it in the same class as high-end german performance cars due to driving dynamics and the price. It gets an honorable mention. If you want tech: Tesla, Audi, or the Cadillac CT6. Tesla wins on automated driving, but Cadillac isn't far behind at all. Audi has some of that, but their interior tech is easily on-par with Tesla when you option it out. If you want all of them: You'll need to go upmarket. The RS7 would qualify, especially the refreshed 2019 model, but really you'll have to enter "optioned out Porsche" territory ($150k+) and even then you'll make sacrifices in the tech department. There are a few generalities you can make, though: First, BMW isn't as competitive as they used to be. MB and Audi have recently started outpacing them in most categories. Second, Tesla definitely isn't competitive at its price bracket without tax incentives, unless all you care about is how other people perceive you, which can't really be quantified like the other categories.
- greglindahl 9y agoIf you talk to Tesla owners, you'll find that their thing is flooring it and NOT making a roar.
- BoorishBears 9y agoFlooring any car from 0 to 60 in 3.6 seconds will be loud. The ludicrous mode launch we did wasn’t silent either. What they really appreciate on a day to day basis is quiet cruising, yet the 7 series out does it in that department.
- greglindahl 9y agoI was actually referring to starts from stop signs and stop lights where you don't get near to 60mph. Also, tire noise (poorly damped from inside a Tesla, admittedly) is quite different from engine roar (damped or not.) From talking to other Tesla owners, I'm expressing a fairly common sentiment.
- BoorishBears 9y agoFor normal starts the 7 series is quieter than the Model S for total noise so I didn’t think it was worth bringing up.
- greglindahl 9y agoI'm mainly concerned with people outside the car. Also, breakthrough noise is completely different from tire noise, which is why it's called "breakthrough noise". Did you not notice that I said "roar"? Do tires "roar" when they aren't skidding? No. ICE's "roar". I'm totally OK with you having different preferences from me. I've met other people who think like you do, and we've had fine conversations about our personal preferences. But you're pretty much ignoring what I have to say, replacing it with your favorite preferences.
- BoorishBears 9y ago
- jordache 9y agothey being compared because they fall into a similar price range. 100K for a Model S, is higher than the vast majority of 5s and E klasse
- reaperducer 9y ago> then you can floor it and hear a V12 roar to life For realsies? Or is it just a soundtrack? https://www.caranddriver.com/features/faking-it-engine-sound-enhancement-explained-tech-dept https://www.caranddriver.com/features/faking-it-engine-sound...
- BoorishBears 9y agoThe article confuses two things, fake noises generated by speakers, and real noises tuned/directed into specific parts of the cabin. A 7 series might be insulated enough that the models that come with V6 and V8s need some artificial help, but the V12 is loud enough that any generated sounds are just overkill, it’s a very throaty engine... if you want it to be
- vinay427 9y agoThe article doesn't seem to confuse them. It literally explains the approaches used on the models they covered.
- BoorishBears 9y agoWhen I say the article I’m specifically referring to the title and some language at the start. It starts off like it’s talking about fake sounds, then goes into differentiating. The comment the person linking made sounds like they were slightly mislead by that.
- jacquesm 9y agoAccording to your link it is the actual engine but played over the stereo. As if the car doesn't have windows :) I can totally see how this will eventually play out the way you describe it though, and worse, maybe they'll end up putting speakers on the outside as well.
- vinay427 9y agoHonestly, it feels more like an A4 or 3-series in quality based on US trims of these cars. It certainly wasn't more luxurious than a C-class.
- reaperducer 9y agoI'm a little more forgiving than most on HN. I'm sure that the cars that BMW cranked out in its third year of production weren't the same as today's BMW's, either. When Tesla's been doing this for a decade, then I'll hold their feet a little closer to the fire. For right now, it's a company learning how to build cars; and from that perspective, it seems to be doing a pretty good job.
- dtparr 9y agoI can certainly understand the challenges that a new entrant in a field like car manufacturing faces, and I agree that Tesla has generally done a good job. However, for a general consumer who isn't buying a product to support the mission/company/tech or whatever you want to call it, it's less clear why they would care about that. If <legacy manufacturer> and Tesla both produce cars for $X, it's not unreasonable to do a direct comparison, certainly including reliability, QA, etc. when deciding who earns that $X. Also Tesla has, in fact, been producing vehicles for a decade: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Roadster_(2008) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Roadster_(2008) If you prefer not to count the Roadster as they used the Lotus gliders, the Model S has been out for 6 years as of this summer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Model_S https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Model_S
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoIt’s being compared to cars in the same size class. Typically people who are buying the Model S would have bought a 7 series or S class, not a 5 or an E. it’s a very expensive car. Similarly Model 3 should be compared to BMW 3 series and Mercedes E class as those are the products a different consumer might be choosing between. It’s not really meaningful to compare sales between cars with dramatically different pricing because the price obviously affects demand. Tesla does not have many of the “luxuries” that BMW has, but it has other benefits like better technology and 0 emissions. The news is that faced with that choice, many consumers are choosing Tesla over a 7 series and it’s quiet cabin.