3 ms·
Disclaimer: I'm not at all familiar with Rieman, but I'll weigh in despite my ignorance :-P > The complacency of seeing progress solely in economic and scienti
by MaxBarraclough 9y ago
Disclaimer: I'm not at all familiar with Rieman, but I'll weigh in despite my ignorance :-P
> The complacency of seeing progress solely in economic and scientific terms
Well, his emphasis has been on rates of human violence. That's a pretty salient thing to study, no? Is your issue with his specific choice of quantitative metric, or the use of a quantitative metric in the first place?
> leaves the gate open for our basest natures to dominate.
If I recall correctly, Pinker touches on that in Better Angels of Our Nature's discussion of utopian political ideologies, such as Nazism, communism, and jihadism, which can justify enormous and perfectly avoidable human tragedies in the name of "it will all be worth it".
He's also fairly explicit that we shouldn't be complacent about the possibilities of such human tragedies.
> Such progress seems to have no predictive power for what we as a civilisation might sink to next.
Pinker's point is very much one of "there are no guarantees, but things are generally getting better". The purpose of his book was to (quite rightly) push back against the widespread misconception that the problem of human violence has only been getting worse.