4 ms·
Last Week at Wellesley
- greenyoda 9y agoBest quote: "A number of students came up to me to say they had really had their minds opened by realizing what they’re told about someone might not at all be true." I thought that this was something that people generally learned long before they got to college. (The student protest against the author was inspired by fake social media accounts that impersonated her on Facebook and Twitter, not by things that she had actually ever said.)
- jonnybgood 9y ago> I thought that this was something that people generally learned long before they got to college. I believe it's confirmation bias in this case.
- brlewis 9y agoThis is something that people generally need to relearn many times. Believing what we're told is the path of least resistance.
- tptacek 9y agoI do not come close, to even 1% of understanding all the backstory and subtext behind this post, but 4 minutes of Googling strongly indicates that there is a _lot_ of it, and it goes quickly into the weedy intricacies of gender science --- something this author is authoritative on, but clearly not exclusively authoritative on, since she's apparently controversial among practitioners in her field --- and which virtually nobody on this site is qualified to remark on and thus, as a basis for a discussion, seems pretty far outside the remit of Hacker News.
- jseliger 9y agoseems pretty far outside the remit of Hacker News There seem to be some pretty severe information viruses or epistemology problems in the wider culture, or at least the wider Internet culture, and examples of those pop up periodically. These issues have existed for a long time, and it's worth reiterating the utility of wondering what you can't say: http://paulgraham.com/say.html http://paulgraham.com/say.html . I'd also argue that at least 95% of students are fine, but the small minority who tend to make the news may not be: https://jakeseliger.com/2017/04/24/ninety-five-percent-of-people-are-fine-but-its-that-last-five-percent https://jakeseliger.com/2017/04/24/ninety-five-percent-of-pe... . It's too easy to lose track of the majority.
- tptacek 9y agoI would not feel comfortable, based on the very limited research I've done, drawing any conclusions --- one way or the other --- from this post. There's a lot going on here.
- darawk 9y agoDid you read the post? It is only incidentally related to feminism / gender studies. It's about the propagation of falsehoods on the internet, campus politics, and social activism. Those topics are well within "Hacker News's remit", whatever that means.
- tptacek 9y agoYes. Also, if you'll take a minute to re-read the HN guidelines linked at the bottom of the page: "did you read the post" is one of just a small handful of arguments you're explicitly not supposed to make on this site.
- darawk 9y agoI'll restate it then: The content of the article is in direct contradiction to the implication of your comment. How do you reconcile that?
- tptacek 9y agoI don't believe that it is, sorry. I think you're making assumptions that the entire controversy about the author's appearance is detailed in this blog post.
- haberman 9y agoI think the story here is that the protesting students clearly didn't understand even 1% of the backstory either. They didn't come to the protest with a deep and sophisticated understanding of Alice Dreger's positions and history. Rather the protest was fueled by an inflammatory quote posted by a fake social media account under her name. Then the students blamed their confusion on her for not policing social media. If you are against HN users commenting on Alice Dreger's story because we don't have the background, what do you have to say about 100 students from one of the country's top liberal arts colleges who showed up to a protest without even verifying basic facts about what they were protesting?
- tptacek 9y agoWhat makes you so sure they didn't?
- haberman 9y ago> Earlier in the day, in a class co-taught by the Freedom Project’s Director, Tom Cushman, a student had read aloud to me something I supposedly have said about transgender people. It was so comically bigoted, it was hard to take seriously. But apparently someone somewhere said I said this, and this “quote” from me was being transmitted in an email around campus, the one calling for the protest of me. The email organizing the protest was based on a false narrative, and the students who were receiving it were apparently unaware of this.
- tptacek 9y agoWhy do you assume that one bit of false narrative was what organized the students? Dreger has said a lot of controversial stuff.
- haberman 9y agoBecause it was literally in the email that called for the protest. An email that was circulating around campus prior to the protest. Because some of the protesters came forth to say that they had been misled about her: > A number of students came up to me to say they had really had their minds opened by realizing what they’re told about someone might not at all be true. This thread is a perfect example of why modern leftist criticisms ring so hollow. If this is such a complicated issue that HN readers are not qualified to even discuss it, why are you suddenly so inclined to give these students a pass that their protest was well-informed, despite strong evidence to the contrary?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI recognized the name because she also made the news for live tweeting her opinions when she went to her son's abstinence only sex ed class at school. https://mashable.com/2015/04/16/alice-dreger-sex-education/#rATp.73kjGqj https://mashable.com/2015/04/16/alice-dreger-sex-education/#... I posit that part of why she is so controversial is because she is a woman. One of my comments today has a dead reply to it characterizing it as redpill garbage. My assumption is that the individual who said that thinks I am a guy with a lot of emotional baggage surrounding dating and what not. I did not specify that I am female, something I fairly often do just to try to avoid weird accusations based on exactly that type of assumption. Women are not expected to have the kinds of opinions about human sexuality that she has or that I have. We are seriously not supposed to express them in public. Given how controversial she is, I am pleasantly surprised by her diplomatic handling of the situation. My assumption is that she is younger than I am. I was a lot more controversial when I was younger. My opinions have not changed. My ability to express them less provocatively is the only real difference. I intentionally kept a low public profile for a long time. I don't like drama. This has actively undermined my ability to establish a real career. Perhaps the groundwork I have laid will allow me to eventually make sufficient money without the kind of drama she is facing, but it has come at a cost of putting off having a public life. So perhaps the primary reason she is so controversial is she went ahead and pursued a career while still in the prime of her life. I don't regret the choices I have made. But I also don't want to see it be some standard expectation that women can't speak in public until they have mastered doing so inoffensively or something. That sounds like a career killing double standard to me.