4 ms·
It's unfortunate that this article provides an analysis and critique of the roots of left-leaning "social justice" but absolutely zero analysis or critique of t
by pmoriarty 9y ago
It's unfortunate that this article provides an analysis and critique of the roots of left-leaning "social justice" but absolutely zero analysis or critique of the roots of right-leaning conservatism or libertarianism.
The latter have a long history of their own victimization rhetoric, which they use for political ends, and an adherence to many conspiracy theories. Neither is even indirectly alluded to, much less analyzed or critiqued despite being directly relevant to the views expressed in the article.
- Beamer92 9y agoRight but... was anybody unaware of that? There's plenty out there critiquing right-leaning beliefs that we didn't really need another. I think it was plenty fair in that it just presented a critical analysis of one side without necessarily supporting the other. You don't need to be fair to every side of an argument to point out a flaw. I mostly got that there's parallels to draw between the idea of breaking down existing power structures while ignoring how you have to build new ones in their place. Instead of seeing a lack of critique of a side I already believe to be flawed, I see themes to be considered when I tell myself I've got the right of it. Another way of seeing it: when attempting to knock someone else off their high horse, you don't need to be reassured that they deserved to be knocked off of their horse to be reminded not to climb up on your own afterwards.
- barrkel 9y agoThat's a red herring, what we'd call whataboutery in my home country.
- greglindahl 9y agoA red herring and whataboutism are two different things! A red herring seeks to tie someone's statement to Communism, and then dismiss it. For example, some people criticizing the GPL do that. This is whataboutism.
- Jtsummers 9y ago“Red herring” has nothing to do with communism. The expression greatly predates the idea (as a cohesive political philosophy) of communism. Red herrings are distractions and misdirections to pull you away from the intended topic or discussion.
- greglindahl 9y agoHey, look at that! I mostly see literal Red herrings. But even though it pre-dates Marx, it's still not the same as whataboutism. (Edit: In case anyone misunderstands, I'm agreeing that even though I'm a native English speaker, the phrase "red herring" predates Marxism by a bunch of years, so my statement above was incorrect. From the downvotes I'm getting, apparently I wasn't initially clear about agreeing that I was incorrect.)
- Jtsummers 9y ago> A red herring seeks to tie someone's statement to Communism, and then dismiss it. Your original description of "red herring" was clearly erroneous, I was trying to correct that for anyone who isn't a native English speaker. No point in misleading them with red herrings about communists when the phrase has nothing to do with it.
- greglindahl 9y agoUm, congratulations? Is repeating yourself an important part of fixing my error? Did my second statement, which agreed that I was wrong, mislead anyone?
- Jtsummers 9y agoI misread the intent and tone of your reply. Sorry. I deal with a lot of people in person who use a lot of rhetorical tricks and logical fallacies to perpetuate various false (and easily falsifiable, if they considered science valid) beliefs. So I've developed a low tolerance for misstatements like what I originally responded to and interpreted your reply to me as sarcastic rather than an honest reaction. Apologies for misinterpreting.
- arkades 9y agoJohn Oliver has a nice bit about whataboutism - that thing you’re engaging in. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RS82JNd0YzQ https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RS82JNd0YzQ
- Slansitartop 9y ago> It's unfortunate that this article provides an analysis and critique of the roots of left-leaning "social justice" but absolutely zero analysis or critique of the roots of right-leaning conservatism or libertarianism. Why would an article about social justice ideology do that? It would be rightly viewed as a digression that should be edited out or turned into an independent article.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Why would an article about social justice ideology do that?" Because it provides context for the very conservative complaints the article provides a platform for.
- Slansitartop 9y agoBut what you were asking for wasn't context, it was: > analysis or critique of the roots of right-leaning conservatism or libertarianism That's a full article in itself. Basically, it seems you are unhappy about the article's topic and focus, and wish an article about something else that's more tailored to your predilections. I'm sure you can find want you want elsewhere, given the current political climate and the fact that conservatism and libertarianism are far older and have been widespread for far longer than the relatively novel "social justice ideology" discussed here.
- ThrowawayR2 9y ago> * Because it provides context for the very conservative complaints the article provides a platform for.* "Conservative complaints"? I am a classical liberal and I find many of the concerns in the article to be valid, as do many other classical liberals.