8 ms·
The Trouble with HomePod Reviews
- majormajor 9y agoFor me the biggest problems with the HomePod are that (a) for the same price you can have a stereo pair of Sonos Ones and (b) I haven't found a surround sound or center channel story for the HomePod a la Sonos soundbar/base station + Sonos Ones. Going from point source to multiple sources makes a very substantial difference. I'm very curious about just how much DSP magic the HomePod is doing (as opposed to what's physical enclosure magic), since in playing with my Sonoses I can't spot a huge effect from their TruePlay tuning in most configurations I've tried out. It's there, but minor sounding for most typical arrangements - perhaps it would be greater if I tried more and more sub-optimal placements, but trying to sabotage my setup isn't my ultimate goal. ;) If Apple let the DSP be shut off so it could be measured that would be interesting from a technical perspective, but should it actually affect the reviews? If anything, the HomePod makes reviews better if now reviewers are actively aware that they should think about what it'll sound like in the user's room vs in an ideal layout.
- threeseed 9y ago1. The quality is better than a pair of Sonos One. 2. AirPlay2 will support multiple units. 3. All of the magic behind the HomePod is in the software. Otherwise it is just a bunch of tweeters in a circular shape and a woofer. It's the software that determines what each tweeter is going to output and the strength of the woofer output. 4. The reviews I've read have been careful about not just testing the HomePod in ideal conditions. Since the ability to "just work" in non ideal conditions is what the entire device is designed for. Anyway all of this is moot. Sound quality is important but more so this is an ecosystem play. HomePod reinforces investments in HomeKit and iOS.
- majormajor 9y agoI've seen as many reviews contradicting your first point as supporting it. Distributed source vs point source - the Sonos's have a huge advantage out of the gate in terms of ambience and imaging, and adding additional units helps with volume and quality as well. I've seen a lot of talk about stereo AirPlay but not about surround. What would you use as the center channel, another homepod? That would look awkward, though sound fine. The enclosure has always been a huge part of speaker design. The software side, ever since the computing power got cheap enough to enable stuff like Audyssey, has been a newer but not unheard-of part. Apple would be fools if they didn't optimize the physical design of the speaker as much as the software side. Ecosystem lock in only works if you have a reason for me to buy a HomePod to use with my iPad instead of a Sonos in the first place. Sonos+Alexa+iPad works perfectly fine for me, so...
- anfilt 9y agoI will tell you the problem with it. It's 350 dollars, and at the point you are getting into the entry price for a pair of studio monitors. The thing has 7 tweeters and only one woofer to cover the mids and bass. So you are not going to get a good left or right channel. Instead the left and right will be mixed into one woofer, and the reduced by probably 3 db to appear at the same volume. This is no good for music.
- pmilla1606 9y agoInteresting to hear you say this in light of all (at least all that I've read) very positive reviews of the sound quality. What are your thoughts on the positive reviews?
- SyneRyder 9y agoSome of the reviews have been mixed. The Screen Savers tried a blind sound test of several devices, and there wasn't a clear winner, everyone had different favorites (which is probably not what you'd expect from Apple's marketing, I personally had expected an obvious improvement over competitors). Jumping straight to the results in the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QqGvmf44FEk&t=7m04s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QqGvmf44FEk&t=7m04s
- bitmapbrother 9y agoThe Screen Savers aren't the only one to have done a blind sound test where the HomePod lost to the Google Home Max. Yahoo's David Pogue[1] and the Washington Post[2] also did blind sound tests. [1]https://finance.yahoo.com/news/head-head-apple-homepod-really-sound-best-160346138.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/head-head-apple-homepod-reall... [2]https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2018/02/09/five-things-to-know-before-you-buy-an-apple-homepod/?utm_term=.b4d728a02484 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2018/02/09...
- anfilt 9y agoYou can also just buy single monitor, and it will sounds good. However, you will loose the difference between the right and left audio channels especially if you mix the two channels into one. I am saying for the money you could get a pair of monitors that give you both left and right audio channels and sounds good. If your playing music, but not really setting up a listening environment why buy a 350 dollar speaker. Let alone one that downmixes stero to mono channel.
- gnicholas 9y agoI would love to buy a pair, but until they can be used with video, I'm staying on the sidelines. Customers report noticeable audio delay that makes them unsuitable for usage with videos. I watch TV (via laptop or laptop-to-TV) in every room where I would consider buying a HomePod. I'm not going to drop hundreds of dollars on a speaker for music if it can't also be used with video.
- jzoch 9y agoAirplay 1 currently has a built in delay of 2 seconds (its an old protocol). Airplay 2 will be released later this year and will fix this problem. For video it will not be suitable unless you use an apple tv which automatically corrects teh latency.
- gnicholas 9y agoThen on the sidelines I shall remain...unless perhaps Airfoil comes up with an ingenious solution to this predicament! But given the ratings and relative price of the Sonos—and their current compatibility with both audio and video, from what my friends tell me—maybe I'll spring for a pair of Ones.
- scarface74 9y agoI agree it is a problem that it doesn't work with most video. But it does work with video streamed from AppleTV.
- headsoup 9y agoI think the biggest problem is that suddenly, testing and environment and tech etc is of immense concern when reviewing these speakers, where all the many product reviews before were taken at face value (by those likely complaining now). It's a consumer speaker, so why all of a sudden are people demanding full audiophile/studio precision in speaker testing and reviewing? I love how Apple's product messaging gets people debating the flaws evident in the review and experiences of their product categories because Apple has introduced terminology to people that they a) never cared about previously (though already existing) and b) don't likely understand or appreciably recognise going forward otherwise. Apple are very good at making people suddenly aware of important things they had no idea about, would not recognise/understand, or cared for previously...
- brokenmachine 9y agoIt's because their marketing is cramming the word "audiophile" in every sentence. Also it's $350, so should logically be compared to speakers that cost $350.
- headsoup 9y agoYeah exactly my point. People are now going to start arguing that the reviews are not 'audiophile' enough, even though the audiophile field has far more specific focus than what most people can appreciate considering hearing ability, genre interests, environment, past experiences and technical understanding. Basically Apple's formula: take something from an 'enthusiast' level of a product. Build a reasonable quality thing around that, slap on a 'upper consumer/lower enthusiast' price on it and market it as the 'the coolest thing of these ever made' and... You get all the mostly regular consumers suddenly arguing in the between space: they are better than all the other regular consumers but too cool to be an enthusiast nerd. GG Apple.
- brokenmachine 9y agoLol, spot on.
- 9y ago
- rb808 9y agoI'm thinking of getting one. I have a nice stereo in the room but my wife would rather use the crappy $20 Alexa puck because its easier just for 10 minutes of music. Drives me nuts. At least with a HomePod I wont have to listen to tinny tunes.
- brokenmachine 9y agoWhy not spend your $350 on a device that can hook into the nice stereo in the room that is easy for the wife to use? Then you get even better sound with probably less money outlay. One of those programmable universal remotes might help as well? So it's one button to get to tunes.
- rb808 9y agoIts the thing with these devices are always on and hands free. There is a big difference between a voice command and one button. To me I'd push the button every time, but to others these devices are preferred.
- brokenmachine 9y agoVoice-controlled programmable remote? Do those exist? A cheap Android phone plugged into the speakers? You can "OK google" that.
- shoobedowop 9y agoHomePod works, requires no maintenance, and sounds great. No one has time to dick around with custom one off solutions that require rebooting, tweaking, and is less reliable except single guys who want to spend half the time fixing something vs. using it. a wife has no time nor tolerance for half ass home baked tech.
- rb808 9y ago> a wife has no time nor tolerance for half ass home baked tech. Lol, another experienced married man on hn! :)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tty7 9y agoi hired a kid to play sitar after me and the wife get up. its amazingly soothing, i couldnt imagine using something like this to relax.