4 ms·

Show HN: Spendbook, a web app to track your expenses

10 points by S4M 9y ago

The website is: https://www.spendbook.net/main https://www.spendbook.net/main I am posting this on behalf of a friend who built it so he can get a feedback - he doesn't have an account and when he created one his post was killed.

fiatjaf 9y ago
You should post the link directly and write these comments as comments.
lozzo 9y ago
my feedback: there is not enough explanation on how you would access my finances and hence I would be very wary on using it...
- tendencydriven 9y ago
  from a cursory glance I believe that you add the transactions, it doesn't automatically access your bank accounts, etc
  - skk78 9y ago
    Yes, you are right. It doesn't access bank accounts or card details.
- skk78 9y ago
  Hi, Thanks for your feedback. I built the site. I agree with you on lack of explanation. Once you login, you can add transactions (by clicking "Add Transactions" Link) and then you can view your finance summary by clicking "View Summary" page. I'll be adding more explanation on how to use in coming days. Please keep visiting the site. Thanks.
xori 9y ago
Good start, overall pretty vanilla. There's a lot of competition in this area so I'd suggest being a little more opinionated. - Privacy Policy, what are you doing with my data, how do you protect it. Something more than just saying we use a HTTPS Certificate - It's really weird to have to create budgets for each month, and not just have a recurring monthly/weekly budget - When viewing transactions default to reasonable views, not just today. Maybe provide some views (last week, last month) - Initially the Add Transaction confused me, there's a lot of fields with no help text as to what each affects. I got over this, but that area definitely needs some optimization.
- skk78 9y ago
  Hi, Thank you for your feedback. I appreciate your comments. I built the site. - I fully agree with you on having privacy policy. I am working on that, should be on the site soon. - Regarding new budget creation, at the moment, editing existing one and saving with new name will create new one with existing details. Yes, It is good to make it recurring automatically. I thought about it before. It is definitely on my list in upcoming updates. - I agree with you on having some customisation option for setting default time period on transaction view page. It is on my list as well. - For your last point, I agree site is lacking in help on how to use it. I will try to add help in appropriate places. Thanks.

10 points by S4M 9y ago

fiatjaf 9y ago

You should post the link directly and write these comments as comments.

lozzo 9y ago

my feedback: there is not enough explanation on how you would access my finances and hence I would be very wary on using it...

tendencydriven 9y ago
from a cursory glance I believe that you add the transactions, it doesn't automatically access your bank accounts, etc
- skk78 9y ago
  Yes, you are right. It doesn't access bank accounts or card details.
skk78 9y ago
Hi, Thanks for your feedback. I built the site. I agree with you on lack of explanation. Once you login, you can add transactions (by clicking "Add Transactions" Link) and then you can view your finance summary by clicking "View Summary" page. I'll be adding more explanation on how to use in coming days. Please keep visiting the site. Thanks.

xori 9y ago

Good start, overall pretty vanilla. There's a lot of competition in this area so I'd suggest being a little more opinionated. - Privacy Policy, what are you doing with my data, how do you protect it. Something more than just saying we use a HTTPS Certificate - It's really weird to have to create budgets for each month, and not just have a recurring monthly/weekly budget - When viewing transactions default to reasonable views, not just today. Maybe provide some views (last week, last month) - Initially the Add Transaction confused me, there's a lot of fields with no help text as to what each affects. I got over this, but that area definitely needs some optimization.

skk78 9y ago
Hi, Thank you for your feedback. I appreciate your comments. I built the site. - I fully agree with you on having privacy policy. I am working on that, should be on the site soon. - Regarding new budget creation, at the moment, editing existing one and saving with new name will create new one with existing details. Yes, It is good to make it recurring automatically. I thought about it before. It is definitely on my list in upcoming updates. - I agree with you on having some customisation option for setting default time period on transaction view page. It is on my list as well. - For your last point, I agree site is lacking in help on how to use it. I will try to add help in appropriate places. Thanks.