5 ms·
This, and similar research I'd seen before seems to point to women being equal or better at STEM than men (and also being better at non-STEM stuff), but activel
by ZeroGravitas 9y ago
This, and similar research I'd seen before seems to point to women being equal or better at STEM than men (and also being better at non-STEM stuff), but actively avoiding it as a low-status role when they have better options.
Slightly baffling to see this celebrated by men in these careers as some kind of vindication.
The data appears to be saying you (we) suck, but that's a win if you think the data was going to show that one gender sucked (and you ignore that you secretly thought it was them).
- mesozoic 9y agoI think men celebrate it in the hope that this may trigger a culture change where they don't have to be seen as less desirables or inherently sexist members of the patriarchy.
- shostrift 9y agoNah, a lot of guys are just weak and will do anything if they think it'll get chicks to like them. It's all good saying you're a male feminist until you realise girls don't want a pussy as a boyfriend. If you want to get a girl hot, act like a man.
- gonvaled 9y agoBeing good and being capable are different things: I am very capable of cleaning toilets, but I am not very good at it since I do not do it with a passion. Edit: and I obviously do not imply with my tongue in cheek joke that women are the ones cleaning toilets. Just going the extra mile here to avoid offending anybody.
- shostrift 9y agoYou joke, but women are the nest-makers biologically. You can see it in their typical enjoyment of shopping (which many guys aren't bothered about), and typically higher desire for cleanliness. Both these behaviours are beneficial from a survival perspective.
- taneq 9y ago> This, and similar research I'd seen before seems to point to women being equal or better at STEM than men (and also being better at non-STEM stuff) What I find onerous is that it's perfectly acceptable to make blanket statements about women being better at things than men, while it's now literally a sackable offense at many major tech companies to even imply the opposite. This doesn't seem like "progress towards equality" to me.
- rullelito 9y agoVariations of this has been growing for a long while. You can't be proud to be man or white; and you shouldn't be proud of success if you belong to that group. Unless your success is something that has benefited someone not in that group.
- draw_down 9y agoGood grief.
- Hextinium 9y agoI said that women usually have a lower understanding of mechanics than men do in conversation and the other person looked at me shocked like I had just killed a puppy. I then said that very often dad's will teach their sons how to mechanically work on things as a basis for this conclusion and they where understanding of that, but not my original point. I find it frustrating that I can't make a statement without first explaining the examples too.
- ionised 9y agoYou find it frustrating that you have to back up your statements?
- dwaltrip 9y agoThe way I see it, society is kind of like a person. When an individual is going through a difficult time, it's normal and considerate to be sensitive to that. Society is currently going through a difficult period of transformation regarding its perspective on women. During this time, sensitivity is much appreciated. It might be frustrating in some cases, but viewing society as a person makes this more understandable, at least for me. One easy way to have done this is by starting with your explanation before saying the thing that could be perceived poorly in the current context. In the future, when this current period has mostly ended, it may be easier to speak more frankly on formerly sensitive topics.
- lliamander 9y ago> Slightly baffling to see this celebrated by men in these careers as some kind of vindication. An amusing and insightful observation. I would say it's baffling until you realize that the alternative is that the whole the gap in female STEM employment continues to be attributed solely to male sexism. It's better to be perceived as stupid than evil. Also, are we all now in agreement that there are likely cognitive differences between men and women, and that it is beneficial to explore those differences scientifically? Honest question. edit: missing word
- rimliu 9y ago> are we all now in agreement that there are likely > cognitive differences between men and women Alas, far from it I am afraid. Which is very puzzling. Not many will argue that men and women have different physiology, different physical build. But god forbid from making the assumption that cognitive interests may also differ.
- shostrift 9y agoNot sure why you're down voted. You just need to read The Guardian and other liberal press to read how illiberal and intolerant many active feminists are.
- palunon 9y agoDo you have relevant scientific literature to back that claim ?
- pas 9y agohttp://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exaggerated-differences/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exagger...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoI thought the three alternatives were "women are bad at it", "women don't enjoy it", "women are being actively put off it by the men being even more sexist than the sexism baseline of men in other career options". If this is claiming they're actually better skilled than the men, then it opens up more space for the comparative sexism option I would have thought? Just the fact that it contradicts the common wisdom that "women aren't capable of STEM" seems to lend some support to sexism clouding people's objective evaluations.
- psyc 9y agoPerhaps they are celebrating the possibility that certain people will ease up on the angle that we're all complicit in perpetuating a culture of misogyny and harassment that drives women out of tech.
- tanilama 9y agoThis article simply means when equal opportunity is offered, there are still fewer women choose to take STEM as their career. Vindictive? No really. The research seems to suggest woman prefers STEM more, when there is no other viable economic opportunity, which makes such choice a conscious calculation, and do render the past accusation that there is an systematic oppression in the society to keep women away from taking the initiative, groundless. This at least speaks some volume, the current diversity program is incapable to achieve its own goal, thus further enforcing such agenda might not be fruitful.
- guitarbill 9y ago> the current diversity program is incapable to achieve its own goal What exactly is the goal of this "diversity program"? Maybe they are completely capable of achieving their goal, it's just not the one you think it is. (This is the curse of technical people: when you spend so much time thinking and solving problems rationally, it's easy to assume all situations can be approached in this way.)
- mamon 9y agoMost diversity programs state 50/50 man/women ratio as their goal, which, according to the article is counterproductive.
- guitarbill 9y agoCounterproductive for what? Individual happiness? Yeah, maybe. But that's not the only possibility. 50/50 is the "goal", but what's the motivation? Let's assume that we're talking increase in people, i.e. you want more women in STEM/tech/whatever, not simply less men (for some reason this option is rarely mentioned. You could fire enough men to get to 50/50, mathematically that's equally valid). Say I wanted more qualified employees without paying more - I can't think of a better to achieve this. Of course, I have no evidence for this and it's super paranoid, but it's just one example how the goal might still make sense.
- 9y ago
- guitarbill 9y ago> actively avoiding it as a low-status role when they have better options. So why don't men avoid it? It's hardly a high-status role for them, either. I hope my kids don't go into tech, regardless of gender. The most cynical part of me thinks that this "equality" agenda isn't put forward to further humanity, but simply to get more people into the job market and drive wages down. Then I realise I should probably lay off the drugs, or become a lobbyist (or worse).
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoTo be clear, this is the research I'm paraphrasing, but they seem to be suggesting that the men have the STEM skills to compare with women, but they don't have the non-STEM skills to compete as well in something like Law or Medicine or whatever. So they have a comparitive advantage, not an absolute advantage in STEM fields. (I also just replied to someone else to point out that "putting more people into STEM" could be considered good for the human race. I personally think that more people should be allowed into Medicine for example, because there's some monopolies there that are driving costs up. Probably feels like an attack if you're a highly paid doctor though).
- mpweiher 9y ago> Slightly baffling to see this celebrated by men in these careers as some kind of vindication. How is it baffling when the dominant narrative is "men in STEM are such horrid creepy sexist misogynists that they are driving the women out"? Now that was always risible, but still it is the dominant narrative.
- nukeop 9y agoBeing a highly paid professional in an extremely intellectual field is a "low-status role"? Where? I'm fine with it if that's what you're telling yourself to cope with why you in particular were unable to enter the field, though.
- gaius 9y agoBeing a highly paid professional in an extremely intellectual field is a "low-status role"? Where? Let’s not pretend that cranking out CRUD apps is in any way intellectual, outside of Silly Valley the pay is nothing special and “geek” is synonymous with “total loser”.
- nukeop 9y agoSo bitter! Should have stayed in school.
- ac29 9y ago>This, and similar research I'd seen before seems to point to women being equal or better at STEM than men I'm not sure that was the conclusion of the research: "But when it comes to their relative strengths, in almost all the countries—all except Romania and Lebanon—boys’ best subject was science, and girls’ was reading. (That is, even if an average girl was as good as an average boy at science, she was still likely to be even better at reading.) Across all countries, 24 percent of girls had science as their best subject, 25 percent of girls’ strength was math, and 51 percent excelled in reading. For boys, the percentages were 38 for science, 42 for math, and 20 for reading." That being said, you could also read this as boys are so much worse than girls at verbal skills that by default, their best subject was science or math.